Page 1 of 1

Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Mon Nov 02, 2015 5:04 pm
by Kimber45
Anyone know the current rule(s) on this?

I always thought stealing signals was considered unsportsmanlike conduct, but like faking injuries (*cough* Cal *cough*), it's one of those things that will virtually never be called on the field.

I ask because during the ASU/Oregon game the broadcasters stated that Coach Graham had basically admitted that he actively tries to steal the opposing teams signals.

I suspect there are also rules governing coaching conduct promulgated by the PAC-12/NCAA. Like canons of ethics, etc.

Is stealing the opposing teams signal consistent with the current rules regarding sportsmanship? I hope that it is not. And that Larry Scott's office might be looking into this issue.

Sorry if already discussed, I searched a little and didn't find anything.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Mon Nov 02, 2015 5:29 pm
by karlhungis
If the announcers and Graham are to be trusted, then no, it is not against the rules.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Mon Nov 02, 2015 6:05 pm
by Kimber45
If they said that on the air I must have missed it.

Had a look at NCAA football rule book and it doesn't seem to expressly address stealing signals. Faking injury, though, is declared unsportsmanlike, so there's that.

The NCAA rules do incorporate the American Football Coaches Association Code of Ethics which is, unfortunately, behind a membership wall on the AFCA site.

Hard to believe that stealing signals is within the 'fair play' concept laid out in the NCAA rules. Curious what the AFCA ethics rules might say.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Mon Nov 02, 2015 6:19 pm
by karlhungis
Kimber45 wrote:If they said that on the air I must have missed it.

Had a look at NCAA football rule book and it doesn't seem to expressly address stealing signals. Faking injury, though, is declared unsportsmanlike, so there's that.

The NCAA rules do incorporate the American Football Coaches Association Code of Ethics which is, unfortunately, behind a membership wall on the AFCA site.

Hard to believe that stealing signals is within the 'fair play' concept laid out in the NCAA rules. Curious what the AFCA ethics rules might say.
Yeah, they said that Graham was asked about stealing signals and he said that it is within the rules.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Mon Nov 02, 2015 6:39 pm
by greenyellow
Stealing signs is not against the rules but it does make for a sleazy coach, which is what I consider Graham.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Mon Nov 02, 2015 7:02 pm
by Kimber45
greenyellow wrote:Stealing signs is not against the rules but it does make for a sleazy coach, which is what I consider Graham.
Bugging the opposing teams locker room and flying a drone over their practices isn't addressed in the NCAA rule book either. But both of those obviously go against the integrity of the game.

Just seems wrong that stealing signals is allowed as part of the game. Shame really.

"Sleazy" pretty much sums it up.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Mon Nov 02, 2015 8:06 pm
by Duck07
greenyellow wrote:Stealing signs is not against the rules but it does make for a sleazy coach, which is what I consider Graham.
that's absurd to equate stealing signs to being sleazy, especially when there is nothing about it that's wrong. what if players pick up an audible call in a game and make an adjustment, is that not stealing a sign?

if someone can figure out what were doing its on the coaches to change it, not whine about it. that's for people like saban

Sent from my KFASWI using Forum Fiend v1.3.3.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Mon Nov 02, 2015 8:31 pm
by FlDuckFan
Stealing signals is part of the game, just like when a QB calls an audible at the line of scrimmage. If the defense figures it out all well. That's why you have dummy signals , and multiple people signaling things in. That's a risk you run when signaling things in, we want the advantage of not getting into a huddle well one of the disadvantages is the opportunity it gives the defense of decoding it.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Mon Nov 02, 2015 10:20 pm
by gogreen55
As much as I would like to pile on Coach Graham, who is an absolute a-hole, I don't have a big issue in this case. If during a baseball game teams notice that the opposing team always attempts to steal a base when the third base coach touches his nose, they would be foolish not to pitch out each time they see him touch his nose. Regardless of the sport, it is quite simply up to the team giving the signals to make them complex enough that they can't be stolen.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2015 9:01 am
by Bud Lee
Yeah, stealing signals is not that big of a deal to me. It is a part of the game on every level. My high school team would change our audible calls every quarter to keep the opposing team from catching on. If you are going to rely heavily on signals then you run the risk of losing the tactful advantage if the other team notices a trend.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2015 6:31 pm
by Kimber45
Completely agree with players on the field using keys to time a snap or deciphering an audible to predict the next play. Totally part of the game.

Just have an issue with the coaching staffs, and probably other resources located in the stadium, actively trying to identify the other team's play before they run it.

The former is the players looking at their opponent prior to the snap for clues; the latter is the players looking to the sideline for an intelligence report before the snap.

Obviously I'm on the wrong side of the issue. I just don't see how stealing signal doesn't detract from the integrity of the game.

Also, have no particular hard on for ASU or Coach Graham. Was just struck that a PAC-12 coach could/would so openly admit stealing signals is part of their game plan.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2015 8:13 pm
by fpsduck
I don't see it as an issue.

Chip always used those big play cards with 4 pictures for everyone to see. Just because the defense thinks they know the play doesn't mean that they can stop it.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2015 8:38 pm
by Duck24
People taking issue with this are just looking to get upset. Although, I don't understand why college football doesn't move to what the NFL has with a coach being able to communicate directly with the QB via speaker in the helmet. Then again, there are many things I don't understand when it comes to the NCAA.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 9:44 am
by Bud Lee
fpsduck wrote:I don't see it as an issue.

Chip always used those big play cards with 4 pictures for everyone to see. Just because the defense thinks they know the play doesn't mean that they can stop it.

If you are deceptive enough you can even trick the opponent up by making them think you are singling something that you are not. I think Chip said once that those cards are only giving the play half of the time and the other half they are using signals or just calling them in.

I just see this as a simple fix, if you don't want the other team figuring out your calls don't use them and if you do use them understand that is the risk you run.

I did think that the sheets at the ASU game was comical though. Made me wonder if the ball coach is a little paranoid or is he messing with ASU's coaching staff.

Re: Stealing the Opposing Team's Signals

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2015 10:22 am
by gofightingducks
I see no issue with it, Graham admits it and doesn't try to hide it, its gamesmanship.