Page 1 of 2

Tate Martell

Posted: Wed May 04, 2016 11:28 pm
by thomas time
decommits from A & M

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 12:35 am
by greenyellow
Looks like things are going to hell in a handbasket down at aTm as their WR coach went on a bit of a Twitter tirade after Martell decommitted. That tirade has also caused their other QB commit to decommit and 2 top WR recruits (including Tyjon Lindsey) to eliminate them.

http://www.oregonlive.com/recruiting/in ... trati.html

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 8:50 am
by damascusduck
Except what the coach originally said was true. A commitment is worthless. Martell's second decommit now. I wouldn't touch this Diva with a 10 ft pole. It's aslo time for football to have an early signing window like bball does.

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 9:32 am
by pudgejeff
damascusduck wrote:Except what the coach originally said was true. A commitment is worthless. Martell's second decommit now. I wouldn't touch this Diva with a 10 ft pole. It's aslo time for football to have an early signing window like bball does.
SMH, these are 16/17 year old kids being courted by people that do this for a living. These kind of comments just blow my mind.

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 9:41 am
by greenyellow
damascusduck wrote:Except what the coach originally said was true. A commitment is worthless. Martell's second decommit now. I wouldn't touch this Diva with a 10 ft pole. It's aslo time for football to have an early signing window like bball does.
While it may be partially true, a coach can't and shouldn't be saying those types of things publicly, especially a few minutes after a decommitment and and then saying it wasn't about anyone in particular, which was a lie. You also have to look at it from the perspective of the recruit. They're getting all these people coming at them while they're trying to make one of the biggest decisions in their lives. Add in media covering their every move if they're high-profile recruits and you get a really bad mix.

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 12:10 pm
by Duck24
pudgejeff wrote:
damascusduck wrote:Except what the coach originally said was true. A commitment is worthless. Martell's second decommit now. I wouldn't touch this Diva with a 10 ft pole. It's aslo time for football to have an early signing window like bball does.
SMH, these are 16/17 year old kids being courted by people that do this for a living. These kind of comments just blow my mind.
^^^FTW^^^

It's too bad these recruits can't be as perfect and decisive as those naysayers on message boards were when they were high school juniors and seniors. These are kids making life changing decisions, get over it. It has happened before and it will happen again. Doesn't make him a diva or anything like that. Given what happened at A&M at the QB position with two 5 star guys transferring out and the OC who he committed to leaving, what did you expect?

Didn't see any of you critics calling Terry Wilson a diva for backing out of his commitment to Nebraska nor De'Anthony or even Darron Thomas for that matter.

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 12:16 pm
by FlDuckFan
Duck24 wrote:
pudgejeff wrote:
damascusduck wrote:Except what the coach originally said was true. A commitment is worthless. Martell's second decommit now. I wouldn't touch this Diva with a 10 ft pole. It's aslo time for football to have an early signing window like bball does.
SMH, these are 16/17 year old kids being courted by people that do this for a living. These kind of comments just blow my mind.
^^^FTW^^^

It's too bad these recruits can't be as perfect and decisive as those naysayers on message boards were when they were high school juniors and seniors. These are kids making life changing decisions, get over it. It has happened before and it will happen again. Doesn't make him a diva or anything like that. Given what happened at A&M at the QB position with two 5 star guys transferring out and the OC who he committed to leaving, what did you expect?

Didn't see any of you critics calling Terry Wilson a diva for backing out of his commitment to Nebraska nor De'Anthony or even Darron Thomas for that matter.

I suspect most of the critics don't remember what it was like when they were 16/17.

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 1:09 pm
by justducky0
Was it Huff or Addison that committed to every school he visited? Doesn't really matter which one, they both turned out to representatives of Oregon. soooo there go that argument.

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 1:23 pm
by GrandpaDuck
The A & M coach was a complete hypocrite and douche.

1) He has bounced jobs repeatedly. Where's his loyalty to his former employers and and kids he recruited just the year before?
2) He was committing an NCAA violation in his comments about a recruit
3) A & M recruits other team's committed players all the time.
4) He called his critic soft when it was him crying and ranting about a player doing what he encourages others to do.

Its a shame A&M put a muzzle on him, he was great entertainment for a couple of hours.

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 1:44 pm
by damascusduck
Duck24 wrote:
pudgejeff wrote:
damascusduck wrote:Except what the coach originally said was true. A commitment is worthless. Martell's second decommit now. I wouldn't touch this Diva with a 10 ft pole. It's aslo time for football to have an early signing window like bball does.
SMH, these are 16/17 year old kids being courted by people that do this for a living. These kind of comments just blow my mind.
^^^FTW^^^

It's too bad these recruits can't be as perfect and decisive as those naysayers on message boards were when they were high school juniors and seniors. These are kids making life changing decisions, get over it. It has happened before and it will happen again. Doesn't make him a diva or anything like that. Given what happened at A&M at the QB position with two 5 star guys transferring out and the OC who he committed to leaving, what did you expect?

Didn't see any of you critics calling Terry Wilson a diva for backing out of his commitment to Nebraska nor De'Anthony or even Darron Thomas for that matter.
This is his second decommit. Here's a novel thought. Don't commit if you aren't ready to. I'd tell my son that if he commits, he needs to stick to it unless something really serious comes up.....Wilson's situation was way different. New coaching staff with a different style offense. Riley didn't even recruit him. That too me comes under "serious" reason. Wilson also didn't have a "look at me" type social media presence. Martell comes across that way IMO.

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 1:51 pm
by jimmy12
Did any of you read the reason Tate decommitted? The coach from UCLA didn't exactly treat him well. I think this was a writing on the wall thing between Tate and their new QB coach.

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 2:09 pm
by StevensTechU
Second decommitment, but in both instances his primary recruiter/coach left the school. To me, that's pretty forgivable, especially when the new guy shows obvious disinterest in bringing you in.

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 2:24 pm
by Duck24
damascusduck wrote:
Duck24 wrote:
pudgejeff wrote:
damascusduck wrote:Except what the coach originally said was true. A commitment is worthless. Martell's second decommit now. I wouldn't touch this Diva with a 10 ft pole. It's aslo time for football to have an early signing window like bball does.
SMH, these are 16/17 year old kids being courted by people that do this for a living. These kind of comments just blow my mind.
^^^FTW^^^

It's too bad these recruits can't be as perfect and decisive as those naysayers on message boards were when they were high school juniors and seniors. These are kids making life changing decisions, get over it. It has happened before and it will happen again. Doesn't make him a diva or anything like that. Given what happened at A&M at the QB position with two 5 star guys transferring out and the OC who he committed to leaving, what did you expect?

Didn't see any of you critics calling Terry Wilson a diva for backing out of his commitment to Nebraska nor De'Anthony or even Darron Thomas for that matter.
This is his second decommit. Here's a novel thought. Don't commit if you aren't ready to. I'd tell my son that if he commits, he needs to stick to it unless something really serious comes up.....Wilson's situation was way different. New coaching staff with a different style offense. Riley didn't even recruit him. That too me comes under "serious" reason. Wilson also didn't have a "look at me" type social media presence. Martell comes across that way IMO.
Of course it's different when the flip benefits Oregon. First off, Martell's first commitment was when he was like 14 years old and the coach he committed to left. Really gonna hold that against him? Secondly, look at what has happened at A&M since he committed there. Total upheaval at the QB position and offensive coaching staff. That isn't "serious" to you? The OC who recruited him is gone and their coaching staff has run off the last two top flight QB's they've landed. Not "serious"' enough for you?

As was mentioned above, Huff committed to two or three schools before finally signing with Oregon. Addison flipped to Oregon at the last minute from A&M. De'Anthony went behind the USC coaches backs to visit and eventually commit to Oregon. Don't think any of those changed their minds for "serious" reasons by your definition but didn't see you on here criticizing them. Hypocrites much?

I could care less if the kid commits to 10 schools, it's their decision to make and live with. At the end of the day, he's making the decision he feels is best for himself so who are we to judge? The "fans" who criticize high school kids making potentially the biggest decision of their lives are insufferable.

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 2:28 pm
by oregontrack
i used to follow recruiting.

then i stopped and my sports fandom life got so much better.

i commend those of you who stick with it. amazing the emotional spectrums folks put themselves through over kids who never play for the school they root for.

Re: Tate Martell

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 2:55 pm
by jimmy12
You stopped following so much you posted on a recruiting board? I am confused.

I agree with you STU