Page 1 of 1
My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 8:33 am
by QuackininBama
Stop, breath, relax....that is my motto this year:
In November 1999, LSU named Nick Saban their 31st head football coach.
2000—In 2000, the Tigers went 8–4 and won the Peach Bowl. The season was somewhat marred by several lopsided losses, including a 34–17 loss to the Auburn Tigers, a 13–10 loss to the UAB Blazers, and a 41–9 loss to the Florida Gators.
2001—Saban led LSU to a 10–3 record, including an SEC Championship and a Sugar Bowl victory.
2002—The season opened with high expectations, but a 26–8 loss at the hands of Virginia Tech raised serious questions about their outlook. LSU also suffered a 35–20 loss to Texas in the Cotton Bowl Classic, and finished 8–5.
2003-They were ranked No. 2 in the BCS standings and advanced to play the BCS No. 1 Oklahoma Sooners in the Sugar Bowl, which was the host of the BCS Championship Game in 2003. The Tigers won the game 21–14. The win gave LSU the BCS national championship and a 13–1 finish for the season.
2004—LSU finished the season 9–3, after losing to the Iowa Hawkeyes in the Capital One Bowl 30–25 on a final play touchdown pass.
2007-Saban became the fifth Alabama coach since 1900 to start his first season 3–0, earning a win over then-ranked No. 16 Arkansas Razorbacks. Alabama ended the regular season with a 6–6 record, including a four-game losing streak, a particularly humiliating loss at home to Louisiana-Monroe, and a sixth straight loss to Auburn in the Iron Bowl. The Tide defeated Colorado in the 2007 Independence Bowl, 30–24, to end the year 7–6.
In short, the moral of the story is, great coaches arn't born, they are made. Even the great god of college football himself had a rocky start. I will admit my expectations are way to high for a coach in his forth season. If Saban can get embarrassed at home to frikkin Louisiana-Monroe, well hell, that makes Helfs losses to Utah and Colorado not look so bad. I just gotta relax this year cause the signs say its gonna be a long one guys.
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 8:52 am
by dthomas=ddixon
The flaw in all of these coaching record comparisons is not one of these other coaches took over a program that was at its peak. When Helf took over we had won more games over the past 5 years than anyone in the country. We were literally one of the best programs in the nation and loaded with talent, including the best player in college football.
A good coach would be able to at maintain somewhat similar success for more than a few seasons. And that's what we're about to find out: Will Helf rein things in and put together an OK season that will be looked back on as just a "down year" or will we continue the slide back to mediocrity?
One thing is for sure though, he has never built anything. And he certainly isn't the accomplished coach some want to make him out to be. He just didn't screw anything up the first couple years. Well, besides hiring Pellum.
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 8:55 am
by buckmarkduck
Marcus was awesome, but best player in college football? I mean we litterly lost to Ohio St because Elliott just ran all over us, and we had no answer. I loved Marcus and wouldn't traded him, but so far I'd say he and Crab legs were even, and Zeke was the best player in college that year.
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 10:53 am
by Phalanx
buckmarkduck wrote:Marcus was awesome, but best player in college football? I mean we litterly lost to Ohio St because Elliott just ran all over us, and we had no answer. I loved Marcus and wouldn't traded him, but so far I'd say he and Crab legs were even, and Zeke was the best player in college that year.
No way. Mariota was missing his two starting receivers in that game, and he had a MUCH harder defensive line to deal with than Elliott did. Mariota carried his team all the way to that game. He was the best player in college football that year, bar none.
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 10:57 am
by OregonFan4Life
buckmarkduck wrote:Marcus was awesome, but best player in college football? I mean we litterly lost to Ohio St because Elliott just ran all over us, and we had no answer. I loved Marcus and wouldn't traded him, but so far I'd say he and Crab legs were even, and Zeke was the best player in college that year.
I don't think any duck fan would be biased to say you're absolutely crazy. Elliot wasn't that impressive, all he had to do was run through the wide open lanes his online gave him, meanwhile Marcus would be dodging three defensive linemen rushing him while throwing darts way downfield while running full speed to avoid being tackled. There's a reason college football experts talked about if he is the greatest college football player ever, nobody that season was close to him. Marcus was easily the best player in the country that year and the Heisman voting is proof of that.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 11:24 am
by dthomas=ddixon
buckmarkduck wrote:Marcus was awesome, but best player in college football? I mean we litterly lost to Ohio St because Elliott just ran all over us, and we had no answer. I loved Marcus and wouldn't traded him, but so far I'd say he and Crab legs were even, and Zeke was the best player in college that year.
Ok so he was the second best player in the country. My point still stands.
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 12:25 pm
by Duck07
buckmarkduck wrote:Marcus was awesome, but best player in college football? I mean we litterly lost to Ohio St because Elliott just ran all over us, and we had no answer. I loved Marcus and wouldn't traded him, but so far I'd say he and Crab legs were even, and Zeke was the best player in college that year.
If you are grading by career, only Tebow beats Marcus in QB efficiency. Marcus has nothing to do with the defensive performance in that game, much like he gets zero credit for what our defense did to Jameis the game prior.
The thing about all of this that stands out and seems obvious to me is that Helfrich isn't anything special as a coach. In 4 years time, what stands out about him as a coach?
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 1:22 pm
by QuackininBama
Duck07 wrote: In 4 years time, what stands out about him as a coach?
He drinks a lot of water?
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 1:43 pm
by buckmarkduck
It's still ridiculous to throw out any wins Helf had with Marcus, for two reason no coach ever won without talented players, and two Helf found and talked Kelly into offering Marcus.
Am I happy with the direction our season is going, or how last year ended? HELL no! But to give Helf no credit, is just people hating on him. He still had a team with half the talent Florida St had, and he destroyed them, in what is certainly a top 5 win in UO history and maybe the biggest win.
Oh and BTW, Colorado is as good as I think they are. They will finish in the top 2 in the South, and win 9-10 games.
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 2:38 pm
by pezsez1
The flaw in all of these coaching record comparisons is not one of these other coaches took over a program that was at its peak. When Helf took over we had won more games over the past 5 years than anyone in the country. We were literally one of the best programs in the nation and loaded with talent, including the best player in college football.
A good coach would be able to at maintain somewhat similar success for more than a few seasons.
We were kind of at our peak, in terms of win/loss records...
But we'd also just been hit with sanctions. We'd been getting bad press as cheaters for a couple years. And Chip was such a hot commodity that losing him was going to hurt recruiting unless we got a HUGE name, which wasn't going to happen. Also, we saw the very next season that we were already very thin at key positions on defense. We've been struggling with that ever since, and the sanctions didn't exactly help us reload, nor did Nick Alliotti retiring just one year into Helf's HC tenure.
I've said it before, but you can't expect the following to happen and expect consistency within the program:
1. Chip Kelly leaves.
2. NCAA sanctions come six months later.
3. After 2013-14 season, longtime defensive coordinator retires.
4. 2014-15 season (no coaching or recruiting changes)
5. After 2015-16 season, new DC leaves
6. Sanctions end!
7. 2016-17... we are here.
If you want to know why we don't have the playmakers on the defensive side of the ball, there it is. We weren't just whiffing on recruits for no reason.
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 2:49 pm
by Duck07
I understand all of those things Pez and I used to support Helfrich, but it's clear to me by now that there isn't anything he does that's special. He's not the play caller or QB guru. He's not an ace recruiter or motivator. We're told repeatedly how intelligent he is, yet we've lost two games this season because of decisions by the coaching staff which should have been obvious. More time with Helfrich will see more 8-4 seasons than 11-1.
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 2:55 pm
by buckmarkduck
Duck07 wrote:I understand all of those things Pez and I used to support Helfrich, but it's clear to me by now that there isn't anything he does that's special. He's not the play caller or QB guru. He's not an ace recruiter or motivator. We're told repeatedly how intelligent he is, yet we've lost two games this season because of decisions by the coaching staff which should have been obvious. More time with Helfrich will see more 8-4 seasons than 11-1.
And that's probably true, but I don't get under selling his getting the team to a natty. if we lose the next two, I'll be fully in the fire Helf bandwagon and probably fire Mullens as well since I know certain coaches reached out wanting the job and he didn't even bother to call them back. He just took Chips word for it, and went with Helf.
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 4:29 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
pezsez1 wrote:The flaw in all of these coaching record comparisons is not one of these other coaches took over a program that was at its peak. When Helf took over we had won more games over the past 5 years than anyone in the country. We were literally one of the best programs in the nation and loaded with talent, including the best player in college football.
A good coach would be able to at maintain somewhat similar success for more than a few seasons.
We were kind of at our peak, in terms of win/loss records...
But we'd also just been hit with sanctions. We'd been getting bad press as cheaters for a couple years. And Chip was such a hot commodity that losing him was going to hurt recruiting unless we got a HUGE name, which wasn't going to happen. Also, we saw the very next season that we were already very thin at key positions on defense. We've been struggling with that ever since, and the sanctions didn't exactly help us reload, nor did Nick Alliotti retiring just one year into Helf's HC tenure.
I've said it before, but you can't expect the following to happen and expect consistency within the program:
1. Chip Kelly leaves.
2. NCAA sanctions come six months later.
3. After 2013-14 season, longtime defensive coordinator retires.
4. 2014-15 season (no coaching or recruiting changes)
5. After 2015-16 season, new DC leaves
6. Sanctions end!
7. 2016-17... we are here.
If you want to know why we don't have the playmakers on the defensive side of the ball, there it is. We weren't just whiffing on recruits for no reason.
Whatever is lacking on defense has a lot more to do with the Pellum promotuon than recruiting. Other than that I agree with you. You cut my post off right before I brought the balance. Or at least I tried to ha.
I think it's fair for fans to be entirely unsure about Helfat this point. The next two seasons are going to tell us everything we need to know and barring a total meltdown I think he should get that long.
Re: My own "A Dose Of College Football Reality"
Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 4:50 pm
by pezsez1
Whatever is lacking on defense has a lot more to do with the Pellum promotuon than recruiting. Other than that I agree with you. You cut my post off right before I brought the balance. Or at least I tried to ha.
I kind of agree with you on this, at least in terms of the Pellum promotion being a huge mistake that probably exacerbated our other problems.
I'm hoping that at some point this season, something clicks and our defense gets some kind of consistency. But I really think Hoke just needs another year of transition and recruiting. And if Pellum being on the staff is honestly a liability, I'm sure he and Helfrich will do something about that. At this point, I'm sure everyone from Puddles to Rob Mullens can see the writing on the wall next season if things don't turn around. If I were them, I'd prefer to stay in that luxurious football operations building.