Page 1 of 2
I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2016 6:47 am
by StevensTechU
This is likely going to be my most debatable/controversial post on this board, so I'll say that from the jump. It has to do with Oregon's big time QB commit Ryan Kelley, the #1 ranked dual-threat QB in the class of 2017 according to ESPN, and #10 overall QB according to the 247sports composite (an aggregate industry ranking of sorts).
As the title indicates, I'm not convinced -- yet -- that Kelley is the second-coming, as I sometimes read on here and very often see on the Oregon 247sports board. In the last couple years, I've become somewhat a HUDL nut, and in particular been curious what the HS film of guys who turned out to be great college players (Trevone Boykin, Cam Newton, Marcus Mariota, Vernon Adams) and not-so-great (Michael Eubank, Jeff Lockie, Jake Rodrigues) looked like in their high school days.
Where I'm at now is that with Kelley, I still think he has a ways to go. More than some other players. And further, his development between his sophomore year and junior year scares me a little bit, as other players around the country seem to possibly be catching up and passing him by as it's possible he's plateaued. Let me make my case this way:
This is Ryan Kelley's junior film.
http://www.hudl.com/athlete/3698560/hig ... /308650515
This is Charlie Brewer's film. Brewer is a fringe 2*-3* QB from Texas that runs a 4.6 40 (faster than Kelley), and holds just 2 offers.
http://www.hudl.com/athlete/2602920/hig ... /326074375
To the naked eye, who looks better? Do they seem comparable? (in my opinion, both should be rated at 4* QBs, but that's just me)
Questioning Kelley's status as the country's best dual threat QB in his class has crept up as he's failed to be considered a top performer at both Nike and Rivals camps, and as I've compared his Jr year film to other players, and compared his recent development to others. Kelley is way ahead of where Boykin or Connor Cook were in their Jr years, but they each made huge strides going into their last year of high school, and it propelled them to great college careers. I'm going to be very curious to see how Kelley plays, and how he leads his team this year, as I think he still has too much development left for any of us to label him the 'next great' or 'most important Oregon recruit' just yet.
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2016 8:11 am
by jimmy12
The only person I have read that calls him the best most important recruit is Jhop. I have literally not seen Jhop hit a prediction about anything yet. Not one thing. Look at this twitter, it's full of predictions that went the other way.
As for Kelly, he has time when he comes in. I think the QBs on the roster now, albeit unproven, are better than we had last year. Adams was the outlier. Everything else was just bad. I think with Yost and the new potential on the roster, we're already in a better position. When Kelly comes in, he'll have a year maybe two under a proven QB coach. If he doesn't develop in year 1, then we recruit 2 the following year.
Why did the QB lull happen? It goes back to one of my previous posts last year. Frost is a seemingly good guy and was a good college football player, but as a coach he was ehhhh.. Our receivers have exploded with quality when he became the O coordinator and Lubick came in and actually started recruiting/ developing the WRs. As a QB coach, there was ZERO development under Frost. This is why, in my opinion, we had the lapse last year. That falls solely on Frost. Frost did seemingly call game plays pretty well. Calling plays is the one question mark for Lubick. Can he call games and adapt to game situations?
As a homer, I think we're much better off with Lubick coaching the WR's. I also want to believe that we are in a better spot with him running the offense. We will see. Regarding the QBs, we are light years better with a proven QB coach now developing and recruiting our QBs. No more Frost is fine by me.
Lastly, it could not get worse than Pellum. Hoke has got to be an improvement. Hand it to Helf he made some HUGE changes to address the blatant issues that were hidden by Marcus.
My rant is over.
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2016 9:34 am
by mdm0302
I think the most interesting thing about about the kelley dilemma is that his commitment is keeping us from offering the QB from the school Marcus went to (I'm assuming thats why we havent offered). pretty sure he has a lot of offers at this point including SC. Oregon was his dream school a while back. If we take Kelley and he doesn't pan out it would be very frustrating considering we could have gone the other way and cemented a larger recruiting foundation in Hawaii and St. Louis High. I kind of feel like not offering the kid over there might hurt our presence too - especially if he goes to SC or another big school and does big things.
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2016 7:58 pm
by buckmarkduck
It's says volumes, at least to me, that he has yet to get that elite 11 invite. I'm worried this is one last Frost fail as a qb recruiter.
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Tue Apr 05, 2016 7:50 am
by StevensTechU
mdm0302 wrote:I think the most interesting thing about about the kelley dilemma is that his commitment is keeping us from offering the QB from the school Marcus went to (I'm assuming thats why we havent offered). pretty sure he has a lot of offers at this point including SC. Oregon was his dream school a while back. If we take Kelley and he doesn't pan out it would be very frustrating considering we could have gone the other way and cemented a larger recruiting foundation in Hawaii and St. Louis High. I kind of feel like not offering the kid over there might hurt our presence too - especially if he goes to SC or another big school and does big things.
Kelley was offered over Tagavailoa after an evaluation by Scott Frost, and presumably other members of the offensive staff. Kelley's commitment isn't "keeping us from offering" Tua, it was the desired course of action. After seeing both of their sophomore film, personally I think it was the right choice. Kelley looked better. Now about 9 months later and a junior season in the books, it's possible that Tua has passed Ryan by. But I just want to make the point that in this case, Ryan was the big fish, and Oregon got him. It wasn't a case of offering our second choice too early.
After following this stuff a few years, I'm somewhat frustrated with Oregon's lack of importance placed on geographic recruiting. Each year, I see big time recruits get swayed by the idea of playing with guys that are from their area, even in destitute places like Norman, OK, Lincoln, NE, and Ann Arbor, MI. Oregon needs a strong foothold in Oregon, Hawai'i, Utah, Idaho, NorCal, Eastern Washington, San Diego, and Nevada to keep the talent at a level where it can be a national-caliber program for many years.
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Tue Apr 05, 2016 9:53 am
by buckmarkduck
Idk I personally think Tua is to small, and lacks the big arm. I thinks UO fans overrate him because of his ties to Marcus. Look he's not now will he ever be, Marcus Mariota. I'm also not a fan of Martell, he reminds me of Tate Forcier.
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Tue Apr 05, 2016 1:25 pm
by mdm0302
buckmarkduck wrote:Idk I personally think Tua is to small, and lacks the big arm. I thinks UO fans overrate him because of his ties to Marcus. Look he's not now will he ever be, Marcus Mariota. I'm also not a fan of Martell, he reminds me of Tate Forcier.
don't need to be a prototypical NFL QB like Marcus to succeed at Oregon. Plus, Tua has a above average wingspan and hand size

Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Tue Apr 05, 2016 1:35 pm
by buckmarkduck
Haha touché mbm... I don't know about Lubick and Yost, but I know for a fact Frost wasn't interested in Tua or Martel because of their size. Adams was great for us, but he also had proven success in college.
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Tue Apr 05, 2016 1:47 pm
by mdm0302
buckmarkduck wrote:Haha touché mbm... I don't know about Lubick and Yost, but I know for a fact Frost wasn't interested in Tua or Martel because of their size. Adams was great for us, but he also had proven success in college.
i just don't think size is important in college as it is in the NFL for success. Tua will probably ball out somewhere and then get drafted in the 5th round!
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Tue Apr 05, 2016 2:38 pm
by Wildcat-Duck
The walking across the goal line by Kelley irritates me. Mariota's highlights were the best I have seen from a high school player.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tXFHH1DkfS8
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Tue Apr 05, 2016 2:56 pm
by UOducksTK1
I wouldn't put it past Kelley potentially decommitting too. I have no inside information or anything, but things happen when there's this much time before signing day.
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Tue Apr 05, 2016 3:03 pm
by jimmy12
You're going to paste who?
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Tue Apr 05, 2016 4:44 pm
by greenyellow
The debate between Kelley and Tagovailoa is one that I don't think will be answered for many years (if at all) and something I knew would happen. People were really high on Tua due to his ties with Marcus and all the publicity he'd already gotten, but you tell there was confusion from a good amount of fans after Kelley's commitment because he was sort of an unknown. From what I've seen posted, many analysts feel Kelley's refinement in the passing game and potential to grow in both size (he's put on nearly 20 lbs since the end of his JR season and has the frame to put on more) and skill are what put him ahead of Tua in the eyes of Oregon's coaches.
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Wed Apr 06, 2016 10:47 am
by gosterman01
I personally think a lot of people will be surprised by Kelley. You have to remember how young he is as well. Get him in our system surround him by all of our talent and with Yost as his QB coach....sky is the limit IMHO with him. I am for one fully behind Kelley and think we made a great early offer. From everything I've read about and seen from him and fam he's all Duck.
Re: I'm not convinced yet
Posted: Sun May 08, 2016 9:13 pm
by UOducksTK1
UOducksTK1 wrote:I wouldn't put it past Kelley potentially decommitting too. I have no inside information or anything, but things happen when there's this much time before signing day.
My annual correct prediction needs horn tooting to outweigh my daily incorrect predictions. I can probably get hired at 247 now.