Page 1 of 2
Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 9:49 am
by StevensTechU
Oregon Gridiron made one of the more interesting moves I have seen in the couple years I've been following recruiting: they're checking into Trevor Knight (less formerly known as "that guy who won a Sugar Bowl against Alabama then fell off the edge of the earth" or "Baker Mayfield's backup").
No telling how high the interest is, but the Oregon staff is definitely doing their due diligence in looking into possible QB options for next season. Knight is also looking into at least one other program in Kansas State.
Stay tuned because it's going to be an interesting offseason!
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 9:54 am
by Phalanx
Not that I mind bringing in QB depth, but doesn't this kind of reflect badly on the current QB depth chart? I mean, out of Lockie, Mahalek, Jonson, Alie, and the several new recruits - isn't that going to be a lot of quarterbacks on the team? It seems like either we are getting hard to please, or somebody has really been dropping the ball recruiting-wise.
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 10:05 am
by StevensTechU
Phalanx wrote:Not that I mind bringing in QB depth, but doesn't this kind of reflect badly on the current QB depth chart? I mean, out of Lockie, Mahalek, Jonson, Alie, and the several new recruits - isn't that going to be a lot of quarterbacks on the team? It seems like either we are getting hard to please, or somebody has really been dropping the ball recruiting-wise.
That's the common response to these stories.
Nobody bats 1.000 on the recruiting trail. Nobody. Alabama has had the #1 ranked recruiting class for about 6 years running, and this last year they went out and got transfers from a defensive lineman from Georgia and a wide receiver from Oregon State. It doesn't reflect well on those position coaches, but it would also be difficult to say that they're irresponsible.
It stinks that Oregon's position of weakness for 2015 and 2016 is quarterback, but it happens. It actually happens at most places (look around the country and see just how many crappy QBs are starters). So in the end, it's not ideal, but it's also not unusual that they aren't satisfied with their existing QBs. Because Oregon is a top 10 program these days, I would personally rather they seek out a transfer and end up with someone who can keep the status quo than to not.
As far as Trevor Knight goes... oh boy. Not sure he's the answer. My last recollection of him is he isn't sure what jersey to throw the ball to.
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 10:17 am
by Phalanx
Well, leave it to me to produce the 'common response'.
I get that nobody is perfect, but given that Mariota was the starter for three years, how many years has it been since we actually recruited a decent starting quarterback? I mean, Ohio State beat us with their third-stringer last year, and Baylor was getting it done with their third-stringer this year until he went down. Forgive me for being so banal, but something seems systemically wrong with our QB recruiting/training process when there are no injuries but we still are pounding the pavement for JC and Grad transfers for the second year in a row looking for the most important position on the team. I don't think this falls under the 'nobody's perfect' category.
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 10:36 am
by DmoneyDuck
Oregon is in an interesting predicament after Mariota's departure after the 2014 season. By all accounts, we all knew we had no quarterback depth and that it would be a dicey situation once he left. Not only did the fans know this, but so did the coaches which is why they went hard after Vernon Adams and Braxton Miller.
Unfortunately, this only solves part of the problem because VA is a one-year transfer. However, Oregon's situation remains the same. As much as I'm thankful for Jeff Lockie and Taylor Allie's commitment to the team, neither is a FBS starting quarterback; we saw this first hand this season.
I do like the prospects Oregon has recently added (Travis Jonsen, RS FR - Terry Wilson, FR - Justin Herbert FR, Ryan Kelly, HS SR) and while all are highly rated and sought after, they are all very young and inexperienced. Jonsen missed his RS year with a toe injury (?), Wilson and Herbert have not even enrolled in school yet, and Kelly will be playing HS football next fall.
Oregon knows they need to keep this program moving in the right direction and does not want to see a 6-6, 7-5 type of season, so not only do I understand the need for another graduate transfer, I applaud it. The transfer won't have the job handed to him on a silver platter; he'll still have to win it with his play in practice.
I would have mentioned Morgan Mahalak, but no one knows what's going on with his development.
I think by the time the 2017 season rolls around, the coaches will feel a lot better about our young stable of quarterbacks taking the reigns for multiple years to come.
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 10:46 am
by Duck07
I think going this route is a bad option as it will hinder the development of the QB's. Let Jonsen, Mahalak and EE Herbert fight it out in spring summer fall and give the reigns to a young guy who can use this year to help build the future.
We need to quit expecting the QB to always be the best player for our team to be successful. Get a real D.C., run the ball and make it easy on the new qb. Getting another stop gap only hurts the young development and if these guys are all so bad that they aren't D1 QB's once they get to campus then some coaches need to be let go if it's that bad.
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 11:01 am
by Phalanx
Duck07 wrote:I think going this route is a bad option as it will hinder the development of the QB's. Let Jonsen, Mahalak and EE Herbert fight it out in spring summer fall and give the reigns to a young guy who can use this year to help build the future.
We need to quit expecting the QB to always be the best player for our team to be successful. Get a real D.C., run the ball and make it easy on the new qb. Getting another stop gap only hurts the young development and if these guys are all so bad that they aren't D1 QB's once they get to campus then some coaches need to be let go if it's that bad.
Totally agree.
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 12:01 pm
by pudgejeff
Duck07 wrote:I think going this route is a bad option as it will hinder the development of the QB's. Let Jonsen, Mahalak and EE Herbert fight it out in spring summer fall and give the reigns to a young guy who can use this year to help build the future.
We need to quit expecting the QB to always be the best player for our team to be successful. Get a real D.C., run the ball and make it easy on the new qb. Getting another stop gap only hurts the young development and if these guys are all so bad that they aren't D1 QB's once they get to campus then some coaches need to be let go if it's that bad.
So, be Florida?
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 12:08 pm
by StevensTechU
Ohio State had phenomenal success with their 3rd string quarterback in 2015, and then in 2016 they spent most of the season unable to generate significant offense with any of the guys until very late in the season. The depth at QB that Baylor has assembled is astounding. Truly enviable.
But Georgia, Florida State, Virginia Tech, Oklahoma, Oregon, and probably others started transfer QBs in 2015. So which is more normal, Baylor above of or the ones to the left?
I agree in principle with the comment basically saying that it's a little ridiculous that Oregon needs a top shelf QB every year to maintain success. Usually the D is good enough to generate turnovers and prevent big points, but this year was historically bad, and as we saw, nobody but VA could help this team win.
Two things to consider in addition to some of the points above. First is the livelihood of the coaches and support staff. While letting a young guy learn on the job would be nice, college football has much faster turnover than the NFL (which is already fast). So each year a coach is effectively coaching for his job, therefore there's a deterrent to waiting and developing a triggerman. Second, the future livelihood of the players with professional aspirations depend, to some degree, on the QB. Carrington, Addison, etc. are not going to have much of a highlight tape with Lockie in the backfield. It's owed to these guys to put a good quarterback in the backfield each and every year.
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 12:27 pm
by Tray Dub
I think I'd side with bringing him in. There's a cost in the lack of in-game experience for a younger guy, but I think you can't let the perfect be the enemy of the good here. We aren't rebuilding yet, our focus has to be on doing our best next season. If this guy has a clear edge over the younger guys, I'm okay with getting a less experienced starter down the road. It's a tradeoff, but in my opinion a worthwhile one.
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 5:01 pm
by Oregonian
I think that the decision to add another stop-gap speaks to the interesting predicament we're in - it's obvious we flopped on Lockie and whiffed on Mahalak, and Jonsen missed a season of practice due to an injury. I think that the coaches reasonably believe in Jonsen, Herbert and Wilson, but the reality is even Mariota had a year to sit and be groomed before he saw the field, and we flat out will not have a good enough QB to let them do that. If a transfer QB can get us through another season - possibly successfully - while we groom one of the three we've got, then I'm good with it.
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 7:47 pm
by damascusduck
Oregonian wrote:I think that the decision to add another stop-gap speaks to the interesting predicament we're in - it's obvious we flopped on Lockie and whiffed on Mahalak, and Jonsen missed a season of practice due to an injury. I think that the coaches reasonably believe in Jonsen, Herbert and Wilson, but the reality is even Mariota had a year to sit and be groomed before he saw the field, and we flat out will not have a good enough QB to let them do that. If a transfer QB can get us through another season - possibly successfully - while we groom one of the three we've got, then I'm good with it.
Actually, Lockie was added for depth, JRod was highly regarded. Got impatient and left. Didn't work out too well for him, did it? Mahalak seems to be a miss. We will see after the spring, assuming he is still here.
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 9:59 pm
by UOducksTK1
Duck07 wrote:I think going this route is a bad option as it will hinder the development of the QB's. Let Jonsen, Mahalak and EE Herbert fight it out in spring summer fall and give the reigns to a young guy who can use this year to help build the future.
We need to quit expecting the QB to always be the best player for our team to be successful. Get a real D.C., run the ball and make it easy on the new qb. Getting another stop gap only hurts the young development and if these guys are all so bad that they aren't D1 QB's once they get to campus then some coaches need to be let go if it's that bad.
What's an extra year of learning the playbook and riding the bench going to hurt anything? Then you can throw Kelly and a redshirted Wilson into the mix.
I'll admit going the JC route always won't solve the problem, but we've put ourselves in a poor position. Look at Dana Altman. He was forced to go the JC route, and we've had probably our best stretch of basketball ever under DA. Now that things have settled, he can recruit more normally. There's a time and a season for different things. I still think a JC QB is an absolutely acceptable alternative given our current state.
Re: Trevor Knight
Posted: Tue Dec 08, 2015 10:11 pm
by lukeyrid13
Ask auburn fans if they would prefer cam Newton or hAving ' one of their guys' play. I don't care where our qb comes from so long as we win games.
Trevor Knight
Posted: Wed Dec 09, 2015 1:04 pm
by UofDuck
I was OK bringing in Vernon as a one time exception, but I do not like the precedence it's sets by doing it again. In my opinion it's not a healthy way to build on our program