Page 1 of 1

my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 3:06 pm
by gofightingducks
It may not be the highest rated but considering the less than stellar season, the end of season coaching changes, the Alamo Bowl debacle and the improved coaching and recruiting within the conference it is not a bad class. I like the idea that despite the very slim chances of landing the blue chip guys so late in the game the coaches swung for the fences rather than settling on guys, going with the back ups. with the new coaches in place this next recruiting class should be much improved. A lot of criticism to Helf for such a "medicore" class but had the coaches settled for the 2-3 star guys people would have complained about that. I for one applaud him for making the coaching changes and getting a great recruiter in Hoke and a guy that can develop QBs in Yost and again despite the slim odds going after the blue chip talent, even though they only really got Simms late in the game, though Kirby was a good late addition.

I am excited for the future and think Helf is doing everything necessary to right the ship from a "bad" season because it could be worse we could have all of the talent in the world like USC and still be medicore or be the beavers.

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 3:18 pm
by pudgejeff
gofightingducks wrote:It may not be the highest rated but considering the less than stellar season, the end of season coaching changes, the Alamo Bowl debacle and the improved coaching and recruiting within the conference it is not a bad class. I like the idea that despite the very slim chances of landing the blue chip guys so late in the game the coaches swung for the fences rather than settling on guys, going with the back ups. with the new coaches in place this next recruiting class should be much improved. A lot of criticism to Helf for such a "medicore" class but had the coaches settled for the 2-3 star guys people would have complained about that. I for one applaud him for making the coaching changes and getting a great recruiter in Hoke and a guy that can develop QBs in Yost and again despite the slim odds going after the blue chip talent, even though they only really got Simms late in the game, though Kirby was a good late addition.

I am excited for the future and think Helf is doing everything necessary to right the ship from a "bad" season because it could be worse we could have all of the talent in the world like USC and still be medicore or be the beavers.
The problem is, the success/failure of a season doesn't usually rate to that years class but the next. So this should have been built off the national championship appearance/heisman trophy season from last year and I think that's where a lot of the frustration stems from.

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 3:24 pm
by UOducksTK1
Yeah I'm excited for the future. VA's injury, coaching changes, and a rough recruiting class made this a stranger year than usual. Here's to basketball and a new start for the football team next year. I'm very confident we end up with a top 15 class (if not top 10) next year.

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 3:30 pm
by greenyellow
UOducksTK1 wrote:Yeah I'm excited for the future. VA's injury, coaching changes, and a rough recruiting class made this a stranger year than usual. Here's to basketball and a new start for the football team next year. I'm very confident we end up with a top 15 class (if not top 10) next year.
Now that football is completely done, I'm ready to focus my attention solely on basketball now. At least they don't look like they'll be as disappointing.

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 3:35 pm
by gofightingducks
pudgejeff wrote:
gofightingducks wrote:It may not be the highest rated but considering the less than stellar season, the end of season coaching changes, the Alamo Bowl debacle and the improved coaching and recruiting within the conference it is not a bad class. I like the idea that despite the very slim chances of landing the blue chip guys so late in the game the coaches swung for the fences rather than settling on guys, going with the back ups. with the new coaches in place this next recruiting class should be much improved. A lot of criticism to Helf for such a "medicore" class but had the coaches settled for the 2-3 star guys people would have complained about that. I for one applaud him for making the coaching changes and getting a great recruiter in Hoke and a guy that can develop QBs in Yost and again despite the slim odds going after the blue chip talent, even though they only really got Simms late in the game, though Kirby was a good late addition.

I am excited for the future and think Helf is doing everything necessary to right the ship from a "bad" season because it could be worse we could have all of the talent in the world like USC and still be medicore or be the beavers.
The problem is, the success/failure of a season doesn't usually rate to that years class but the next. So this should have been built off the national championship appearance/heisman trophy season from last year and I think that's where a lot of the frustration stems from.

I agree with that however I think you can see that a lot of this seasons class was committed early as a result of the NC run but then the poor season and coaching changes saw later in the year guys decommit and guys that looked promising end up going elsewhere. I think those guys bought into the negativity of the media and of course the others schools coaches. It sucks to lose some highly touted guys and not land any big recruits in the final hour like years past but overall this class is not as bad as I think some people are making it out to be. Oregon lost most of the big time recruits to the likes of Alabama, USC, etc. and it is not too often Oregon will win those battles. With an improved defensive performance this upcoming season and Hoke having a full season to recruit I think this will be a much better recruiting class and a bigger one at that with more scholarships available.

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 5:06 pm
by UOducksTK1
Oregon's recruiting class rankings by year (247):
2010: 13
2011: 12
2012: 13
2013: 19
2014: 21
2015: 16
2016: 27

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 5:29 pm
by maxduck
UOducksTK1 wrote:Oregon's recruiting class rankings by year (247):
2010: 13
2011: 12
2012: 13
2013: 19
2014: 21
2015: 16
2016: 27
A quick glance at the recruiting lists from the highest rated years show how misleading they can be.

2010--Lache Seastrunk, Curtis White, Dior Mathis, Ricky Heimuli, Dante Williams

2011--DAT, Devon Blackman, Tacoi Sumler, Andre Y, Anthony Wallace, BJ Kelly

2012--Arik Armstead, Byron Marshall, Bralon Addison, Jake Rodriguez, Dwayne Stanford

Obviously 2012 was a good year. With the exception of DAT the other two years the top ranked recruits didn't produce much for Oregon.

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 5:54 pm
by duckfan96
Some people will be satisfied with this years class, others will not be. And some would not be satisfied with anything, they would find a reason to complain about something. Don't you sort of have to take a wait and see approach? I mean on paper it isn't as good as years past, but who knows how good these kids can be?

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 6:54 pm
by UOducksTK1
maxduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:Oregon's recruiting class rankings by year (247):
2010: 13
2011: 12
2012: 13
2013: 19
2014: 21
2015: 16
2016: 27
A quick glance at the recruiting lists from the highest rated years show how misleading they can be.

2010--Lache Seastrunk, Curtis White, Dior Mathis, Ricky Heimuli, Dante Williams

2011--DAT, Devon Blackman, Tacoi Sumler, Andre Y, Anthony Wallace, BJ Kelly

2012--Arik Armstead, Byron Marshall, Bralon Addison, Jake Rodriguez, Dwayne Stanford

Obviously 2012 was a good year. With the exception of DAT the other two years the top ranked recruits didn't produce much for Oregon.
That list is a little skewed. You omit some higher ranked guys, and include lower ranked guys. For example:

2011- Lyerla, Ifo, and Johnstone were ranked higher than Sumler. French, Fisher, and Coleman were ranked higher than BJ, If you take the top 12 commits from this class, like 8 of them turned out good.

And same logic for some of the other classes too. Yeah take out a 5 star and a couple 4 stars and we go from top 15 to top 20. So 27 is even worse if you take out the outlying high rankers.

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 7:05 pm
by karlhungis
UOducksTK1 wrote:
maxduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:Oregon's recruiting class rankings by year (247):
2010: 13
2011: 12
2012: 13
2013: 19
2014: 21
2015: 16
2016: 27
A quick glance at the recruiting lists from the highest rated years show how misleading they can be.

2010--Lache Seastrunk, Curtis White, Dior Mathis, Ricky Heimuli, Dante Williams

2011--DAT, Devon Blackman, Tacoi Sumler, Andre Y, Anthony Wallace, BJ Kelly

2012--Arik Armstead, Byron Marshall, Bralon Addison, Jake Rodriguez, Dwayne Stanford

Obviously 2012 was a good year. With the exception of DAT the other two years the top ranked recruits didn't produce much for Oregon.
That list is a little skewed. You omit some higher ranked guys, and include lower ranked guys. For example:

2011- Lyerla, Ifo, and Johnstone were ranked higher than Sumler. French, Fisher, and Coleman were ranked higher than BJ, If you take the top 12 commits from this class, like 8 of them turned out good.

And same logic for some of the other classes too. Yeah take out a 5 star and a couple 4 stars and we go from top 15 to top 20. So 27 is even worse if you take out the outlying high rankers.
It also assumes that everyone in this class is going to pan out.

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 8:20 pm
by greenyellow
As much as people want to say it doesn't matter where a class is rated, it still helps to have a perceived high level of overall talent because even if you have the normal average of people who washout, you're still left with a lot of talent. A lower rated class doesn't have the same margin of error for misses because if your higher rated guys don't pan out, you're possibly left with a bunch of guys who may or may not be talented enough keep them at title contending strength.

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 8:21 pm
by maxduck
UOducksTK1 wrote:
maxduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:Oregon's recruiting class rankings by year (247):
2010: 13
2011: 12
2012: 13
2013: 19
2014: 21
2015: 16
2016: 27
A quick glance at the recruiting lists from the highest rated years show how misleading they can be.

2010--Lache Seastrunk, Curtis White, Dior Mathis, Ricky Heimuli, Dante Williams

2011--DAT, Devon Blackman, Tacoi Sumler, Andre Y, Anthony Wallace, BJ Kelly

2012--Arik Armstead, Byron Marshall, Bralon Addison, Jake Rodriguez, Dwayne Stanford

Obviously 2012 was a good year. With the exception of DAT the other two years the top ranked recruits didn't produce much for Oregon.
That list is a little skewed. You omit some higher ranked guys, and include lower ranked guys. For example:

2011- Lyerla, Ifo, and Johnstone were ranked higher than Sumler. French, Fisher, and Coleman were ranked higher than BJ, If you take the top 12 commits from this class, like 8 of them turned out good.

And same logic for some of the other classes too. Yeah take out a 5 star and a couple 4 stars and we go from top 15 to top 20. So 27 is even worse if you take out the outlying high rankers.
I just glanced at the ESPN rankings, didn't delve into detail.

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 9:15 pm
by wlduck
UOducksTK1 wrote:Oregon's recruiting class rankings by year (247):
2010: 13
2011: 12
2012: 13
2013: 19
2014: 21
2015: 16
2016: 27
There's two things I hate:

-Saying recruiting rankings don't matter because anyone can find the high ranked busts and the low ranked guys that turned into stars. We all know that happens. We also all know that Alabama just secured their 7th #1 class in the last nine years- think that has any causation with their 4th NC? I do. It's pretty easy to see that the teams that finish highest in recruiting rankings are the ones that finish top 10 and contend for titles. This isn't even contestable, although I grant you have to filter out a couple of outliers. Fortunately, Oregon has been the most noticeable outlier, consistently finishing higher than their ranking.

- Overreacting to any single data point. Looking at those numbers above, 2016 is certainly concerning, but it's not like it's suddenly 50th (all though to be fair I think 27 is the highest ranking I have seen from any of the recruiting services- most have us in the 30's, which is even more concerning).

Oregon consistently outperforms rankings based on a variety of things- our recruits all get into school, in the past we have had a distinct schematic advantage (yes, I went all Charley Weiss on you), and we have done a good job at talent evaluation and cultural fit (with obvious QB misses as exceptions- I know). It looks like the schematic advantage on offense is mostly gone- we are relying on players more than system as evidenced by the successes with MM and VA, and the failures without them. I believe to continue our success longer term we are going to need to bump those rankings up by about an average of about 5 places yearly.

However, I think we can survive this class and thrive if we get back on track in 2017. Based on a few of our early recruits, the restoration of all of our visits, and the fact that the staff will have been in place for a full year I think we are in good position to do this. I would be more disappointed with a 15-20 ranking next year than this years ranking. I think a 5-10 ranking is possible, and needs to happen. If we fall short again, I'll probably be more in line with those that don't think Helfrich is the guy.

One other positive about this years class- it does address needs fairly well, at least on paper.

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 9:39 pm
by UOducksTK1
maxduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:
maxduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:Oregon's recruiting class rankings by year (247):
2010: 13
2011: 12
2012: 13
2013: 19
2014: 21
2015: 16
2016: 27
A quick glance at the recruiting lists from the highest rated years show how misleading they can be.

2010--Lache Seastrunk, Curtis White, Dior Mathis, Ricky Heimuli, Dante Williams

2011--DAT, Devon Blackman, Tacoi Sumler, Andre Y, Anthony Wallace, BJ Kelly

2012--Arik Armstead, Byron Marshall, Bralon Addison, Jake Rodriguez, Dwayne Stanford

Obviously 2012 was a good year. With the exception of DAT the other two years the top ranked recruits didn't produce much for Oregon.
That list is a little skewed. You omit some higher ranked guys, and include lower ranked guys. For example:

2011- Lyerla, Ifo, and Johnstone were ranked higher than Sumler. French, Fisher, and Coleman were ranked higher than BJ, If you take the top 12 commits from this class, like 8 of them turned out good.

And same logic for some of the other classes too. Yeah take out a 5 star and a couple 4 stars and we go from top 15 to top 20. So 27 is even worse if you take out the outlying high rankers.
I just glanced at the ESPN rankings, didn't delve into detail.
Fair enough. Ultimately, it is just numbers. I have faith that the coaches can take a below-average ranked class by Oregon standards and make it work. Moreso than the rankings itself like others have mentioned, is how the class didn't fulfill some weaknesses and how many decommits we had. But I'm confident, we will balance things out in the 2017 class. No biggie, just somewhat disappointing.

Re: my take on this recruiting class

Posted: Thu Feb 04, 2016 1:07 am
by GrantDuck
Bottom line is, for whatever reason, Helfrich hasn't closed as well as Chip. could be the recruiting restrictions or it could be charisma/connection.

Hopefully with Hoke in the fold, we can get back into the top 15 range.