Page 1 of 1
Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2015 9:14 am
by QuackininBama
Not sure how I feel about this. Its not like the Big 10, playing Rutgers and Illinois, all the Pac teams are playing quality opponents and beating each other up, so because were not padding our schedule with patsys or have a weak conference were penalized?
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2015 9:22 am
by GoDucksIn09
Start of the season the Pac 12 had the highest percentage chance to have a 2 loss team and possibly a 3 loss team that would win the conference. It is playing out pretty much how the experts thought. They also said the north would come down to Stanford or Oregon. If Oregon beats USC next week it looks like that is true. USC will be a really tough game though I think.
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2015 10:13 am
by SuperDuck
QuackininBama wrote:Not sure how I feel about this. Its not like the Big 10, playing Rutgers and Illinois, all the Pac teams are playing quality opponents and beating each other up, so because were not padding our schedule with patsys or have a weak conference were penalized?
This is exactly why I think the playoff should be expanded to either 8 or 16 teams. I'd lean towards 8. That way it's not saturated, but there's still enough room for all Power-5 conference champs, one Mid-Major champ and two at large teams.
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2015 10:19 am
by mdm0302
what if there is just a ridiculous meltdown and then Oregon goes undefeated and smacks Utah with the revenge in the Pac 12 title game. The committee says Oregon is elite now, since they have a healthy QB. we slip into the 4th spot past a team with 2 losses. lollll
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2015 11:35 am
by gofightingducks
I don't care, I am just happy Oregon is winning again. I always felt Utah was a little over rated and the Oregon blowout inflated them too high. I think the conference outside of Oregon State and Colorado is really good and unfortunately that hurts the conference where other have a couple teams that are really good and the rest are average or bad.
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2015 11:41 am
by pezsez1
I think the Pac-12 needs to take a play from the SEC's playbook at least until we have an 8-team playoff with guaranteed spots for Power 5 conference champs.
That said, I'm glad the Pac-12 is shut out. If Oregon doesn't go to the playoff, I sure as hell don't want Stanford, USC or anyone else getting all that national attention.
Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2015 12:28 pm
by UofDuck
pezsez1 wrote:I think the Pac-12 needs to take a play from the SEC's playbook at least until we have an 8-team playoff with guaranteed spots for Power 5 conference champs.
That said, I'm glad the Pac-12 is shut out. If Oregon doesn't go to the playoff, I sure as hell don't want Stanford, USC or anyone else getting all that national attention.
I agree. We battle both schools for recruits. And a few recruits hearing from other coaches that "Oregon is done" needs to be put to bed.
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2015 12:56 pm
by Bud Lee
SuperDuck wrote:QuackininBama wrote:Not sure how I feel about this. Its not like the Big 10, playing Rutgers and Illinois, all the Pac teams are playing quality opponents and beating each other up, so because were not padding our schedule with patsys or have a weak conference were penalized?
This is exactly why I think the playoff should be expanded to either 8 or 16 teams. I'd lean towards 8. That way it's not saturated, but there's still enough room for all Power-5 conference champs, one Mid-Major champ and two at large teams.
I like this plan
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2015 3:51 pm
by RebelDuck
It is a Catch 22. It benefits the conference as a whole to have a team in the playoffs but Oregon needs to win all (or as many as they can) of their games too. Now we're playing for a Rose Bowl berth and hoping for a Stanford loss. Not too bad given the start of the season.
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2015 4:03 pm
by buckmarkduck
I could honestly care less what the rest of the conference does in the post season. I only care about UO and you would never catch me chanting Pac 12.
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2015 6:02 pm
by Oregonian
Bud Lee wrote:SuperDuck wrote:QuackininBama wrote:Not sure how I feel about this. Its not like the Big 10, playing Rutgers and Illinois, all the Pac teams are playing quality opponents and beating each other up, so because were not padding our schedule with patsys or have a weak conference were penalized?
This is exactly why I think the playoff should be expanded to either 8 or 16 teams. I'd lean towards 8. That way it's not saturated, but there's still enough room for all Power-5 conference champs, one Mid-Major champ and two at large teams.
I like this plan
I'm a big fan of the Top 6 idea, with 3 vs 6 and 4 vs 5 at the high seed's home field the week after the conference championship games. After that, it plays out exactly as the current system.
I think knowing that we have at least 5 "Power" conferences, 4 teams is inevitably not going to be enough - but large expansion starts really trampling on academics and starts bloating the length of the season drastically. With a Top 6, we mostly keep the season we already have (and there's still significant value to being #1 or #2) and we at least guarantee that if all the P5 champions all go undefeated, there's enough spots for them. And when seasons gets messy like this one (and especially last year's), we have the slots to clean up the mess.
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2015 6:22 pm
by buckmarkduck
Why is it that every other level of football can have a 16 team playoff without "trampeling" academics, but at the top level is such a concern? The reality is, because the sec would be exposed if they allowed 16 teams in.
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2015 6:57 pm
by Oregonian
buckmarkduck wrote:Why is it that every other level of football can have a 16 team playoff without "trampeling" academics, but at the top level is such a concern? The reality is, because the sec would be exposed if they allowed 16 teams in.
Well, first of all, it actually IS a complaint at the lower levels with regards to academics. Second, the FCS does not have the obsession with neutral locations that the FBS does, so playoff games through academic periods are done exactly like regular season games (up until the championship), so teams typically can travel on a Friday and return Saturday night still. With neutral sites in FBS games, teams typically travel and practice in the area for a period of time before the game, usually there's media stuff at location they have to do, etc. I suppose you could argue that the FBS should shift to the FCS model and just play at high seed's home fields, but there's a lot of money and tradition that's against that.
Further, the FCS is kind of a bad model because their seasons drastically differ from FBS teams. Most FCS teams only play 11 games, and don't have conference championship games. Their playoff starts the week the Pac-12 plays its rivalry games, and that's just to get it all done around the same time we get the current playoff done.
It's not a matter of SEC bias, it's also a matter of practicality.
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2015 8:25 pm
by Zyme
mdm0302 wrote:what if there is just a ridiculous meltdown and then Oregon goes undefeated and smacks Utah with the revenge in the Pac 12 title game. The committee says Oregon is elite now, since they have a healthy QB. we slip into the 4th spot past a team with 2 losses. lollll
The midwest and south would burn... do it.
Re: Pac-12 out of playoffs
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2015 10:32 pm
by buckmarkduck
Oregonian wrote:buckmarkduck wrote:Why is it that every other level of football can have a 16 team playoff without "trampeling" academics, but at the top level is such a concern? The reality is, because the sec would be exposed if they allowed 16 teams in.
Well, first of all, it actually IS a complaint at the lower levels with regards to academics. Second, the FCS does not have the obsession with neutral locations that the FBS does, so playoff games through academic periods are done exactly like regular season games (up until the championship), so teams typically can travel on a Friday and return Saturday night still. With neutral sites in FBS games, teams typically travel and practice in the area for a period of time before the game, usually there's media stuff at location they have to do, etc. I suppose you could argue that the FBS should shift to the FCS model and just play at high seed's home fields, but there's a lot of money and tradition that's against that.
Further, the FCS is kind of a bad model because their seasons drastically differ from FBS teams. Most FCS teams only play 11 games, and don't have conference championship games. Their playoff starts the week the Pac-12 plays its rivalry games, and that's just to get it all done around the same time we get the current playoff done.
It's not a matter of SEC bias, it's also a matter of practicality.
Most teams only played 11 games a year until a few years ago. It's funny they can add extra games to the regular season, an conference title games, but fight a 8-16 team playoff. In reality an 8 team playoff make the most sense, 5 automatic bids with 3 at large. The one extra game would only affect two teams, and would be the only fair thing to do.