Page 1 of 1
2 points
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 4:27 pm
by chapelhillduck
Is it Nelson that calls it?
(On the second Hollins should have been wide open but stopped)
Re: 2 points
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 4:30 pm
by greenyellow
chapelhillduck wrote:Is it Nelson that calls it?
(On the second Hollins should have been wide open but stopped)
I think it is. Beginning to think teams are baiting Oregon into going for 2 because they know Oregon is greedy enough to keep trying them. What Oregon is doing is not smart and calculated anymore; it's borderline arrogant/stupid.
Re: 2 points
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 4:32 pm
by Alan
It's simply time to kick for one
Re: 2 points
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 4:57 pm
by Tray Dub
greenyellow wrote:chapelhillduck wrote:Is it Nelson that calls it?
(On the second Hollins should have been wide open but stopped)
I think it is. Beginning to think teams are baiting Oregon into going for 2 because they know Oregon is greedy enough to keep trying them. What Oregon is doing is not smart and calculated anymore; it's borderline arrogant/stupid.
I disagree. Before today we've been very successful with that strategy. I'm sure we convert significantly more than half of the ones we attempt, which means we're scoring more total points than we would if we just kicked PATs every time. Today we just got unlucky on two of 'em. Doesn't mean the whole strategy is flawed.
Re: 2 points
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 5:53 pm
by Alan
Just listened to Helf post game on the radio, he said it's always up to the player calling it on the field and he thought it was the right call each situation. BUT, just kick the dam ball and don't line up for two. (My thoughts)
Re: 2 points
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 5:57 pm
by pezsez1
Here's my view on 2-pt conversions...
I think we should approach our 2s the same why I approach roulette when I go to Vegas.
I only put down $5. If I win, I'll play it again. If I win again, I'll play again. If I win again, I'll play again. Etc.
But the moment I lose, I'm done.
I think going for 2 (if the alignment is in our favor) is both entertaining and worth the risk. It's good for our identity and good for morale. But if you miss out on more than one, then it really can come back to bite you.
Overall, I think folks are overreacting to today's 1-5 stat. The first miss cancelled out the first make, and the last two made sense at the time given the moment in the game. But the last three misses would have been extra-point kicks had we stopped going for two at 1-1. It was that third missed attempt that justified going for two on the fourth attempt, and it was the cumulative misses that justified the fifth attempt.
Re: 2 points
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 8:16 pm
by Everythingsducky
Alan wrote:Just listened to Helf post game on the radio, he said it's always up to the player calling it on the field and he thought it was the right call each situation. BUT, just kick the dam ball and don't line up for two. (My thoughts)
Agreed, but I also call BS on Helf. There is a point in the game where HE is the COACH, and should tell whomever responsible for the call to just kick the freakin ball. Or does he leave all decisions to the players? Ridiculous. You think Saban lets his players make all critical decisions?
Re: 2 points
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 9:00 pm
by midwestduck82
It's greedy and more importantly it's why there is a 1 in the loss column. I'm with Pez. Quit after the first fail. Take the high percentage points. Also, there is a chance of Nelson being injured when he's diving into piles of defenders.
Re: 2 points
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 2:56 pm
by Duck07
The decision up 4 to go for 2 is a basic coaching error, plain and simple. The first half pat's were one thing, that one was an idiotic decision for someone were constantly told is a genius.
Re: 2 points
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 9:30 pm
by QuackAttack92
Duck07 wrote:The decision up 4 to go for 2 is a basic coaching error, plain and simple. The first half pat's were one thing, that one was an idiotic decision for someone were constantly told is a genius.
Its beyond stupid...can no one on the sidelines do 3rd grade math? 5 point lead plus 7 if they score makes it possible that we could have won with a FG...of course they would have gone for two as well but why go for it there...just dumber than dumb
Re: 2 points
Posted: Mon Sep 19, 2016 8:12 am
by Bud Lee
I personally don't get it. I understand that there are studies and statistics that say the percentages tell you going for two makes more sense but I think it is crazy and if the Ducks would of gone for the extra points instead you have another ball game.
Re: 2 points
Posted: Mon Sep 19, 2016 8:15 am
by rockthief
The fans I know are shaking their heads wondering what the hell were the coaches doing
Re: 2 points
Posted: Mon Sep 19, 2016 8:28 am
by duckfan22
In certain situations you go for two. But to me this was insane. Helf said its up to the
players to access the d and go from there. It should not come down to that. Helf needs to
say we kick the extra point. Other teams are now prepared for it.
Re: 2 points
Posted: Mon Sep 19, 2016 11:14 am
by duck58
History of 2 point conversions since Chip. During Chips tenure we were 14/17 after 1st TD in game. We were 2/6 after 2nd plus TDs, All of these were dictated by game situation. After 1st TD Chip did not choose to go for 2. Strangely, the 2 pt conversions or lack of had no influence on the outcome of any game. His record would have been the same if we would have just kicked the extra pts.
2009- 3/3 and 0/1, 2010 - 5/5 and 2/3, 2011 - 3/4 and 0/2, 2012 - 3/5 and 0/0
Under Helf we are 7/15 after 1st TD and 2/14 after 2nd plus TDs. Maybe 5-6 were dictated by game situation. The rest were by choice. Only 2 made were against UC Davis. Again the 2pt conversions or lack of had no affect on the outcome of any game until Sat, You might say if we had attempted 4 and made all of them against MSU last year(not likely) it would have made a difference. If we had just kicked the extra pts. game would have went to overtime. If He had followed Chip's formula and kicked after the 2pt conversion on the 1st TD we would have had 36 pts and forced Nebraska to go for 2 after their last TD to go to OT.
2013 - 2/3 and 0/3, 2014 - 3/5 and 0/2, 2015 - 0/4 and 0/1(3rd OT at ASU), 2016 - 2/3 and 2/8
My opinion, therefore, is that the 2pt conversions have been more of a gimmick, and not the greatest thing since ice cream, as some think. And Helf certainly hasn't been as effective in converting them as Chip was.