Page 1 of 4
What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 9:50 am
by StevensTechU
Seems like nearly every thread quickly turns into a conversation about a handful of topics, so how about a thread specifically about one of those topics. What say you -- What's wrong with the defense?
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 10:58 am
by Duck24
Would it be a cop out to say everything except for Buckner?
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 11:02 am
by dthomas=ddixon
Duck24 wrote:Would it be a cop out to say everything except for Buckner?
Mondeaux has been pretty great as well, just not on the level of Buck obviously.
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 11:09 am
by Alan
It seems like the D has struggled ever since the O has started to be one of the best in the country. My two cents, the Ducks need to be more aggressive, get rid of the 3-4 and go to a 4-3. We had/have great D lineman who get stuck making pile ups on the line or take the double team and hope the linebackers can make the play. Also this will shock some of you guys...... I think it's time to fire DP and bring in fresh blood, don't hire within.
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 11:14 am
by Duck24
dthomas=ddixon wrote:Duck24 wrote:Would it be a cop out to say everything except for Buckner?
Mondeaux has been pretty great as well, just not on the level of Buck obviously.
Very true. Maybe we just say everything except for the DL. The games where we have actually let them rush the passer and not just be space eaters, they have definitely made their impact be felt.
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 11:22 am
by UOducksTK1
The LB play has been very disappointing. Coleman has had some nice games, and French/Prevot sometimes show flashes, but as a group with a lot of talent and experience, you think they'd be the closest thing to the anchor of the defense. DL and DB (with Nelson at safety and Tyree at CB) have performed close to what I've expected. But with the exception of Hardrick, I was expecting big things from Walker, French, Prevot, and Coleman. And I was hoping to see some big time growth in Swain and Mattingly. We are in November and I've see little good from our LB group.
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 12:21 pm
by mdm0302
Alan wrote:It seems like the D has struggled ever since the O has started to be one of the best in the country. My two cents, the Ducks need to be more aggressive, get rid of the 3-4 and go to a 4-3. We had/have great D lineman who get stuck making pile ups on the line or take the double team and hope the linebackers can make the play. Also this will shock some of you guys...... I think it's time to fire DP and bring in fresh blood, don't hire within.
Agreed. Dline play has always been better than out LB play. it makes no sense to put 4 backers on the field when they are constantly the weakest unit. We need to hire a DC who wants the Dline to be the heart of the defense.
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 12:24 pm
by vagusnerve
LB development has been sad.
Mattingly, Swain, Ragin?
None of the young guys play much. The juniors and seniors are not very good.
LB has been an issue for a while, and I don't see it changing with Pellum at the helm.
I understand that we won't have elite units everywhere. But its sad that we are one of the worst defenses in CFB. That is inexcusable IMO.
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 12:24 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
Duck24 wrote:dthomas=ddixon wrote:Duck24 wrote:Would it be a cop out to say everything except for Buckner?
Mondeaux has been pretty great as well, just not on the level of Buck obviously.
Very true. Maybe we just say everything except for the DL. The games where we have actually let them rush the passer and not just be space eaters, they have definitely made their impact be felt.
Totally. Aiken doesn't get much coverage/credit but the results are there if you look close enough, he's just stuck in a terrible scheme under a DC who is probably the least capable guy on the entire defensive staff, save for Chinander. It's too bad because we have great assistants but they've been rendered ineffective... promoting Pellum was just an absolutely atrocious decision by Helf.
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 12:35 pm
by StevensTechU
I see 'development' get thrown around quite a bit, but past linebackers have been good basically since they got their feet wet on campus. Kiko had some personal issues that delayed his impact on the field, but he was causing quite a stir in practice. Michael Clay, Josh Kaddu, and Clay Matthews all forced their way onto the field. Hardrick, Malone, etc. over the last 2 years have seen the field due to attrition, not because they fought their way into getting key minutes.
When your team is in the PNW, it's easier to get quality linebackers than it is defensive linemen. That's what predicated the move from a 4-3 to a 3-4 (that, and added versatility against all the different offensive styles in the Pac-10/12). Yet somehow Oregon has gotten less from LBs since Kiko/Clay than uw, OSU, and possibly even WSU. Pellum hasn't been bringing in good enough players, despite what any star ratings may say. If Oregon had Kaddu, Paysinger, Matthews, and Kenny Rowe (starting lineup from 2010) this would be a completely different team.
John Neal missed on the recruiting trail pretty mightily between Ifo/Troy Hill's class and bringing in Arrion. His recruiting seems pretty boom or bust.
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 4:09 pm
by duckfan96
Thought balducci has played decent at times
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 4:11 pm
by Kimber45
We spend too much time in our basic 3-4 look and other teams are doing a better job of exploiting it's weaknesses. I think our defense is too easy for the offense to read. Compare ASU. Who was coming and where were they coming from? So much more presnap confusion.
A drop end in our system is not really the right person to be covering a slot receiver.
Another tactic is to run any eligible receiver into the area where Hardrick lined up to start the play and have them sit down. WSU threw this 6 or 8 times and it worked every time, excepting the couple of drops.
When our DBs are playing zone coverage we constantly give up those cringworthy 3rd and forever conversions. WSU absolutely murdered our zone coverage. Then they came back and mutilated the corpse just for fun.
The back seven doesn't tackle well because we apparently don't tackle to the ground in practice. Some of this may be the effect of player safety rules (concussion prevention) promulgated by the Conference. But the YAC that Oregon gives up after first contact is staggering.
And as much as I like Balducci, and he's having a good year too, we don't have the 350lb Ngata-type Samoan required to properly anchor the middle of a 3-4 defense. IMO.
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 7:48 pm
by buckmarkduck
Its probably easier and a much shorter list, to say what's right with our d. Seriously, our biggest issue is the LB. during the 3 qrt and litterly saw Walker and Hardrick standing so close their shoulders touched, and the RB ran right by them without them even knowing it.
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 9:37 pm
by pezsez1
We spend too much time in our basic 3-4 look and other teams are doing a better job of exploiting it's weaknesses. I think our defense is too easy for the offense to read. Compare ASU. Who was coming and where were they coming from? So much more presnap confusion.
It's not surprising our defense is easy to read... we've had to simplify it to keep the players from getting confused and blowing assignments.
I asked in a different thread if people here could gauge whether we've made things any more complex in recent weeks, but looks like we're probably still keeping things ultra simple.
So that's another thing that's wrong.
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2015 10:04 pm
by buckmarkduck
pezsez1 wrote:We spend too much time in our basic 3-4 look and other teams are doing a better job of exploiting it's weaknesses. I think our defense is too easy for the offense to read. Compare ASU. Who was coming and where were they coming from? So much more presnap confusion.
It's not surprising our defense is easy to read... we've had to simplify it to keep the players from getting confused and blowing assignments.
I asked in a different thread if people here could gauge whether we've made things any more complex in recent weeks, but looks like we're probably still keeping things ultra simple.
So that's another thing that's wrong.
Simplification is the weakest excuse ever! Do people not understand that Pete Carroll has dominated in both college and the NFL by running a simple D to perfection? His D isn't hard or complex, he just gets his guys to play what they do, very well. When you line up vs the old SC teams or the Seahawks, you know what they are good not to do, cover 3 about 80% of the time, and a basic 4-3 front. There's no tricks, just solid tackling, and out tough other teams.