Page 1 of 2
Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 9:33 am
by pezsez1
We're one year out of competing for a national championship and there seems to be more than one person who thinks we have a coaching problem.
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 9:46 am
by Duck24
Fire everybody! The sky is falling! Next stop, Beaver status!
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 9:47 am
by SuperDuck
pezsez1 wrote:We're one year out of competing for a national championship and there seems to be more than one person who thinks we have a coaching problem.
I know. Dumb, isn't it?
Oregon is 22-5 over the past 2 seasons and with the exception of the loss to Ohio State, all 4 of the other losses were almost 100% attributed to major injuries. Jake Fisher and Vernon Adams. That leaves one loss that was actually what I'd consider to be an actual acceptable "loss". The rest was just bad luck.
Take away the 4 losses this season due to injuries and the injury to Mariota vs Stanford 2 years ago, and Oregon would be 38-3. Of course, no one knows what would have happened in the playoffs this year if we'd made it, but really, everyone should look at those games and realize how ridiculous it is to question the coaching staff. That's even with the Don Pellum defense!
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 9:49 am
by pezsez1
Right. If you want to see a school with a coaching problem, look at USC. They have so much talent, they've been picked to win national titles in recent years even more than we have... and they can barely finish inside the top 25.
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 10:07 am
by karlhungis
You are the same person that defended DP when others were calling for his head. The ones calling for his head ended up being right in the long run. Maybe...just maybe, there is an issue with the program and you just can't see it through your green tinted glasses.
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 10:24 am
by pezsez1
You are the same person that defended DP when others were calling for his head. The ones calling for his head ended up being right in the long run. Maybe...just maybe, there is an issue with the program and you just can't see it through your green tinted glasses.
No, I'm the person who urged people to be rational and not jump the gun after we struggled for a few games early this season... because our defense last season was statistically above average, there was no reason to start waving pitchforks so early this year, especially with such a young secondary.
By the way, I'm also the guy two seasons ago (Pellum's first) who correctly identified our defense as being above-average before the season's midway point. By the end of the year, most people agreed with me.
And this last season -- although I urged people to be patient -- by the year's end, I agreed that it was time to make a change. And I came to that conclusion DESPITE our defense actually improving for much of the second-half of the season. That's because I was able to remain objective (it's a skill) and actually break down our failings in the context of each game. Pellum's biggest problem wasn't his scheme, but his failure to make key in-game adjustments -- and that's something a lot of the parrots in here didn't start repeating until I brought it up.
If anything, that makes most of us 1-1 in terms of how we judged Pellum's defenses.
And now, again, I'm asking people to step off the crazy train and use some common sense.
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 10:48 am
by dthomas=ddixon
Why does everything have to be thought of in absolutes? You can still really like Helf while being critical of him. You can also really dislike him while recognizing his strong suits.
Helf is great coach IMO but the staff really flubbed it up in some areas of recruiting and certain games (Alamo bowl, wazzu, etc) this year. If there's anyone who deserves major criticism it's Pellum, who failed in every area that he was responsible for.
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 10:59 am
by Phalanx
Guys, today is a day to celebrate. We have new blood in key coaching positions (finally). We filled the major hole in the defense at linebacker very well. It looks like a pretty good QB is coming in to give our young guys another year to develop. We are in much better shape than this time last year, it seems to me. Yeah, we lost a running back, but it kinda seems like he wouldn't have played much this year anyway, doesn't it? I'm excited to see what Brooks-James and Griffin can do, and they are both underclassmen.
It seems like we lose a big star recruit every year, and we should be used to it by now. If you look at the history of our five-star recruits, it is surprising how few of them actually pan out. We've been getting it done with three and four star guys the whole time, and I expect it to continue. Lets just enjoy the ride.
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 11:05 am
by pezsez1
I agree, it's healthy to question. We're fans -- if we didn't question things, we'd have nothing to do.
But to suggest we have a coaching problem is just overkill. That goes beyond questioning.
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 11:15 am
by dthomas=ddixon
pezsez1 wrote:I agree, it's healthy to question. We're fans -- if we didn't question things, we'd have nothing to do.
But to suggest we have a coaching problem is just overkill. That goes beyond questioning.
Yes, it is.
It just seems to be human nature to take one side or the other. Either Helf is the greatest or the worst ha.
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 11:20 am
by GoDucksIn09
Nothing of what I have said is not true. We lost 2 games at home this year. Fact. One of those losses was by 42 points. Fact. One of the worst home losses ever. Fact. We nearly lost to Oregon state after being comfortably ahead. Fact. We were up against Washington state and still lost in overtime... fact. We were up against TCU 31-0 and lost... Fact. In the recruiting cycle we ranked as high as 11th and the top Pac 12 school. Now we are fifth in the conference. These are all facts. For those who want to question anything I have said regarding the coaches today then are questioning the facts. I am merely stating facts. Nothing more. As a cop would say from Dragnet years ago... Just the facts.
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 11:27 am
by dthomas=ddixon
GoDucksIn09 wrote:Nothing of what I have said is not true. We lost 2 games at home this year. Fact. One of those losses was by 42 points. Fact. One of the worst home losses ever. Fact. We nearly lost to Oregon state after being comfortably ahead. Fact. We were up against Washington state and still lost in overtime... fact. We were up against TCU 31-0 and lost... Fact. In the recruiting cycle we ranked as high as 11th and the top Pac 12 school. Now we are fifth in the conference. These are all facts. For those who want to question anything I have said regarding the coaches today then are questioning the facts. I am merely stating facts. Nothing more. As a cop would say from Dragnet years ago... Just the facts.
Agreed, but I would say that almost all of that falls directly on Pellum's shoulders.
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 11:35 am
by greenyellow
GoDucksIn09 wrote:Nothing of what I have said is not true. We lost 2 games at home this year. Fact. One of those losses was by 42 points. Fact. One of the worst home losses ever. Fact. We nearly lost to Oregon state after being comfortably ahead. Fact. We were up against Washington state and still lost in overtime... fact. We were up against TCU 31-0 and lost... Fact. In the recruiting cycle we ranked as high as 11th and the top Pac 12 school. Now we are fifth in the conference. These are all facts. For those who want to question anything I have said regarding the coaches today then are questioning the facts. I am merely stating facts. Nothing more. As a cop would say from Dragnet years ago... Just the facts.
Agree with this for the most part. Pellum as recruiting coordinator sucked big-time this year by targeting so many guys they fell out of it really early and were left with almost no one the final month. Getting only 2 commits in the last month while losing 4-5 guys in the same timespan is not good recruiting. Thank god the recruiting sanctions are over and Helfrich and staff are no longer hamstrung.
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 11:46 am
by UOducksTK1
Lol I was worried the server crashed because of increased activity. To find out that this was only about members on the forum is quite a relief.
Re: Is there a forum problem
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 11:56 am
by pezsez1
Oh man, TK... sorry if I made you panic!
