Page 1 of 2
Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2016 6:43 pm
by StevensTechU
A year ago, nobody was talking about having more than one capable offensive center. At other times, we've seen injury strike at WR, QB, TE, and other spots along the lineup because in the sport of football, injury is as much a part of the game as coin flips and who gets the ball first. So my question to you fare people-- where along the depth chart are you most concerned?
You could take this question and pick a spot where you're not sold on the starter(s), or take the angle of where an injury would be the most substantial. To me, linebacker touches on both. I expect the starting lineup to be Ragin, Hotchkins, and Swain for most of the season, with Moi, Dye, and Mattingly backing them up, and DeQuan McDowell playing substantial snaps. That group already contains one true freshman (Troy Dye), and so with every possible injury, there is likely to be another true freshman running in from the sidelines. The young bucks are talented, but it's asking a lot to give meaningful minutes in your first term of college on a team that should compete for a conference crown. Also, as mentioned earlier, I have reservations about the starting group. If Ragin takes a big leap forward and Hotchkins can play the pass decently well (I have no questions about his ability to get in the backfield), then I'm feeling good, but those are not givens.
What say you?
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2016 7:02 pm
by buckmarkduck
My question is still depth at center. They had to use Hunt at center the other day, due to backups not being able to snap.
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2016 9:05 pm
by Kimber45
StevensTechU wrote:You could take this question and pick a spot where you're not sold on the starter(s), or take the angle of where an injury would be the most substantial. To me, linebacker touches on both. I expect the starting lineup to be Ragin, Hotchkins, and Swain for most of the season, with Moi, Dye, and Mattingly backing them up, and DeQuan McDowell playing substantial snaps. That group already contains one true freshman (Troy Dye), and so with every possible injury, there is likely to be another true freshman running in from the sidelines. The young bucks are talented, but it's asking a lot to give meaningful minutes in your first term of college on a team that should compete for a conference crown. Also, as mentioned earlier, I have reservations about the starting group. If Ragin takes a big leap forward and Hotchkins can play the pass decently well (I have no questions about his ability to get in the backfield), then I'm feeling good, but those are not givens.
What say you?
Boy, that's a tough question. Given that we are installing a new defensive scheme it's difficult to pick a spot where I'm not sold on the starters because we don't know the defensive depth chart. Spring game and Fall camp practice reports give some clues but injuries and/or player development could yield a very different 1st team defense on 9/3 than what we may think after the first week of practice. This will be unpopular, but I'm not sold (yet) on A. Maloata as the starting 3 tech. As you suggest, the LB group seems to need the most sorting out. Though methinks the same can bet said about the safety positions.
At what position we lack the most quality depth - I'll go with DBs as a whole. Seems like lots of DBs have come through the program recently and given us very little on the field production (or none). A. Springs seems to be a lock on one corner. I don't think we have a clear cut favorite for the other spot. Is it Ugo? And who is behind Springs? Just have zero sense for our cornerback depth chart and not a lot of confidence after last years performance. Safety spots also. Last year strips and interceptions were down, YAC was way up, and run support took a nose dive. There are lots of names on the roster (DBs) who are talented and show promise. When is M. McGraw going to do something? Is T. Robinson going to play corner or safety? Is J. Williams the real deal? Seisay going to play a year better than last year? [or wasn't he injured?] R. Daniels? K. Oliver? Lots of names; not a lot of resume for a fan to hang his hat on.
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2016 10:36 pm
by greenyellow
At corner, the top 4 are probably Springs, Lovette, Seisay, and Amadi with Griffin and Stewart as outside possibilities and likely ST guys. At safety, Williams, Daniels, and Robinson will be fighting for starting spots while Leiato, Oliver, and McGraw are going to be fighting for the back-up spots.
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2016 11:56 pm
by pudgejeff
greenyellow wrote:At corner, the top 4 are probably Springs, Lovette, Seisay, and Amadi with Griffin and Stewart as outside possibilities and likely ST guys. At safety, Williams, Daniels, and Robinson will be fighting for starting spots while Leiato, Oliver, and McGraw are going to be fighting for the back-up spots.
I thought Mcgraw moved to corner?
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2016 1:05 am
by GrantDuck
1. Defensive line for me since we're going to 4 down guys and haven't really recruited for that until some scrambling this year.
Nobody is proven at all and we have 4 spots to fill. Lots of *'s but not much experience/production an replacing a top 10 draft pick.
2. Center is the obvious one of course, but it's been discussed. Keep Hanson healthy!!
3. Easy #1 for me is Secondary. Basically, I really liked what I saw from Springs after the ASU INT last season was a different player. That 2nd corner spot and safety spots are...scary though. Ugo has looked awful in any game type situation, Lovette is a first year player at that position, and we saw a rotating door of guys that couldn't hack it last season there. At safety I like Williams IF he's healthy, Robinson is OK but nothing special..outside of that ?!?!?
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2016 6:06 am
by UofDuck
QB. Two guys battling for a spot and neither has ever taken a snap at this level. Behind them are a few guys who are just not the caliber we need.
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2016 6:24 am
by StevensTechU
My thoughts on some spots brought up:
Re: DBs- I feel really good about the corners. Springs is going to take another step forward, and all reports (not just Moseley, but from interviews with other players) Ugo Amadi is really stepping up and locking things down. Behind them, I feel good about Lovette and Seisay as second stringers. At safety, I think it will be Robinson and Williams, and I didn't realize how good Williams was playing before he got hurt until I re-watched WSU and uw this week. I'm feeling much better. Behind them, Daniels brings a lot of experience, and the rest are somewhat seasoned for 3rd and 4th options (Oliver, Griffin, McGraw).
Center- Hunt being able to play center is exactly the reason I'm NOT worried about center. There are a lot of guys who can play guard, so if Hunt has to play center like Hamani Stevens did a few years ago, that's fine.
DL- I don't know what we'll get out of Maloata, but I feel like a healthy Manu is going to tear things up. Behind them, I don't think the dropoff between them and Baker/Carlberg/Kaumatule is that large, which is why I'm more bullish than bearish.
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2016 10:48 am
by GrantDuck
Heard the same things last offseason with Ugo. Will believe it when I see it on Saturdays.
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2016 12:15 pm
by mdm0302
GrantDuck wrote:Heard the same things last offseason with Ugo. Will believe it when I see it on Saturdays.
the older i get the more I'm am on this page. Still optimistic though
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2016 1:12 pm
by GrantDuck
Don't get me wrong, Troy Hill was a disaster at first and turned out to be a very good corner as a senior.
Aaron Gipson was a joke for 2 years and then led the nation in INT's as a senior.
Just believe it when I see it overall.
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2016 1:22 pm
by buckmarkduck
GrantDuck wrote:Don't get me wrong, Troy Hill was a disaster at first and turned out to be a very good corner as a senior.
Aaron Gipson was a joke for 2 years and then led the nation in INT's as a senior.
Just believe it when I see it overall.
Troy was pretty good as a Fr, then regressed. He was even ahead of Ifo as Fr until getting hurt.
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2016 1:55 pm
by StevensTechU
Ifo got abused as a frosh. I still remember when T-Mitch covered Robert Woods the entire second half of the USC game because he was killing Ifo in the first.
Cornerback is one of the hardest positions to play on the field. Last year the coaches and players were saying Ugo was doing great for a FRESHMAN, which is very different than saying he's going to go out and lock down older competition. This year they're saying he's playing fantastic for ANYBODY. I'm optimistic.
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2016 9:23 pm
by Kimber45
greenyellow wrote:At corner, the top 4 are probably Springs, Lovette, Seisay, and Amadi with Griffin and Stewart as outside possibilities and likely ST guys. At safety, Williams, Daniels, and Robinson will be fighting for starting spots while Leiato, Oliver, and McGraw are going to be fighting for the back-up spots.
Thanks for your insight.
GrantDuck wrote:1. Defensive line for me since we're going to 4 down guys and haven't really recruited for that until some scrambling this year.<br abp="873"><br abp="874">Nobody is proven at all and we have 4 spots to fill. Lots of *'s but not much experience/production an replacing a top 10 draft pick.<br abp="875"><br abp="876"><br abp="877">
I'm going to go against you on this one GrantDuck. It may take a little while to fully acclimate to the 4-3 but we have a lot of quality kids available for Coach Aiken and Hoke to work with. IMO the D line has been the best unit on the team since '10-'11 when we last had an outstanding LB unit (Jordan included).
StevensTechU wrote:DL- I don't know what we'll get out of Maloata, . . .
I'm not down on A. Maloata at all I just think he's a natural NT. I question whether he has the range and moves/technique to excel at the DT spot. Maloata may well end up as our 1st string 3 tech because he's the best guy available. I do think Maloata is much more suited for 1 gap than 2 gap stuff. He'll be on the field a lot this coming year but his patented spin move last year was almost laughably ineffective. Strong bull rush though.
mdm0302 wrote:GrantDuck wrote:Heard the same things last offseason with Ugo. Will believe it when I see it on Saturdays.
the older i get the more I'm am on this page. Still optimistic though
Ugo was a true freshman last year. And played like a true freshman. That he played as a freshman is one of the reasons I question the DBs so much this year.
@ mdm0302, get your spirit squad sweater out of the hope chest you old bastard!
Re: Weaknesses in the Depth Chart
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2016 10:21 pm
by buckmarkduck
It's funny, I watched 5* Iman Marshall get burned plenty of times last year. Corners have a tough time as FR.