Page 1 of 2
3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 4:45 pm
by GrantDuck
1. Really poor clock management to end the first half. I'm still 50/50 on Helfrich on the whole, but that was just a massive debacle.
2. Couldn't stop the run in the 2nd half consistently. Couldn't get pressure with 4 man pass rush at all.
3. Officiating. Phantom hold to kill our last drive. The too many men on the field where we didn't get a substitution chance that gave them an extra down , which they scored on, and 4 indefensible PI penalties. Worst..homering...ever.
There's lots of other little things(injuries, certain play calls, Prukop missing throws), but those were the big ones.
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 4:55 pm
by squintsdd
GrantDuck wrote:1. Really poor clock management to end the first half. I'm still 50/50 on Helfrich on the whole, but that was just a massive debacle.
2. Couldn't stop the run in the 2nd half consistently. Couldn't get pressure with 4 man pass rush at all.
3. Officiating. Phantom hold to kill our last drive. The too many men on the field where we didn't get a substitution chance that gave them an extra down , which they scored on, and 4 indefensible PI penalties. Worst..homering...ever.
There's lots of other little things(injuries, certain play calls, Prukop missing throws), but those were the big ones.
I think you might be homering a little. At least 2 of those PIs were correct, the hold on the last drive was correct.
What got us the loss were the penalties (135+ yards is ridiculous), Oregon's inability to stop the run, and all those really really stupid failed 2 point conversations. If Oregon had kicked an extra point every time after the successful conversion they would've won by a point.
I'm not calling for the firing of Helfrich, but he should be feeling his chair getting a little warm.
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 4:58 pm
by GrantDuck
The 2 point conversion complaining is utter nonsense, sorry.
Live by the sword/die by the sword. Where were the complaints when it was working?
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 4:59 pm
by QuackininBama
squintsdd wrote:GrantDuck wrote:1. Really poor clock management to end the first half. I'm still 50/50 on Helfrich on the whole, but that was just a massive debacle.
2. Couldn't stop the run in the 2nd half consistently. Couldn't get pressure with 4 man pass rush at all.
3. Officiating. Phantom hold to kill our last drive. The too many men on the field where we didn't get a substitution chance that gave them an extra down , which they scored on, and 4 indefensible PI penalties. Worst..homering...ever.
There's lots of other little things(injuries, certain play calls, Prukop missing throws), but those were the big ones.
I think you might be homering a little. At least 2 of those PIs were correct, the hold on the last drive was correct.
What got us the loss were the penalties (135+ yards is ridiculous), Oregon's inability to stop the run, and all those really really stupid failed 2 point conversations. If Oregon had kicked an extra point every time after the successful conversion they would've won by a point.
I'm not calling for the firing of Helfrich, but he should be feeling his chair getting a little warm.
I actually think that this should be Helfs last season. You either A. concede that Oregon will slip back into mediocrity and consider the Holiday bowl a great season, B. Accept that no longer will 4-5* kids consider the Ducks as a serious possibility, or C. Open up the checkbook and hire a big time coach. Those really are our choices now. We can continue the momentum with the excellent athletes we have now, or slip back into 8 wins is a great year. This year the university will make that call.
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 5:01 pm
by Sooth
squintsdd wrote:GrantDuck wrote:
At least 2 of those PIs were correct, the hold on the last drive was correct.
I'm surprised they even still call it football in whatever bizzaro universe you were watching the game in.
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 6:00 pm
by squintsdd
Sooth wrote:squintsdd wrote:GrantDuck wrote:
At least 2 of those PIs were correct, the hold on the last drive was correct.
I'm surprised they even still call it football in whatever bizzaro universe you were watching the game in.
It's called reality, you're welcome to join anytime
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 6:01 pm
by squintsdd
GrantDuck wrote:The 2 point conversion complaining is utter nonsense, sorry.
Live by the sword/die by the sword. Where were the complaints when it was working?
When was the last time oregon NEVER kicked an extra point
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 6:10 pm
by greenyellow
squintsdd wrote:GrantDuck wrote:The 2 point conversion complaining is utter nonsense, sorry.
Live by the sword/die by the sword. Where were the complaints when it was working?
When was the last time oregon NEVER kicked an extra point
Probably not since the 2007 game against UCLA where they were held scoreless. Not using an All-American caliber kicker to get basically free points is on the coaches and Nelson for thinking every 2-pt try was a good one.
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 6:12 pm
by pezsez1
I think you might be homering a little. At least 2 of those PIs were correct, the hold on the last drive was correct.
Some of the PI calls against us were totally justified. But that last holding call was an absolute joke. Brown let go of the defensive player as soon as he turned around, but the defensive guy stumbled and the ref threw the flag.
The substitution issue was also bizarre. Refs blew that.
We didn't lose because of officiating though. No point blowing things up too much.
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 6:18 pm
by buckmarkduck
Your all right, but I'll also give you a 4th reason
Dye, Jelks, Crosby, Freeman all playing very little or missing the game entirely as a reason for the L. Moi stepped up and played well, but I really think Dye and Jelks are our best two players in the front 7. And neither played.
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 6:19 pm
by greenyellow
Oregon just isn't good enough to win with as many penalties as they had, even if a handful are bad ones.
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 6:23 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
buckmarkduck wrote:Your all right, but I'll also give you a 4th reason
Dye, Jelks, Crosby, Freeman all playing very little or missing the game entirely as a reason for the L. Moi stepped up and played well, but I really think Dye and Jelks are our best two players in the front 7. And neither played.
Good point. Anyone know why Dye didn't play? He was suited up I'm pretty sure holding his helmet when I saw him on screen.
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 6:27 pm
by GrandpaDuck
buckmarkduck wrote:Your all right, but I'll also give you a 4th reason
Dye, Jelks, Crosby, Freeman all playing very little or missing the game entirely as a reason for the L. Moi stepped up and played well, but I really think Dye and Jelks are our best two players in the front 7. And neither played.
Agreed. Frankly Dye and Moi shouldn't play the same position. I would like to see them play Dye, Moi and Ragin as the main linebackers. They lack size but so did Michael Clay.
The holding call on that last drive was atrocious as was the substitution call. Poor calls at critical moments.
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 6:29 pm
by greenyellow
This season is the first season in a long time where there's really aren't any legitimate stars on the defense. In past years, you could at least name off 3-4 guys that you could count on every game and fans would instantly recognize them.
Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 6:42 pm
by GrandpaDuck
greenyellow wrote:This season is the first season in a long time where there's really aren't any legitimate stars on the defense. In past years, you could at least name off 3-4 guys that you could count on every game and fans would instantly recognize them.
True. Dye though might become a star this year, if he ever plays again. I watched the Virginia game several times and even his "off game" was better than anyone else's on the D. Jelks has been the only front 4 pressure guy and neither of those 2 played this game.