Wait a minute.
Who said that we'd automatically win the Alamo bowl?
Let's look at this a bit closer.
"If" we were to play Ohio State in the Rose Bowl, there would be some differences, both good and bad, vs last years game.
1. Our linebackers aren't as good as a year ago and Elliott ran all over them then.
2. On the positive side, odds are they'd start J.T. Barrett, not Cardale Jones, though Urban could pull a switch. Our defense played tough, but with both Elliott and Jones hammering us constantly they eventually tired. This time it might just be a matter of containing Barrett and Elliott. It would still be a challenge, but I think it would be easier to get their offense off the field on 3rd down. Jones just killed us with his arm and his power last year. Barrett is more elusive, but not as strong a runner or passer.
3. Our O-Line isn't as good as last year either and their D-Line is full of plug and play dudes. The biggest threat to the Oregon offense (Kryptonite) is getting consistent pressure up the middle. We used the short passing game to offset much of the Michigan State pass rush and would have to try multiple things offensively to keep them off of VA so he'd have time to throw.
4. OSU stuffed our running game last year, so we'd have to find some balance and not become one dimensional. If we can establish a good mix of run/pass I'd like our chances much better.
5. Urban Meyer doesn't lose many Bowl games, especially when he has a month to prepare. That's where the Ducks have struggled against really good teams. If it's a regular season game we generally play very well, but when you're facing a team like Ohio State, who has players that can simulate your strengths and are deeper than the Ducks, that's been harder to overcome. We exploited FSU last year, but when we beat Kansas State and Wisconsin it was because we were better and should have beaten them. That's not necessarily the case with OSU.
Here's the problem with the Rose Bowl vs the Alamo Bowl, there's no guarantee that we'd win the Alamo Bowl either!
Everyone here seems to be tacking on that 10th win as if all we have to do is show up, but I assure you that whoever we end up playing, especially if it's Baylor or TCU, will be formidable and there's no guarantee we'd win.
Baylor is down to their 3rd string QB and there's really no way to get a grasp on how good this guy really is yet. He played well for part of the game after Stidham went down vs Oklahoma, but last week they played TCU in a torrential rainstorm and their passing game sucked.
Side Note: I had Baylor's top 2 receivers on my college fantasy team and both receivers scored 0 points. I lost the championship game by 16 points.
Getting back on track, they play Texas this week and it'll be interesting to see how well they play. Baylor also has excellent running backs, Linwood Shock being the best.
TCU lost their starting QB, Trevon Boykin, and star receiver, Josh Doctson, for at least 2 games earlier this year. Boykin is back now, but not Doctson. I'm not sure if he'd make it back for the Bowl or not? They may have beaten Oklahoma if they'd had Boykin. TCU also has a good running back in Aaron Green.
In other words, all 3 teams Oregon, Baylor and TCU could have easily been in major Bowls or even the playoffs if not for significant injuries. Oregon would likely go into a game vs Baylor as a 1-3 point favorite and, now that Boykin is back for TCU, the Ducks may be the underdog.
Of course, Oklahoma State is also a possibility but the fact that they went 1-2 against the top 3 conference teams with a healthy team may make them less endearing to the Alamo Bowl. Still, their one win came against a healthy TCU team by 20 points. Hmmm...
Dr. Saturday currently has the following projections:
Russell Athletic: North Carolina vs. Oklahoma State
Peach (12/31): Florida State (at-large) vs. Houston (G5/at-large)
Fiesta (1/1): Iowa (at-large) vs. Notre Dame (at-large)
Rose (1/1): Stanford (Pac-12) vs. Ohio State (Big Ten)
Sugar (1/1): Ole Miss (SEC) vs. Baylor (Big XII)
Alamo (1/2): TCU (Big-12) vs Oregon (Pac-12)
Pick your poison. Either way it'll be a very tough game.