Page 1 of 1

Alie and Schneider

Posted: Tue Dec 01, 2015 11:58 am
by Alan
Should they scholarships this off season?

Re: Alie and Schneider

Posted: Tue Dec 01, 2015 12:03 pm
by StevensTechU
Schneider is a slam dunk scholarship. Unless Alie is viewed as being next year's starter, then he is not.

Kaulana Apelu is one to watch.

Re: Alie and Schneider

Posted: Tue Dec 01, 2015 12:50 pm
by pezsez1
I think Allie deserves a scholarship even if he's our top backup QB. Being in that position still requires putting in the same amount of work and focus as the starter. It wouldn't send a good message if our no. 2 QB was basically carrying his own water while some dude on the scout team gets a free ride.

Re: Alie and Schneider

Posted: Tue Dec 01, 2015 12:58 pm
by StevensTechU
I'm with you as far as 'deserving' but this is one of those places where you have a guy who proved on the field this year that he's just not good enough for this level. Assuming Lockie comes back for a final go-round, Alie doesn't add a lot of value. Would rather give reps to Mahalak and Jonsen (again, assuming they're on the roster) than watch Alie run a limited offense.

Re: Alie and Schneider

Posted: Tue Dec 01, 2015 1:01 pm
by pezsez1
I'm not ready to say Allie has reached his potential. If anything, the coaches seem to describe him as continually getting better, and I think he's only a sophomore. Most of his time with Oregon has been spent with the scout team, and not getting serious reps with the 1s. I think he could easily become a great backup.

But if someone else is better, then Allie (or anyone else on the team) isn't owed anything.

Re: Alie and Schneider

Posted: Tue Dec 01, 2015 3:03 pm
by Alan
As said, Schneider is a slam dunk, he needs one ASAP. I believe Alie is a better QB than Lockie, while I don't think either one will Start next year, Alie gets lots of playing time, a lot more than some scholarship kids do...... He needs one too.

Re: Alie and Schneider

Posted: Tue Dec 01, 2015 4:02 pm
by gogreen55
Alan wrote:I believe Alie is a better QB than Lockie...
Based on what? The coaches see how these players perform in practice. They made it very clear before the season began that it was a two player race (between VA and Lockie) to be the starting QB and there was a sizable gap between the rest of the quarterbacks. We know Lockie played better in the Spring Game. We know he played better in camp before the season started. When VA was hurt, it was Lockie that was given the first shot. When Alie was given a shot, he could not have looked more incompetent throwing the ball in his limited opportunities. The coaches clearly had no confidence in Alie throwing the ball, and who could blame them? As bad as things were with Lockie, at least he did complete over 64% of his passes and didn't look nearly as incompetent throwing as Alie did. A lot of Lockie's negative statistics game against Utah, when the entire team was in complete meltdown mode.

Just to be clear, I am not defending Lockie. I am just perplexed why people think Alie is a better choice. Choosing between Lockie and Alie is a bit like choosing between breaking your right leg or your left leg.

Getting back to the initial question...should Alie be given a scholarship? Unless he completely transforms himself as a player during the offseason, the answer falls somewhere between "no" and "hell no."

Re: Alie and Schneider

Posted: Tue Dec 01, 2015 4:12 pm
by Alan
gogreen55 wrote:
Alan wrote:I believe Alie is a better QB than Lockie...
Based on what? The coaches see how these players perform in practice. They made it very clear before the season began that it was a two player race (between VA and Lockie) to be the starting QB and there was a sizable gap between the rest of the quarterbacks. We know Lockie played better in the Spring Game. We know he played better in camp before the season started. When VA was hurt, it was Lockie that was given the first shot. When Alie was given a shot, he could not have looked more incompetent throwing the ball in his limited opportunities. The coaches clearly had no confidence in Alie throwing the ball, and who could blame them? As bad as things were with Lockie, at least he did complete over 64% of his passes and didn't look nearly as incompetent throwing as Alie did. A lot of Lockie's negative statistics game against Utah, when the entire team was in complete meltdown mode.

Just to be clear, I am not defending Lockie. I am just perplexed why people think Alie is a better choice. Choosing between Lockie and Alie is a bit like choosing between breaking your right leg or your left leg.

Getting back to the initial question...should Alie be given a scholarship? Unless he completely transforms himself as a player during the offseason, the answer falls somewhere between "no" and "hell no."
I didn't even read more than the first few words of your post...... Alie is a better QB based on nothing more than my opinion, so is the words "I think". With luck this thread doesn't get derailed into another "who's better". IMO Alie should get a scholarship.

Re: Alie and Schneider

Posted: Tue Dec 01, 2015 4:18 pm
by gogreen55
Alan wrote:I didn't even read more than the first few words of your post...... Alie is a better QB based on nothing more than my opinion, so is the words "I think". With luck this thread doesn't get derailed into another "who's better". IMO Alie should get a scholarship.
You are certainly entitled to your opinion, just like I am entitled to give my opinion.

By the way, if you read a little more you might learn something and be able to support your opinion a little better, or change your mind to a better opinion.