Page 1 of 4
Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 4:42 pm
by OregonFan4Life
I never want to see a coach fired during the season, and I know Oregon is not a top destination for coaches, but with LSU reaching out to Herman and the possibility of USC reaching out to him too, does Mullens need to consider acting soon to get a chance at landing him? Anyone who has paid attention to Houston has seen what an incredible job he has done. I watched that Oklahoma game and Houston looked dominant really. Herman clearly knows what he's doing and I think he could take Oregon in the right direction right now. To me, this is a situation where Mullens can't wait and play it safe again, otherwise he may be feeling some heat too. I know he was hired for his financial expertise, but with the current decline of the football program and fans getting angry, he has to feel some sort of urgency to make a move. Like I previously said, I don't like firing a coach mid season, but if it would result in getting someone like Herman, I would be for it. Thoughts on this?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 4:54 pm
by pezsez1
I think I understand you better than I did last season. You get pumped and emotional about the Ducks (don't we all?) and you want nothing more than to see the team thrive.
But no, I don't think Mullens will or should fire Helfrich this season. It just doesn't make sense. Is there any comparable situation in the past 10 or 20 years when a coach has been fired following a trip to the national championship, a 9-win season (following the loss of a Heisman QB) and then a 2-2 start (with both losses by a combined six points)?
I mean, maybe there is... but I don't know of any. This would just seem like the ultimate knee-jerk reaction, especially considering many of the Ducks' current problems were somewhat predictable, even to folks like myself who tend to be more optimistic.
I think Helf will deserve the true hot seat treatment next season if things don't turn around. But the team's only glaring problem this season is its defense, and we're in Year #1 of breaking in a new DC who hasn't even had a full recruiting cycle to get his own playmakers.
Does the team have other issues? Yes, but so do all teams. If Oregon had even an average D right now, we'd be 4-0 and talking about the playoffs.
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 4:54 pm
by karlhungis
He isn't coming. He will be offered more money by bigger programs in better recruiting areas. There is literally nothing that we can offer that other big programs won't out bid us on. All we can offer are frequent uniform changes and I don't think that will be enough.
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 4:58 pm
by vegasdom
He is not going to Oregon. Did you see what Ohio State did to Oklahoma in Norman? Houston is a total garbage conference. Lets see what happens to them vs Louisville.
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 5:01 pm
by TualatinDuck
Perez, reference gene chizick. Fired after going what 3-9? The season after a national championship and Heisman winner.
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 5:02 pm
by TualatinDuck
Grr auto correct
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 5:16 pm
by QuackAttack92
Just so depressing...waited all year for college football and October is not even here and there's nothing to play for
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 5:27 pm
by lmduck
OregonFan4Life wrote:I never want to see a coach fired during the season, and I know Oregon is not a top destination for coaches, but with LSU reaching out to Herman and the possibility of USC reaching out to him too, does Mullens need to consider acting soon to get a chance at landing him? Anyone who has paid attention to Houston has seen what an incredible job he has done. I watched that Oklahoma game and Houston looked dominant really. Herman clearly knows what he's doing and I think he could take Oregon in the right direction right now. To me, this is a situation where Mullens can't wait and play it safe again, otherwise he may be feeling some heat too. I know he was hired for his financial expertise, but with the current decline of the football program and fans getting angry, he has to feel some sort of urgency to make a move. Like I previously said, I don't like firing a coach mid season, but if it would result in getting someone like Herman, I would be for it. Thoughts on this?
Why don't you e-mail or call Mullens and let him know what your thoughts are. I am sure he would appreciate hearing from you.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 5:43 pm
by pezsez1
Regarding Chizik, from wiki:
In his first year, Chizik led the Tigers to the 2010 Outback Bowl, a fairly quick turnaround for a team that went 5-7 the year before. The next year, he led the team to a 14-0 record and the BCS National Championship—the first undisputed national championship in school history. With the loss of several players from that team who opted to go pro, Chizik's third team slipped to 8-5. The 2012 season, however, was more than disappointing as the team finished 3-9 and was outscored 150-21 in its final three SEC games—including a 49-0 loss to Alabama in the Iron Bowl.
So he wasn't fired the year after the natty... it was two years later, AFTER the season ended, and after the team went 3-9.
Helfrich was a VA concussion away from a 10-win season and an easy Alamo Bowl win last season (and more if VA doesn't break his finger, but no point playing the "woulda coulda" game at this point), but still nine wins is better than Chizik's third season. And in no way do I see this year's Oregon team finishing with a losing record.
Now... if these Ducks did finish the season with a losing record, then I think the conversation about firing Helfrich changes. But we're nowhere near that point yet. We're 2-2 and a couple plays away from being 4-0. I know it's easy to obsess over the win/loss record, but context has to matter with things like this.
I also think we have to account for the future, and the fact that Helfrich seems to be putting us in position to return to elite status for at least the next few seasons -- starting next year. This could end up being a tragically bad time for yet ANOTHER coaching change -- it would be our third major coaching shakeup in five years (and fourth major transition if you count Mariota's departure), which is way too much transition to establish regularity within the program. It doesn't just mess with scheming, gameplanning and morale, but -- as we've seen in recent years -- these transitions also cost us in recruiting.
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 7:31 pm
by Duckattack7
I'm hoping they lite a fire under the team but honestly I don't think Helf has it in him. Helf is too nice no way around it.
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 7:49 pm
by OregonFan4Life
Pez you're a great poster but you always seem to do the "a play or two away" argument which I drastically disagree with. Colorado could've been one bad play from their backup QB from a complete blowout, and with Nebraska, same thing, imagine if they didn't have that boneheaded fumble on a bad lateral that Springs recovered. Football is never about what ifs, cause every team has them. Football is simply about results, and so far, the results have been two very unimpressive wins against two very bad teams and two losses, one was tough, but one was against a weak conference foe with no starting QB. And don't even get me started with how this team plays, 2nd in the country in penalties, sloppy, and undisciplined. Plus, can anyone remember the culture Helf tried to implement? I remember it, but it doesn't seem like the players buy into it because if they did the fundamentals would be far better. I believe Helf is really smart, he really is a genius, however being a college football coach requires a lot of leadership and I doubt his ability to lead college athletes.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 8:24 pm
by QuackAttack92
If my uncle had a c*** he'd be my aunt...bottom line is we don't have a defense and MH isn't getting it done
A fish rots from the head down. Who's in charge of recruiting these players that don't even belong in the team? Marky Mark
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 8:49 pm
by SuperDuck
pezsez1 wrote:Regarding Chizik, from wiki:
In his first year, Chizik led the Tigers to the 2010 Outback Bowl, a fairly quick turnaround for a team that went 5-7 the year before. The next year, he led the team to a 14-0 record and the BCS National Championship—the first undisputed national championship in school history. With the loss of several players from that team who opted to go pro, Chizik's third team slipped to 8-5. The 2012 season, however, was more than disappointing as the team finished 3-9 and was outscored 150-21 in its final three SEC games—including a 49-0 loss to Alabama in the Iron Bowl.
So he wasn't fired the year after the natty... it was two years later, AFTER the season ended, and after the team went 3-9.
Helfrich was a VA concussion away from a 10-win season and an easy Alamo Bowl win last season (and more if VA doesn't break his finger, but no point playing the "woulda coulda" game at this point), but still nine wins is better than Chizik's third season. And in no way do I see this year's Oregon team finishing with a losing record.
Now... if these Ducks did finish the season with a losing record, then I think the conversation about firing Helfrich changes. But we're nowhere near that point yet. We're 2-2 and a couple plays away from being 4-0. I know it's easy to obsess over the win/loss record, but context has to matter with things like this.
I also think we have to account for the future, and the fact that Helfrich seems to be putting us in position to return to elite status for at least the next few seasons -- starting next year. This could end up being a tragically bad time for yet ANOTHER coaching change -- it would be our third major coaching shakeup in five years (and fourth major transition if you count Mariota's departure), which is way too much transition to establish regularity within the program. It doesn't just mess with scheming, gameplanning and morale, but -- as we've seen in recent years -- these transitions also cost us in recruiting.
Agreed. You don't just start firing coaches that have an excellent won/loss record after 2 close losses. You're also right about Helfrich having the team set up for the future. I get emotional like everyone else. I hate to lose, and it's even harder now that our expectations have become so high. Still, very few teams are elite year in and year out.
There are a couple unrealistic individuals on here that are screaming for a lynching and everyone else seems to be keeping a level head.
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 8:53 pm
by Sooth
Helfrich is not a FBS football coach. End of discussion.
Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2016 8:56 pm
by QuackAttack92
Malzahn wouldnt come here...but if Mullen gets the boot at Miss St I'd love to have him