Page 1 of 3
The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 7:25 am
by SuperDuck
I know that there are those who think that Helfrich should be replaced. I think they're wrong. Once a team starts winning big and gets a taste of success, especially coming so close to a national championship, fans become unruly and unrealistic.
The BEST coaches in NCAA history have around a 75-85% winning percentage. That means that in today's world, the "best of the best" would average around 9-10 wins per year during the regular season. That means that even though they would have great seasons, they'd also have some that were very average.
In addition, all but a handful of the coaches who achieved the greatest heights did so in a different era of college football. I'm talking early era or the era where there were unlimited scholarships and great teams could horde good players.
Personally, I think Helfrich is an excellent coach. Chip Kelly would say the same thing. He hired him! He also pushed for the UO to hire him when he left for the NFL.
Chip was innovative and at that time was a great coach, but Chip was also stubborn. Chip would run, run, run the ball even when it wasn't working. He'd do it to the point of ignorance. Also, much of Chip's success was based on tempo and getting the ball snapped before defenses could get into position.
What would Chip be doing now that defenses have begun to adjust to seeing tempo more often?
Also, how would the defense be if Chip were still here? Remember that Aliotti was retiring. Would his replacement have been adequate? Would Chip have been forced to hire Don Pellum, too?
What Helf has done is balanced the offense and is scoring as many (or more) than Chip's teams ever did. You can't blame the defensive struggles on Helfrich until this year, seeing as he was forced to hire Pellum.
I see that defense getting much better over the course of the next 1-2 years. They're very young right now, but they're getting better.
Helf won 11 games in his first season (more than Chip's 10) and 13 in his second. They would have likely made the playoff last year if not for the injury to VA.
Honestly, I was also worried about Helfrich when he was first hired, but now I'm completely on board.
Once again, let's look at fair expectations of a college coach.
1. They should be in contention for a conference championship apx 75% of the time. Growing pains happen some years, injuries, whiffs on recruits, etc.
2. Making it to the conference championship game 40% of the time.
3. Winning it 75% of the time they make it.
4. Get to the college football playoffs 20% of the time.
Based on those numbers, the Ducks would be in the thick of things in the conference race 7-8 times in each decade. A couple down years and lower tier Bowls.
Based on those numbers, the Ducks would win the Pac-12 North 4 times in each decade.
Based on those numbers, the Ducks would win the conference championship 3 times in each decade.
Based on those numbers, the Ducks would make the college football playoff 2 times in each decade.
I think that as long as a coach maintained a high graduation rate, kept his nose clean, was easy to get along with, boosters loved him, etc that just about any AD in the country would want him. This is a description of a fantastic coach.
There are very few Nick Saban's and Urban Meyer's out there. Even Jimbo Fisher, who WON a national championship at Florida State, has been routed in the past 3 years by Oregon, and by Louisville yesterday.
I really think that the "Helf haters" need to lighten up.
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 7:48 am
by buckmarkduck
Chip wouldn't have been forced to do crap. Coach Azz, who made Aliotti d look good, would have been the DC. He almost took the job this time, and I'm told even told Helfrich he would, but the next day Chip got the 9ers job and he backed out to go to SF with Chip.
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 7:57 am
by maxduck
Thank you, best thing I have read this morning. The well respected George Raveling once said it takes 5 years to really learn how to be a head coach.
Although I don't understand the lack of discipline during the game I really appreciate the good citizenship the players demonstrate off the field.
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 8:05 am
by GoDucksIn09
Last year people would say the back end of the defense is young... this year... front seven is young... I remember some team in Seattle people always saying they were young. They would do it every year. I do not want to be like that team from Seattle. I have not been sold on Helfrich for awhile. Last year's bowl game... the loss to Utah at home... this year beating a lower tiered fcs opponent by 18 and I get tired of seeing all the penalties.
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 10:33 am
by soduck
We could do better, maybe, we could definitely do worse. Saban, Meyer, and a few others are not coming here. Helfrich in my mind, is not a great head coach yet. But he still could become great. A new DC and new OC and yes a young team are all issues he had minimal control over. Lets' give him another year, or two Right now beating Washington and getting to a BCS bowl, if not CFP are still possible. I am a not ready to throw the baby out with the bath water. And burn this program down with at best a third base hire. A home run hire does not exist for us. So why bring up firing Helfrich unless you want to bitch because we loss a game. We were so close to winning this game in several ways from our own unforced penalties, a couple of poor penalty calls, Charles Nelson wrapping up, Royce not going down. All in a very tough away game environment, our largest and loudest crowd we will face this season. +++ SuperDuck
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 10:39 am
by buckmarkduck
Altman was fired at Kansas St, I'd bet at this point they wish they allowed him to develop as a HC. I don't know if Helf can develop into a coach like Altman, but I think the personalities are similar. And both are pretty intelligent when it comes to the games they coach. For all the criticism Helf takes, our O is still producing just as good as it did under Chip. If he can turn the D around, and cut out the stupid penalties, we would be winning 11-12 games a year still. Honestly, with a top 50, hell even top 90 D last year, we win the Pac 12 and probably beat Iowas in the Rose Bowl.
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 11:12 am
by GrandpaDuck
What is the source of this Helf forced to hire Pellum legend? If it is the phony insider info at 247 and Scout then it is as ridiculous as it sounds.
No I am not in the fire Helf crowd, but this new spin on the Pellum hire is so illogical. Did Phil Knight interview Pellum and Neal on their defensive philosophies and decide in his vast knowledge of X and Os that his evaluation of defensive schematics was better than Helf's who actually interviewed all the candidates?
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 11:28 am
by greenyellow
GrandpaDuck wrote:What is the source of this Helf forced to hire Pellum legend? If it is the phony insider info at 247 and Scout then it is as ridiculous as it sounds.
No I am not in the fire Helf crowd, but this new spin on the Pellum hire is so illogical. Did Phil Knight interview Pellum and Neal on their defensive philosophies and decide in his vast knowledge of X and Os that his evaluation of defensive schematics was better than Helf's who actually interviewed all the candidates?
Why is it ridiculous because it came from there? Those boards get people with access to the program and have provided some inside knowledge that turned out true. It's really not a far stretch that an assistant would be hired that wasn't fully the idea of the HC since it's been done at other schools in a slightly more public manner.
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 12:31 pm
by SuperDuck
buckmarkduck wrote:Chip wouldn't have been forced to do crap. Coach Azz, who made Aliotti d look good, would have been the DC. He almost took the job this time, and I'm told even told Helfrich he would, but the next day Chip got the 9ers job and he backed out to go to SF with Chip.
Yeah, you're right about that. No way Chip would have allowed anyone to tell him who and who not to hire.
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 12:33 pm
by SuperDuck
maxduck wrote:Thank you, best thing I have read this morning. The well respected George Raveling once said it takes 5 years to really learn how to be a head coach.
Although I don't understand the lack of discipline during the game I really appreciate the good citizenship the players demonstrate off the field.
Thanks. And the very wise George Raveling was likely correct. That's especially true when you lose top assistants.
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 12:43 pm
by SuperDuck
GoDucksIn09 wrote:Last year people would say the back end of the defense is young... this year... front seven is young... I remember some team in Seattle people always saying they were young. They would do it every year. I do not want to be like that team from Seattle. I have not been sold on Helfrich for awhile. Last year's bowl game... the loss to Utah at home... this year beating a lower tiered fcs opponent by 18 and I get tired of seeing all the penalties.
Early last year was awful. The loss to TCU was awful. No arguments there, but Helf has two new coordinators and a lot of good young recruits that it's going to take some time to develop.
I get, and agree, about the penalties. No excuses for those. Only beating UC-Davis by 18 was a combination of a lot of new faces, a new system being installed and more. At least we didn't only beat Nicholl's State by 2 (like Georgia last week), lose to Eastern Washington (like WSU in week one), lose to North Dakota State (like #13 Iowa just did).
Helf did something about those embarrassing losses, he fired Don Pellum and brought in Brady Hoke, which I think is a good hire. The problem is that Buckner, Balducci and nearly all the rest of the front seven are gone. First year coordinator, 5 new starters on defense and everyone wants instant improvement right out of the gate. It doesn't always work that way, unfortunately.
Oh, #1 Alabama just gave up 43 points to Mississippi. #2 Florida State just gave up 63 to a very good Louisville team, but 63 points with all those 4 and 5 star recruits?
On any given day it can happen to anyone.
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 12:53 pm
by SuperDuck
soduck wrote:We could do better, maybe, we could definitely do worse. Saban, Meyer, and a few others are not coming here. Helfrich in my mind, is not a great head coach yet. But he still could become great. A new DC and new OC and yes a young team are all issues he had minimal control over. Lets' give him another year, or two Right now beating Washington and getting to a BCS bowl, if not CFP are still possible. I am a not ready to throw the baby out with the bath water. And burn this program down with at best a third base hire. A home run hire does not exist for us. So why bring up firing Helfrich unless you want to bitch because we loss a game. We were so close to winning this game in several ways from our own unforced penalties, a couple of poor penalty calls, Charles Nelson wrapping up, Royce not going down. All in a very tough away game environment, our largest and loudest crowd we will face this season. +++ SuperDuck
That's the thing. Even if we
could bring in a big name coach, how much better would the Ducks get? Would it be significantly better? I mean, we're talking about a team that's averaging 10+ wins per season. No pressure, coach. You think?

Would they destroy the continuity of the staff? How long would they remain at Oregon?
Most young coaches like to use Oregon as a stepping stone. Helf has already said that Oregon is the pinnacle for him. The last stop. Top of the mountain. He doesn't want to go anywhere. This is home for him, just like Ohio State is home for Urban Meyer.
Unless he has a couple consecutive losing seasons, and the program is CLEARLY in decline, I say we leave him alone and let him do his job. If he can achieve what I posted when I started this thread then I hope he stays for another 40-50 years.
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 12:56 pm
by SuperDuck
greenyellow wrote:GrandpaDuck wrote:What is the source of this Helf forced to hire Pellum legend? If it is the phony insider info at 247 and Scout then it is as ridiculous as it sounds.
No I am not in the fire Helf crowd, but this new spin on the Pellum hire is so illogical. Did Phil Knight interview Pellum and Neal on their defensive philosophies and decide in his vast knowledge of X and Os that his evaluation of defensive schematics was better than Helf's who actually interviewed all the candidates?
Why is it ridiculous because it came from there? Those boards get people with access to the program and have provided some inside knowledge that turned out true. It's really not a far stretch that an assistant would be hired that wasn't fully the idea of the HC since it's been done at other schools in a slightly more public manner.
Yep, in this case I was just passing on what a few others have shared. I certainly have no inside knowledge.
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 2:02 pm
by nogerO
And what do you suppose MH's record would be if he hadn't inherited one Marcus Mariota? Guy is not too bright.
Re: The Argument For Helfrich
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 3:19 pm
by Surging Chaos
soduck wrote:We could do better, maybe, we could definitely do worse. Saban, Meyer, and a few others are not coming here
Saban and Meyer are once-in-a-generation coaches. If you're going to compare good coaches to two individuals who have won national titles over and over and over again you're going to be pretty disappointed. Those two are the exception, not the rule.
I think a lot of the anxiety over Helfrich comes from the fact that college football programs are spending more money than ever before, yet there are still only the same number of wins to fight for. Look at LSU. They spend the most money on assistants than any other program in the country and it has been met with diminishing returns.