Page 1 of 1

2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sat Dec 12, 2015 10:36 am
by vagusnerve
Can anyone share their thoughts on where were at with the 2016 class?

Looking over our commit list there's around 16-17 guys. How many are we taking, and what positions are left to fill?

Prukop is a likely addition, but overall I'm not super stoked on the class, and I'll tell you why.

I see a lot of 2-3 star guys without offers from other good programs. Stars aren't everything but I tend to trust offer lists. Not saying there isn't room for those guys, but I don't see many guys with impressive offers outside of 3-4 guys.

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 12:16 am
by GoDucksIn09
That seems to be Oregon's thing. I would love to see a bunch of 4 or maybe even 5 star guys. It isn't bout the stars as much as it is the fact that generally speaking the 4s and 5s and some 3s the only ones getting to the pros. Of course there are exceptions but it seems Oregon seems to think they always go after what they think are exceptions instead of aggressively pursuing the top talent every year. I find it odd because we are getting the Oregon brand out there finally. I know getting the top talent isn't easy. I just don't get why we every year are settling for guys who nobody else is offering. It is ok occasionally. Every year though is a problem. In the end for me I guess it does not matter. I will always be a duck fan. I just wish we would get the higher caliber players with a lot more upside and a lot more chance of getting Oregon to the next level.

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 12:37 am
by gogreen55
vagusnerve wrote:but I don't see many guys with impressive offers outside of 3-4 guys.
I guess it depends on what offers you consider impressive? If only elite football powers outside of the West Coast (Alabama, Ohio State, Florida State, etc.) qualify, you might have a case.

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 12:40 pm
by vagusnerve
gogreen55 wrote:
vagusnerve wrote:but I don't see many guys with impressive offers outside of 3-4 guys.
I guess it depends on what offers you consider impressive? If only elite football powers outside of the West Coast (Alabama, Ohio State, Florida State, etc.) qualify, you might have a case.
Half our commitment list has offers from good schools, like UCLA, Cal, Stanford, USC, tOSU, Notre Dame, places like that.

The other half is guys we are competing against Arizona, Utah, WSU, Oregon State, maybe even the Weber States and other lower level schools.

And a lot of the guys were scouted by guys on here and DT, saying they were'nt Pac12 quality guys. Those diamonds in the rough, we all know what it pretty quickly after watching some highlight tape.

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 12:45 pm
by greenyellow
vagusnerve wrote:
gogreen55 wrote:
vagusnerve wrote:but I don't see many guys with impressive offers outside of 3-4 guys.
I guess it depends on what offers you consider impressive? If only elite football powers outside of the West Coast (Alabama, Ohio State, Florida State, etc.) qualify, you might have a case.
Half our commitment list has offers from good schools, like UCLA, Cal, Stanford, USC, tOSU, Notre Dame, places like that.

The other half is guys we are competing against Arizona, Utah, WSU, Oregon State, maybe even the Weber States and other lower level schools.

And a lot of the guys were scouted by guys on here and DT, saying they were'nt Pac12 quality guys. Those diamonds in the rough, we all know what it pretty quickly after watching some highlight tape.
Talk about being overly negative on a class that's viewed as being pretty strong overall for Oregon. Might be better to wait who they get and how they develop before calling the class a bust and the coaches a bunch of bums.

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 1:37 pm
by UOducksTK1
greenyellow wrote:
vagusnerve wrote:
gogreen55 wrote:
vagusnerve wrote:but I don't see many guys with impressive offers outside of 3-4 guys.
I guess it depends on what offers you consider impressive? If only elite football powers outside of the West Coast (Alabama, Ohio State, Florida State, etc.) qualify, you might have a case.
Half our commitment list has offers from good schools, like UCLA, Cal, Stanford, USC, tOSU, Notre Dame, places like that.

The other half is guys we are competing against Arizona, Utah, WSU, Oregon State, maybe even the Weber States and other lower level schools.

And a lot of the guys were scouted by guys on here and DT, saying they were'nt Pac12 quality guys. Those diamonds in the rough, we all know what it pretty quickly after watching some highlight tape.
Talk about being overly negative on a class that's viewed as being pretty strong overall for Oregon. Might be better to wait who they get and how they develop before calling the class a bust and the coaches a bunch of bums.
Seriously^

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 1:46 pm
by vagusnerve
Just said I'm not completely stoked. No mention of a bust class. Never said anything about bums.

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 5:17 pm
by Phalanx
greenyellow wrote: Talk about being overly negative on a class that's viewed as being pretty strong overall for Oregon. Might be better to wait who they get and how they develop before calling the class a bust and the coaches a bunch of bums.
I didn't see the overly negative thing. He wanted to see higher-rated guys in the class. That's a pretty universal want. It's fine to counter that Oregon is well known for turning another man's 2-3 star into gold, but I don't see a problem with a guy expressing his opinion.

Anyway, when I survey this class, I am happy that we have some good looking linebackers, which was definitely a concern, but the other concern was CB, and we still feel weak there, with only Mayden so far. Not sure what the latest with Knott is, but it seems like we could sure use at least one more back there. Possibly the coaches intend to permanently convert someone from among the legions of receivers on the team, like Nelson and/or Lovette.

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 6:18 pm
by vagusnerve
Phalanx wrote:
greenyellow wrote: Talk about being overly negative on a class that's viewed as being pretty strong overall for Oregon. Might be better to wait who they get and how they develop before calling the class a bust and the coaches a bunch of bums.
I didn't see the overly negative thing. He wanted to see higher-rated guys in the class. That's a pretty universal want. It's fine to counter that Oregon is well known for turning another man's 2-3 star into gold, but I don't see a problem with a guy expressing his opinion.

Anyway, when I survey this class, I am happy that we have some good looking linebackers, which was definitely a concern, but the other concern was CB, and we still feel weak there, with only Mayden so far. Not sure what the latest with Knott is, but it seems like we could sure use at least one more back there. Possibly the coaches intend to permanently convert someone from among the legions of receivers on the team, like Nelson and/or Lovette.
LB recruiting looking pretty solid.No Mique Juarez types, but takes some luck to pick up guys like that.

Love the Hotchkins offer, could make an impact next year.

Last I heard on Knott we have a real shot. One of those guys that really hasn't made a decision from the sound of it. I don't see us recruiting any other CBs, and we need another one in this class, so they must be somewhat confident we got a shot.

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 6:30 pm
by greenyellow
There's supposedly one recruit who's a silent commit who wants to announce it at the US Army AA Game. Of the recruits with Oregon still on their list, that narrows it down to Caleb Kelly, Dylan Crawford, and Javon McKinley. Talk on DT seems to indicate it's a WR, which would mean either Crawford or McKinley, but nothing too solid.

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 7:11 pm
by pdxduck2013
greenyellow wrote:There's supposedly one recruit who's a silent commit who wants to announce it at the US Army AA Game. Of the recruits with Oregon still on their list, that narrows it down to Caleb Kelly, Dylan Crawford, and Javon McKinley. Talk on DT seems to indicate it's a WR, which would mean either Crawford or McKinley, but nothing too solid.
I think it's McKinley. I feel like I've seen a few people here and other places hint at him being a silent commit.

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 7:49 pm
by gogreen55
vagusnerve wrote:
gogreen55 wrote:
vagusnerve wrote:but I don't see many guys with impressive offers outside of 3-4 guys.
I guess it depends on what offers you consider impressive? If only elite football powers outside of the West Coast (Alabama, Ohio State, Florida State, etc.) qualify, you might have a case.
Half our commitment list has offers from good schools, like UCLA, Cal, Stanford, USC, tOSU, Notre Dame, places like that.

The other half is guys we are competing against Arizona, Utah, WSU, Oregon State, maybe even the Weber States and other lower level schools.

And a lot of the guys were scouted by guys on here and DT, saying they were'nt Pac12 quality guys. Those diamonds in the rough, we all know what it pretty quickly after watching some highlight tape.
That is why I responded to your initial post, since you said there were only 3-4 current commits with impressive offers. If you consider offers from schools like UCLA, USC, Stanford, Cal, Michigan, etc. to be impressive, then there are many more than 3-4 of our commits with impressive offers lists (if 247's lists of offers for each recruit is accurate). Like you said in your follow up post, about half the current commits would qualify as having impressive offer lists, with about 4 others having very respectable offer lists.

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 8:07 pm
by vagusnerve
gogreen55 wrote:
vagusnerve wrote:
gogreen55 wrote:
vagusnerve wrote:but I don't see many guys with impressive offers outside of 3-4 guys.
I guess it depends on what offers you consider impressive? If only elite football powers outside of the West Coast (Alabama, Ohio State, Florida State, etc.) qualify, you might have a case.
Half our commitment list has offers from good schools, like UCLA, Cal, Stanford, USC, tOSU, Notre Dame, places like that.

The other half is guys we are competing against Arizona, Utah, WSU, Oregon State, maybe even the Weber States and other lower level schools.

And a lot of the guys were scouted by guys on here and DT, saying they were'nt Pac12 quality guys. Those diamonds in the rough, we all know what it pretty quickly after watching some highlight tape.
That is why I responded to your initial post, since you said there were only 3-4 current commits with impressive offers. If you consider offers from schools like UCLA, USC, Stanford, Cal, Michigan, etc. to be impressive, then there are many more than 3-4 of our commits with impressive offers lists (if 247's lists of offers for each recruit is accurate). Like you said in your follow up post, about half the current commits would qualify as having impressive offer lists, with about 4 others having very respectable offer lists.
Yeah, 3-4 guys with impressive offers, like bama or OSU.

About half our guys have good offer lists, like UCLA, Stanford, etc.

Re: 2016 Class Home Stretch

Posted: Sun Dec 13, 2015 9:48 pm
by greenyellow
pdxduck2013 wrote:
greenyellow wrote:There's supposedly one recruit who's a silent commit who wants to announce it at the US Army AA Game. Of the recruits with Oregon still on their list, that narrows it down to Caleb Kelly, Dylan Crawford, and Javon McKinley. Talk on DT seems to indicate it's a WR, which would mean either Crawford or McKinley, but nothing too solid.
I think it's McKinley. I feel like I've seen a few people here and other places hint at him being a silent commit.
With Wallace now on board, that makes 3 WRs in this class so I'm wondering if they'd consider taking a 4th with the intentions of moving either Wallace or McDoom.