Page 1 of 1
What do people think of Brady Hoke at DC?
Posted: Sun Jan 10, 2016 1:25 pm
by jimmy12
I have a bias because of how weird things were at the end of his tenure at Michigan. (and his lack of wanting to use headsets etc).
Anyone have thoughts on him as a defensive mind?
Re: What do people think of Brady Hoke at DC?
Posted: Sun Jan 10, 2016 1:38 pm
by Duck07
He's a defensive orientated coach but I don't know if he's ever called a defense per se, which would be a knock for me. Some have suggested Hoke shows interest in jobs so that he can keep collecting checks from UM. That said, he's been influenced by a lot of quality coaches and may also provide a good sounding board for Helf beyond just the defense,too.
Re: What do people think of Brady Hoke at DC?
Posted: Sun Jan 10, 2016 2:00 pm
by SuperDuck
I'd have mixed feelings about Hoke, mostly because of never having been a DC. I do believe that he has a lot to offer in other areas, though, as mentioned.
I wonder if Helfrich might consider making Hoke & Neal Co-Coordinators and Hoke Assistant Head Coach? Like him or not, he is a good coach with years of experience. He could essentially consult on both sides of the ball, which could also be helpful to both Helfrich and Lubick.
Just a thought.
Re: What do people think of Brady Hoke at DC?
Posted: Sun Jan 10, 2016 2:10 pm
by srsmiley007
I know Hoke personally and he's a players coach. Passionate guy, great at getting players motivated. While it's true, hasn't been a DC before, his schemes and real expertise lies in defense. If we can't get a tier 1 stud I think we would still be in good hands with him aboard. He can recruit, he'll do away with our silly "hold the gap" mentality, move us to a 4-3 and instill much better tackling fundamentals. I wouldn't freak out about his lack of experience as a DC. While not my first choice as a DC, he would certainly bring us a top 50 D. Still would like to see us grab a Entz, NDSU's head coach or Jancik (UT) at this point since everyone else has already been snatched up or is not interested. Keep in mind that with CHins gone, whoever we get needs to be an elite recruiter. Aiken and PELLUM aren't world beaters in this category so whomever we get has to be a very good recruiter and DC.
Re: What do people think of Brady Hoke at DC?
Posted: Sun Jan 10, 2016 2:33 pm
by buckmarkduck
From all accounts he's a top tier DL coach, and a awesome recruiter. He left a crap ton of talent at Michigan, and had some really talented guys drafted last year. But I also don't think he cares as much about the character of players as much as Helf and UO has. But at some point we need to understand, you need those crazy junk yard dogs to win a natty. You can't win with choirs boys either. Like the above poster said, he's not the first choice, but I'd take him over Wilcox.
Re: What do people think of Brady Hoke at DC?
Posted: Mon Jan 11, 2016 4:14 am
by jimmy12
STU-- do you have an opinion?
Re: What do people think of Brady Hoke at DC?
Posted: Mon Jan 11, 2016 9:24 am
by Alan
Don't like Hoke, don't want Hoke. Same goes for Wilcox and Sirmon. The guy I liked stuck with USC. We need a quality, proven DC, not someone who has HC experience but no DC experience or someone who's a proven hot head.
Re: What do people think of Brady Hoke at DC?
Posted: Mon Jan 11, 2016 9:35 am
by StevensTechU
jimmy12 wrote:STU-- do you have an opinion?
Hey sorry, been a bit checked out since the holidays.
Hiring former HCs who are likely to become HCs again isn't ideal, but not the worst thing. I think we could see a short-term recruiting boost, but I don't know if it offsets the recruiting disruption that is almost guaranteed to occur in 1-3 years when Hoke gets offered a head position. He also may have some useful insights from his previous head coaching experience and could actually make Helfrich a better coach for it. So in all, I think Hoke is a good backup if more permanent DCs fall through, and I think Helf knows that.
Re: What do people think of Brady Hoke at DC?
Posted: Mon Jan 11, 2016 10:27 am
by jimmy12
Thanks STU-- I value your opinion. Check back in man... This board needs it.
Re: What do people think of Brady Hoke at DC?
Posted: Mon Jan 11, 2016 11:14 am
by karlhungis
So is Hoke an actual possibility or just a message board pipe dream? Has he been contacted by the ducks?
Re: What do people think of Brady Hoke at DC?
Posted: Mon Jan 11, 2016 11:27 am
by buckmarkduck
karlhungis wrote:So is Hoke an actual possibility or just a message board pipe dream? Has he been contacted by the ducks?
There have been multiple reports in both Michigan (mlive) and Oregon that he interviewed for the job.