Page 1 of 2
New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 4:07 pm
by Quietduck
A word of warning for all of you calling for coaches to be fired.
1. We are not a big boy in the world of College Football for all our recent success and even if we were look at USC it's been how many years since Pete C. and while they get lots of big name coaches they are still looking for someone to bring them to the record we still have.
2. A new coach or coordinator is not necessarily an improvement does anyone remember Rich Stubler and "The Edge"
3. No matter what we are at best a mid level school in size, salaries, recruiting and support so if we think we are in the class of of the big teams we need to change our weather, our population, and our university size before we go looking for a new coach to make us what some fans want us to be.
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 4:11 pm
by buckmarkduck
Quietduck wrote:A word of warning for all of you calling for coaches to be fired.
1. We are not a big boy in the world of College Football for all our recent success and even if we were look at USC it's been how many years since Pete C. and while they get lots of big name coaches they are still looking for someone to bring them to the record we still have.
2. A new coach or coordinator is not necessarily an improvement does anyone remember Rich Stubler and "The Edge"
3. No matter what we are at best a mid level school in size, salaries, recruiting and support so if we think we are in the class of of the big teams we need to change our weather, our population, and our university size before we go looking for a new coach to make us what some fans want us to be.
BS. 110% crap
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 4:20 pm
by Quietduck
Oh?
Has USC a better season? Have they not gone through more than a couple big name coaches? I could fill this whole box with new coaches that were worse than the former coach. Perhaps you could tell me why Eugene Oregon (a city I love) has the same draw and resources of say LA or history and tradition of football of any of the Texas schools, or perhaps the talent pool of Florida.
I don't say that coach never should be fired, just be careful what you ask for as it may come back worse than you have.
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 4:26 pm
by rockthief
I have difficulty imagining a DC worse than coach LPellum
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 4:32 pm
by buckmarkduck
The only coach anyone wants gone is Pellum. Two UO is a top 15 program whether you want to admit it or not. We have the money to pay coordinators, frost with zero experience made 700 last season. If we want a Orlando, we can pay 1mill. And you put down Eugene, but is LSU located in much bigger of an area? A&M? Iowa, MSU, in fact most of he sec.
Comparing to LA is dumb, they suck at hiring. Besides most college towns are closer to Eugen than LA.
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 4:52 pm
by rentdodger1
Quietduck wrote:Oh?
Has USC a better season? Have they not gone through more than a couple big name coaches? I could fill this whole box with new coaches that were worse than the former coach. Perhaps you could tell me why Eugene Oregon (a city I love) has the same draw and resources of say LA or history and tradition of football of any of the Texas schools, or perhaps the talent pool of Florida.
I don't say that coach never should be fired, just be careful what you ask for as it may come back worse than you have.
Unless the Pac-12 adds a 13th team how could Pellum do any worse statistically or by performance? Last gets you fired in most jobs.
Your argument was valid 30yrs ago, not now. Knight and Nike make Oregon a national attraction. The relationship and the resources brought to the school has leveled the field. You should be able to figure that one out on your own.
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 5:01 pm
by greenyellow
I know people are still a bit emotional after last night and this season but people need to remember we're all Duck fans here and posting stuff that seems to be questioning someone's intelligence is not needed.
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 5:15 pm
by ducksrock
Sometimes it's wise to remain a Quiet Duck.... We ARE a national power.... And that is not dictated by a Very Poor 2nd half in one bowl game....it is dictated by our successes in the recent past... Check out the win/loss records and how the balance of the country view the program
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 5:18 pm
by squintsdd
greenyellow wrote:I know people are still a bit emotional after last night and this season but people need to remember we're all Duck fans here and posting stuff that seems to be questioning someone's intelligence is not needed.
Normally I would agree, but the OP doesn't seem to realize that Oregon football is one of the top earners in college sports, and also forgot about the support of a man named Phil knight and company named Nike. Oregon can afford to pay it's coaches and has the backing to attract a top level staff
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 5:25 pm
by duckfan22
we are a power now..Hell last year we played in the
championship game. Not the first one either. Another thing
to look at is how were recruiting and who were going up against.
Dakota Prukop chose us over Alabama. Several of our commits
chose Oregon over the bigs guns. Were getting visits by some of the
very best. When we go into a recruits they know what Oregon is all about.
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 5:27 pm
by fpsduck
rockthief wrote:I have difficulty imagining a DC worse than coach LPellum
Rich Stubler?
Mark Banker?
it's a short list for sure.
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 5:41 pm
by rentdodger1
greenyellow wrote:I know people are still a bit emotional after last night and this season but people need to remember we're all Duck fans here and posting stuff that seems to be questioning someone's intelligence is not needed.
I would say our viewpoints are similar most of the time. Unfortunately. I think your the one off base here. I am not questioning his intelligence or his right to state his view and insinuating that is wrong. Settling for mediocrity is not a formula for success.
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 5:44 pm
by buckmarkduck
I wasn't questioning anyone's intelligence fwiw. Just disagree with his thinking that UO isn't big time, and we don't have money or the resources.
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 9:16 pm
by Quietduck
Money doesn't make us big time. Phil isn't for ever. Why does N.D. keep coming back? Why do the Florida schools have talent we only dream of. Why does USC get five star players even when they are losing? We haven't the time to have N.D. tradition and money can't buy that. We don't have the population to have enough talent to compete with USC and the Florida schools. Seattle has a better chance than Oregon if we keep having this entitled view of ourselves. As I said I'm not against firing a coach but be aware just like first round draft picks or five star high school players there are more failures than anyone likes.
Re: New coachs
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2016 10:00 pm
by srsmiley007
buckmarkduck wrote:I wasn't questioning anyone's intelligence fwiw. Just disagree with his thinking that UO isn't big time, and we don't have money or the resources.
And you would be correct! Facilities, conference, competition and proven tradition all come into play for coaches and we are a highly coveted top 15 org. While a great opportunity, we're not going to get a successful power 5 DC from another org for just a few more dollars. For them, it will be the prestige, latitude to build your defense your way, quality of life, ability to recruit,etc.
That said, you can't just grab any coach without looking at full-time staffing limitations, retaining certain coaches for recruiting or perceived value. Based upon what they will likely do if they fire Pillows would require replacing him with another LB coach in order to retain Neal, Chins, Aiken. That narrows our pool of options and that is just some of the challenge. There's the DC's willingness to retain existing staff, etc.Salary and buyout don't come into play on this one. It's recruits, long term planning, retaining staff, etc.
However, it's almost statistically impossible to do worse than Pillows with how our offense also plays defense for us by forcing offenses to be one-dimensional. The only other teams with a worse D, don't have the same offensive firepower. Almost anyone would be better than DP at this point. Hell, I would take the "edge" defense over what I'm seeing right now. 31 points in a half to a backup QB. Would could have blitzed 3 and run Cover 0 every play with better results. THERE IS NO WAY FIRING PELLUM is going to haunt us. ABSOLUTELY NO DOWNSIDE.