Page 1 of 1

NCAA Rules On Commitments

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 2:47 pm
by SuperDuck
I decided to start this thread because I didn't want to hijack the threads on Kelley or Martell.

Basically, the rules are a mess. I was watching "Mike & Mike" discuss this on ESPN yesterday. From a kids standpoint, most good players have several schools to choose from. Many of these kids get a ton of calls, letters, texts, etc and because there's nothing legally "binding" in a so called "commitment", that word is really quite meaningless until they sign their name on the dotted line.

On the other hand, coaches, who have massive annual salaries at stake, are left to take the word of these young kids when they "say" they're coming to their school. Since there's nothing legally binding there's nothing from leaving programs hanging, sometimes in a BIG way, when they decommit. Especially if they do it late in the process.

Many coaches have been pushing to have the signing date moved up to before the Bowl season. I tend to agree. These kids are being given a very expensive full ride scholarship at major universities with major opportunities associated with getting a degree from those schools.

Yes, kids are young, they are immature and they're going to change their minds. Hey, they're under a LOT of pressure! That's not to mention situations where they may have family finances to consider and some slick recruiter may be offering improper benefits.

Bottom line, I think that the rules should look something like this. Please feel free to correct me if I'm mistaken about something.

1. Kids should have a set amount of official (paid) visits. I believe it's currently 5, right?

2. Kids should have a set amount of unofficial visits. My thoughts behind this is that some kids have wealthy families and can trip all over the place, while others can't possibly afford it. I think limiting visits altogether would make sure that kids are very serious about the schools they visit. I'd set the unofficial visits at 2, that way a kid could visit at least 2 in-state schools and not lose any of their paid visit opportunities.

3. With few exceptions, the signing period should happen before the Bowl season. These kids have months to go through this process and coaches shouldn't be left holding the bag. If they're TRULY committed, they need to sign then.

4. If kids don't sign by a certain date they should have to wait until the next recruiting cycle. No loss of eligibility, they'd just have to wait a year if they can't make a decision in time. They'd receive no more visits the following year. The same choices would remain.

5. If a kid signs and changes his mind, he has to sit out a year - except in the event of hardship.

6. Kids should be able to qualify for a monthly stipend to offset impoverished families. I'm not taking about a lot of money, just enough to take care of their own needs while in school so their families don't have to worry about anything like that.

7. Coaches should be held to these kid's commitments, as well, after a certain date. If a kid signs, you're stuck with him - even if someone better comes along.

Did I leave something out? :?

I got distracted and lost my train of thought. My point is that major changes need to be made to this process.

Re: NCAA Rules On Commitments

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 3:22 pm
by GrandpaDuck
SuperDuck wrote:I decided to start this thread because I didn't want to hijack the threads on Kelley or Martell.

Basically, the rules are a mess. I was watching "Mike & Mike" discuss this on ESPN yesterday. From a kids standpoint, most good players have several schools to choose from. Many of these kids get a ton of calls, letters, texts, etc and because there's nothing legally "binding" in a so called "commitment", that word is really quite meaningless until they sign their name on the dotted line.

On the other hand, coaches, who have massive annual salaries at stake, are left to take the word of these young kids when they "say" they're coming to their school. Since there's nothing legally binding there's nothing from leaving programs hanging, sometimes in a BIG way, when they decommit. Especially if they do it late in the process.

Many coaches have been pushing to have the signing date moved up to before the Bowl season. I tend to agree. These kids are being given a very expensive full ride scholarship at major universities with major opportunities associated with getting a degree from those schools.

Yes, kids are young, they are immature and they're going to change their minds. Hey, they're under a LOT of pressure! That's not to mention situations where they may have family finances to consider and some slick recruiter may be offering improper benefits.

Bottom line, I think that the rules should look something like this. Please feel free to correct me if I'm mistaken about something.

1. Kids should have a set amount of official (paid) visits. I believe it's currently 5, right?

2. Kids should have a set amount of unofficial visits. My thoughts behind this is that some kids have wealthy families and can trip all over the place, while others can't possibly afford it. I think limiting visits altogether would make sure that kids are very serious about the schools they visit. I'd set the unofficial visits at 2, that way a kid could visit at least 2 in-state schools and not lose any of their paid visit opportunities.

3. With few exceptions, the signing period should happen before the Bowl season. These kids have months to go through this process and coaches shouldn't be left holding the bag. If they're TRULY committed, they need to sign then.

4. If kids don't sign by a certain date they should have to wait until the next recruiting cycle. No loss of eligibility, they'd just have to wait a year if they can't make a decision in time. They'd receive no more visits the following year. The same choices would remain.

5. If a kid signs and changes his mind, he has to sit out a year - except in the event of hardship.

6. Kids should be able to qualify for a monthly stipend to offset impoverished families. I'm not taking about a lot of money, just enough to take care of their own needs while in school so their families don't have to worry about anything like that.

7. Coaches should be held to these kid's commitments, as well, after a certain date. If a kid signs, you're stuck with him - even if someone better comes along.

Did I leave something out? :?

I got distracted and lost my train of thought. My point is that major changes need to be made to this process.
I disagree with #3.

A signing date between the end of the regular season and the bowl season puts teams going to a bowl at a disadvantage. Are bowl bound coaches going to coach or recruit in that period.

No 5. Penalizing the kid a year for a change of heart, can we call this the Dred Scott rule?

The fact is coaches lie. If their lips are moving they are probably lying. Sometimes kids figure it out before signing day, like when another kid is offered at the same position that they told you that you were a shoe-in to have that spot for 3 years from day 1 until you became a first round draft pick.

Coaches change jobs on their own or are fired. Kids that have signed to a school and have been recruiting you to join them switch.

Recruiting sucks, but mostly from the School's side. Its men paid millions of dollars to manipulate children. The rules should all lean in favor of the kids.

Re: NCAA Rules On Commitments

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 3:47 pm
by GrandpaDuck
To expand a little more. Suppose you are a Junior and are pressured into "verbally committing" to a mid major. They tell you if you don't verbally commit right now your offer will go to someone else. Its your best offer, you cant afford to let it go so you say sure I'll take it. Then you have a big senior year, and your slow to offer home state school you have been a fan of your whole life finally says they'll offer you. Should you be stuck? Should the hard work you put in between your Junior and Senior year be for nothing?

Now if you are one of the few 5 star kids, you tell a coach to pound sand knowing that they'll take you whenever you decide., but most kids don't have that leverage.

Re: NCAA Rules On Commitments

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 10:07 pm
by Duck07
I don't see a problem with how it is now other than that our priorities are totally out of whack. This just further reinforces that some of these players are not student athletes in any sense of the word. Frankly the less rules the Incas creates the better. They can't even enforce the rules they already have.

If a chemistry major changes minds after one term and decides to transfer, should that student suffer a hardship in transferring schools? Why would you punish a student for being wealthy and limiting their chance to visit other schools? From a parity standpoint, it would likely eliminate their chance at considering a school that they may have liked and on and on.

Frankly this is a very anti-American stance and im not going to stand around here and watch you bad the mouth the good old U S of A!

Re: NCAA Rules On Commitments

Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 10:08 pm
by Duck07
Incas? Classic autocorrect

Re: NCAA Rules On Commitments

Posted: Fri May 06, 2016 10:25 pm
by wlduck
Duck07 wrote:Incas? Classic autocorrect
The Incas knew how handle a decommit though, for sure.