Page 1 of 2
Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Wed Dec 02, 2015 11:15 am
by Duck24
Just saw this on Twitter. Take it for what it's worth:
https://twitter.com/SteveMims_RG/status ... 6171541504
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Wed Dec 02, 2015 12:04 pm
by greenyellow
Would suck to lose him as he's really helped out the OLBs and is a great recruiter. Hate to see Oregon be short-handed like in 2012 as recruiting closes out. If Chins does leave, maybe they could go after Peter Sirmon since he's not a given to stay at USC.
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Wed Dec 02, 2015 12:31 pm
by SuperDuck
greenyellow wrote:
Would suck to lose him as he's really helped out the OLBs and is a great recruiter. Hate to see Oregon be short-handed like in 2012 as recruiting closes out. If Chins does leave, maybe they could go after Peter Sirmon since he's not a given to stay at USC.
I was wondering if Chinander might leave, too. Actually, this would allow Don Pellum to assume the title of Co-Defensive Coordinator/LB and John Neal to be Co-Defensive Coordinator/DBs. Or they could just bring Peter Sirmon back and let him coach linebackers.
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Wed Dec 02, 2015 2:51 pm
by UOducksTK1
That would be quite the upgrade for Chins. While he can recruit, I don't think he's ready for DC.
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Wed Dec 02, 2015 6:42 pm
by fpsduck
Yes, please.
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Wed Dec 02, 2015 10:47 pm
by uostudent
Peter Sirmon is awesome. USC pays their assistants more than Oregon though. Can't see him taking a paycut. Only way he leaves is if Helton wants to hire his own staff. Also Sirmon is going to likely want to coach with Wilcox.
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Thu Dec 03, 2015 12:17 am
by greenyellow
uostudent wrote:Peter Sirmon is awesome. USC pays their assistants more than Oregon though. Can't see him taking a paycut. Only way he leaves is if Helton wants to hire his own staff. Also Sirmon is going to likely want to coach with Wilcox.
If Sirmon has aspirations to become a DC or HC, he can't be with Wilcox forever so taking a job at Oregon where he could possibly become the DC should Pellum retire or be fired could be an incentive.
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Thu Dec 03, 2015 11:12 am
by buckmarkduck
Frost might not be able to pay him more than 300k a year. Id bet we can match the offer minus being the DC right now. But I've heard hes a guy that will be our next DC when he's ready
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Thu Dec 03, 2015 11:14 am
by StevensTechU
Lubick-- I really hope he's the Oregon OC come 2016.
Chinander-- I would like Oregon to retain him, but if Frost is willing to make him the DC at UCF, then you just have to let him go. He's shown to be a good recruiter, but there are many guys out there much more fit to be defensive coordinators. Paying him an absurd amount to stay also doesn't make sense, as there are plenty of other young, solid recruiters around the country that would gladly take Chins' place.
Graduate Assistants-- Bernardi is the GA most ready to be a full-time coach. I don't think Costa is really far behind, but it would be interesting if Costa got a job over Bernardi as the latter actually stepped in for Greatwood during spring recruiting this year, and his father has been in the business for decades (OL coach at Colorado). We'll see how that plays out because Costa becoming QB coach seems to fit like a glove, and his salary would likely open up some cash to float Lubick or a defensive coach's way.
Pellum-- Frost leaving makes it inconvenient to let go of Pellum, and if Chins goes then it becomes really inconvenient. There's no perfect answer for Helfrich here. Demotion to OLBs coach if Chins leaves and bringing in a new DC seems to me to be the best of the lackluster options, as opposed to straight up letting him go and causing more turnover.
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Thu Dec 03, 2015 12:17 pm
by greenyellow
StevensTechU wrote:Lubick-- I really hope he's the Oregon OC come 2016.
Chinander-- I would like Oregon to retain him, but if Frost is willing to make him the DC at UCF, then you just have to let him go. He's shown to be a good recruiter, but there are many guys out there much more fit to be defensive coordinators. Paying him an absurd amount to stay also doesn't make sense, as there are plenty of other young, solid recruiters around the country that would gladly take Chins' place.
Graduate Assistants-- Bernardi is the GA most ready to be a full-time coach. I don't think Costa is really far behind, but it would be interesting if Costa got a job over Bernardi as the latter actually stepped in for Greatwood during spring recruiting this year, and his father has been in the business for decades (OL coach at Colorado). We'll see how that plays out because Costa becoming QB coach seems to fit like a glove, and his salary would likely open up some cash to float Lubick or a defensive coach's way.
Pellum-- Frost leaving makes it inconvenient to let go of Pellum, and if Chins goes then it becomes really inconvenient. There's no perfect answer for Helfrich here. Demotion to OLBs coach if Chins leaves and bringing in a new DC seems to me to be the best of the lackluster options, as opposed to straight up letting him go and causing more turnover.
You could always just take away his DC title and let him keep the ILBs, which he coaches now.
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Thu Dec 03, 2015 12:21 pm
by vagusnerve
StevensTechU wrote:Lubick-- I really hope he's the Oregon OC come 2016.
Chinander-- I would like Oregon to retain him, but if Frost is willing to make him the DC at UCF, then you just have to let him go. He's shown to be a good recruiter, but there are many guys out there much more fit to be defensive coordinators. Paying him an absurd amount to stay also doesn't make sense, as there are plenty of other young, solid recruiters around the country that would gladly take Chins' place.
Graduate Assistants-- Bernardi is the GA most ready to be a full-time coach. I don't think Costa is really far behind, but it would be interesting if Costa got a job over Bernardi as the latter actually stepped in for Greatwood during spring recruiting this year, and his father has been in the business for decades (OL coach at Colorado). We'll see how that plays out because Costa becoming QB coach seems to fit like a glove, and his salary would likely open up some cash to float Lubick or a defensive coach's way.
Pellum-- Frost leaving makes it inconvenient to let go of Pellum, and if Chins goes then it becomes really inconvenient. There's no perfect answer for Helfrich here. Demotion to OLBs coach if Chins leaves and bringing in a new DC seems to me to be the best of the lackluster options, as opposed to straight up letting him go and causing more turnover.
Good analysis.
Best option on D, imo: Promote Neal, give him a raise and give him de facto control of the D, but let Pellum keep DC title.
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Thu Dec 03, 2015 2:32 pm
by StevensTechU
greenyellow wrote:
You could always just take away his DC title and let him keep the ILBs, which he coaches now.
Yea, I kind of snuck that in without explanation. My thought is/was that Oregon has a fairly unique position in the Drop End, and finding a guy who really knows that spot schematically would be harder to find than an ILBs coach. I agree with your statement, that would be totally fine as well.
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Thu Dec 03, 2015 2:47 pm
by duckfan96
Why would Neal being hired as dc be good? The pass d for Oregon isn't good, isn't he in charge of that? Oh I know everything that happens on defense (if bad) is on pellum. And anything good that happens is cause of Neal. Yea. That being said , I would think they would look outside the program. But what do I know haha
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Thu Dec 03, 2015 2:50 pm
by UOducksTK1
duckfan96 wrote:Why would Neal being hired as dc be good? The pass d for Oregon isn't good, isn't he in charge of that? Oh I know everything that happens on defense (if bad) is on pellum. And anything good that happens is cause of Neal. Yea. That being said , I would think they would look outside the program. But what do I know haha
Since Nelson has switched to safety, our DB play has been pretty study. LB play has been the liability consistently all year (Minus the Stanford game, a miracle happened there). With all the injuries at DB, and the amount of youth we have, I'd give them a pretty good grade on the 2nd half of the season.
Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF
Posted: Thu Dec 03, 2015 3:23 pm
by FlDuckFan
duckfan96 wrote:Why would Neal being hired as dc be good? The pass d for Oregon isn't good, isn't he in charge of that? Oh I know everything that happens on defense (if bad) is on pellum. And anything good that happens is cause of Neal. Yea. That being said , I would think they would look outside the program. But what do I know haha
Because Neal has consistently put a good product on the field. This year we had a secondary full of inexperienced players, who continued to show improvement as the season went on. Pellum on the other hand has done the exact opposite the linebackers have regressed from last year. Pellum also calls the plays on defense so the continuous plays of rushing 3 and dropping 8 people into coverage is on Pellum. When you have a young secondary the worse thing you can do for them is give the opposing QB an extended period of time to make the reads and throws.