Page 1 of 2
Wilcox
Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 1:46 pm
by FlDuckFan
Ok so, it sounds like most of us here are against hiring Wilcox. Some may say it wouldn't be that bad but most prefer a different guy leading the defense.
I present to you a question. What if Oregon interviewing Wilcox is to fill a void at LB coach whether it be outside or inside if Pellum were to retire once we hire a new DC?
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 1:49 pm
by pezsez1
I'd give Wilcox a shot at LB coach. I think the Pellum experience proves that being a position coach and coordinator are two very different things.
Pellum is a man of great integrity though, and whoever eventually replaces him needs to fit that mold. Not sure Wilcox does at the moment, but other than that caveat I'm sure he'd be a fine LB coach.
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 1:50 pm
by vegasdom
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 2:01 pm
by duckfan22
This is why I doubt they hire him. Not part of the culture here.
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 2:55 pm
by greenyellow
Why put Wilcox in charge of the LBs when you could potentially get Sirmon, who seems to be a pretty good LB coach?
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 3:16 pm
by GrandpaDuck
Arizona is looking at Wilcox too. I don't think his stock has dropped enough that he would consider a position job at this point.
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 3:22 pm
by greenyellow
GrandpaDuck wrote:Arizona is looking at Wilcox too. I don't think his stock has dropped enough that he would consider a position job at this point.
At this point, I think he's looking for a job that can rehab his image/skillset before he strikes out to try for a HC job in a few years.
Wilcox
Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 9:22 pm
by UofDuck
duckfan22 wrote:
This is why I doubt they hire him. Not part of the culture here.
Not part of the culture? His family help develop it. His dad, brother, and he, all played for Oregon. His dad is a football hall of famer. Wilcox grew up around the program in Eugene. He hired Sirmon, his roommate at Oregon. I'm getting tired of hearing this statement. The Wilcox family is deeply ingrained in UofO's make-up.
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 9:34 pm
by duckfan22
True but those times have changed ever since chip was here. Attitude changed. And all I saying was his going off at the Rose Bowl would not work here. I grew up watching him and know they were a big part of every thing here
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 9:41 pm
by duxforlyfe
UofDuck wrote:duckfan22 wrote:
This is why I doubt they hire him. Not part of the culture here.
Not part of the culture? His family help develop it. His dad, brother, and he, all played for Oregon. His dad is a football hall of famer. Wilcox grew up around the program in Eugene. He hired Sirmon, his roommate at Oregon. I'm getting tired of hearing this statement. The Wilcox family is deeply ingrained in UofO's make-up.
I think roots are heavily tied to culture when talking about a particular population group, but we're talking about football. a football program's culture can change very quickly when there is personnel change. I didn't like his players at bsu with all the cheap shots they took, but I can't say that I have seen the same from his other teams more recently. However, I haven't been too impressed with his D with his last three teams either. I get the feeling he's riding the coattails of his bsu tenure.
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2016 9:58 pm
by buckmarkduck
I'll hold out judgment on whoever we hire, until I see it on the field. Of course I'll freak out if the new DC allows Lockie to go 12/13 for 250 yds or whatever Pellum d allowed him in the spring game. That should have been huge red flags for us fans.
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Fri Jan 08, 2016 5:40 am
by QuackininBama
buckmarkduck wrote:I'll hold out judgment on whoever we hire, until I see it on the field. Of course I'll freak out if the new DC allows Lockie to go 12/13 for 250 yds or whatever Pellum d allowed him in the spring game. That should have been huge red flags for us fans.
Lockie?
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Fri Jan 08, 2016 5:40 am
by srsmiley007
Wrong style of defense. Culture isn't the issue at this point. We need an attacking one-gap mentality. We'll occassionally get burned deep but if we're getting our defense off the field with 3 & outs does anyone get into a possession war with our offense? No!
What kills us is our defense getting gassed because they're on the field letting teams grind down them down to 20 than hoping we can hold them to a field goal while our offense sits and their "D" rests. Wilcox doesn't play that hyper-aggressive style. Whereas guys like Randy Shannon, Chuck Heater, Marcel Yates or Nate Woody will provide that approach.
At this point, I would beg Randy Shannon to come aboard the Oregon train. He's at Florida now as assistant DC, he coaches LB's and he's a phenomenal recruiter with ties throughout the South, etc. He would be a perfect fit.
Marcel Yates would also be a good fit for our program and coaches LB's.
I'm not sure who else is left unless we grab UT's recently fired DC John Jancek who's sported some pretty good defenses in the last 6 years at 2 different stops (Cinci and Tennessee) and can actually recruit. He might be a good fit as he's yielded 2 top 20 D's during that time and fixed a porous UT defense that ranked about as bad as ours this year taking them from 100th to 30something depending upon the stat philosophy utilized.
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Fri Jan 08, 2016 6:24 am
by wepto
srsmiley007 wrote:Wrong style of defense. Culture isn't the issue at this point. We need an attacking one-gap mentality. We'll occassionally get burned deep but if we're getting our defense off the field with 3 & outs does anyone get into a possession war with our offense? No!
What kills us is our defense getting gassed because they're on the field letting teams grind down them down to 20 than hoping we can hold them to a field goal while our offense sits and their "D" rests. Wilcox doesn't play that hyper-aggressive style. Whereas guys like Randy Shannon, Chuck Heater, Marcel Yates or Nate Woody will provide that approach.
At this point, I would beg Randy Shannon to come aboard the Oregon train. He's at Florida now as assistant DC, he coaches LB's and he's a phenomenal recruiter with ties throughout the South, etc. He would be a perfect fit.
Marcel Yates would also be a good fit for our program and coaches LB's.
I'm not sure who else is left unless we grab UT's recently fired DC John Jancek who's sported some pretty good defenses in the last 6 years at 2 different stops (Cinci and Tennessee) and can actually recruit. He might be a good fit as he's yielded 2 top 20 D's during that time and fixed a porous UT defense that ranked about as bad as ours this year taking them from 100th to 30something depending upon the stat philosophy utilized.
I'd be curious to hear what you think of Hoke's 4-3 under. Looks like 2 linemen play 2 gap technique, 2 linemen play 1 gap technique and there is also a linebacker on the line playing 1 gap technique. I think he's the only one of the coaches rumored to be interviewed who wasn't running the 3-4.
Re: Wilcox
Posted: Fri Jan 08, 2016 7:10 am
by wlduck
wepto wrote:srsmiley007 wrote:Wrong style of defense. Culture isn't the issue at this point. We need an attacking one-gap mentality. We'll occassionally get burned deep but if we're getting our defense off the field with 3 & outs does anyone get into a possession war with our offense? No!
What kills us is our defense getting gassed because they're on the field letting teams grind down them down to 20 than hoping we can hold them to a field goal while our offense sits and their "D" rests. Wilcox doesn't play that hyper-aggressive style. Whereas guys like Randy Shannon, Chuck Heater, Marcel Yates or Nate Woody will provide that approach.
At this point, I would beg Randy Shannon to come aboard the Oregon train. He's at Florida now as assistant DC, he coaches LB's and he's a phenomenal recruiter with ties throughout the South, etc. He would be a perfect fit.
Marcel Yates would also be a good fit for our program and coaches LB's.
I'm not sure who else is left unless we grab UT's recently fired DC John Jancek who's sported some pretty good defenses in the last 6 years at 2 different stops (Cinci and Tennessee) and can actually recruit. He might be a good fit as he's yielded 2 top 20 D's during that time and fixed a porous UT defense that ranked about as bad as ours this year taking them from 100th to 30something depending upon the stat philosophy utilized.
I'd be curious to hear what you think of Hoke's 4-3 under. Looks like 2 linemen play 2 gap technique, 2 linemen play 1 gap technique and there is also a linebacker on the line playing 1 gap technique. I think he's the only one of the coaches rumored to be interviewed who wasn't running the 3-4.
These are both very good posts. Smiley I think most agree that an attacking defense would be a great change from what we've been doing, and your knowledge of these guys and their styles is impressive. Wonder why no whispers about Shannon to this point?
I am not technically sound enough to comment on the question about Hokes defense. As a layman, it sounds slightly complicated, and I have always heard that's the knock on our defense- requires more thinking, slowing down naturally aggressive defenders, at least in their early years.