Page 1 of 3
I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 8:04 am
by Alan
Yup, Helf gets a pass this year, I know that's a shocker to some. We were embarrassed by the defense last year and Helf and others made wholesale changes in the coaching staff. Now we are 5 games in, struggle to learn a new scheme with kids fresh out of high school playing with the big boys. I don't respect drum beaters so I'll stop there.
But if the Ducks don't make a marked improvement next year, the D needs to see big improvements, O line needs big improvement and we had better have a mostly developed QB (one recruited out of high school). If I don't see this improvement I'll be driving the "change the coach" bandwagon.....well maybe, it's a year away.

Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 8:08 am
by karlhungis
struggle to learn a new scheme with kids fresh out of high school playing with the big boys.
Am I counting wrong or are there only 2 FR getting meaningful playing time on defense? And one of them (Dye) happens to be the best player on the defense, even though the coaches seem to not let him play much.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 8:13 am
by Alan
karlhungis wrote:struggle to learn a new scheme with kids fresh out of high school playing with the big boys.
Am I counting wrong or are there only 2 FR getting meaningful playing time on defense? And one of them (Dye) happens to be the best player on the defense, even though the coaches seem to not let him play much.
I didn't say freshman on the D. I said kids, meaning youngsters.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 8:35 am
by Duck07
Wholesale changes aren't retaining the staff and putting a new system in, that's a tweak. Nor does it explain the misery of the offense, which is his strong suit.
Further, if next year implodes and THEN you're ready for changes, you'll be a day late and a dollar short.
If Helf wanted a pass for this season, he should have been sounding the "youth" horn from fall camp. Instead we got a bunch of hubris.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 8:38 am
by buckmarkduck
This is big boy football, with millions at stake for the school. No one is getting orange slices after the game. Helf has one job, and one job only, win. He's not, and it's clear he's lost the team. Fire him.
Make the call today, have Phil offer Bellotti whatever it takes to have him coach this team the rest of the year. Then after the regular season hire Larry Fedora.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 8:41 am
by Alan
Duck07 wrote:Wholesale changes aren't retaining the staff and putting a new system in, that's a tweak. Nor does it explain the misery of the offense, which is his strong suit.
Further, if next year implodes and THEN you're ready for changes, you'll be a day late and a dollar short.
If Helf wanted a pass for this season, he should have been sounding the "youth" horn from fall camp. Instead we got a bunch of hubris.
It's simply a matter of perspective. I don't consider a new OC and New DC along with a new defensive scheme a tweak. But as said it's just different perspectives.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 8:45 am
by Duck07
Alan wrote:Duck07 wrote:Wholesale changes aren't retaining the staff and putting a new system in, that's a tweak. Nor does it explain the misery of the offense, which is his strong suit.
Further, if next year implodes and THEN you're ready for changes, you'll be a day late and a dollar short.
If Helf wanted a pass for this season, he should have been sounding the "youth" horn from fall camp. Instead we got a bunch of hubris.
It's simply a matter of perspective. I don't consider a new OC and New DC along with a new defensive scheme a tweak. But as said it's just different perspectives.
Well the offensive side shouldn't change. Helfrich is an offensive coach and that unit is just as poor as the defense. He also made these hires. If they aren't working, that's on him. This season didn't start with coaches knowing a rough stretch was ahead. They went out and got a mercenary QB because they saw the talent on this roster and thought they should compete.
These coaches are in over their heads with what they know versus what they think they know.
What kind of game plan did you see last night? Missed tackles is a youth and experience thing. Out of alignment and no where near the ball is a gameplanning issue.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 8:48 am
by QuackininBama
buckmarkduck wrote:This is big boy football, with millions at stake for the school. No one is getting orange slices after the game. Helf has one job, and one job only, win. He's not, and it's clear he's lost the team. Fire him.
Make the call today, have Phil offer Bellotti whatever it takes to have him coach this team the rest of the year. Then after the regular season hire Larry Fedora.
Na, its never a good idea to fire a coach mid-season. Not only will the team not perform any better on the field with an intern coach, your pretty much writing off every single, at least verbally committed recruits as they will all bail when that happens. Lets relax and see how the season plays out and they will make a decision in January.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 8:50 am
by dthomas=ddixon
I'm sure Helf appreciates the pass from you, Alan.
Here's a different perspective: He and his complacent staff are doing a major disservice to the veteran players like Pharoah Brown, Freeman, Prukop, Carrington, etc, etc. They get to spend their last year of college football playing for a HC who has no idea what he's doing and with an entire crop of his players that are mailing it in every Saturday. They deserve a coach who's going to put them and the rest of their teammates in a position to be their very best.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 8:53 am
by karlhungis
Alan wrote:karlhungis wrote:struggle to learn a new scheme with kids fresh out of high school playing with the big boys.
Am I counting wrong or are there only 2 FR getting meaningful playing time on defense? And one of them (Dye) happens to be the best player on the defense, even though the coaches seem to not let him play much.
I didn't say freshman on the D. I said kids, meaning youngsters.
Every team has youngsters. Most team's youngsters still learn how to play big boy football. I don't see how our situation is so unique that we just give a pass for not being able to play basic football.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 8:56 am
by Alan
Duck07 wrote:Alan wrote:Duck07 wrote:Wholesale changes aren't retaining the staff and putting a new system in, that's a tweak. Nor does it explain the misery of the offense, which is his strong suit.
Further, if next year implodes and THEN you're ready for changes, you'll be a day late and a dollar short.
If Helf wanted a pass for this season, he should have been sounding the "youth" horn from fall camp. Instead we got a bunch of hubris.
It's simply a matter of perspective. I don't consider a new OC and New DC along with a new defensive scheme a tweak. But as said it's just different perspectives.
Well the offensive side shouldn't change. Helfrich is an offensive coach and that unit is just as poor as the defense. He also made these hires. If they aren't working, that's on him. This season didn't start with coaches knowing a rough stretch was ahead. They went out and got a mercenary QB because they saw the talent on this roster and thought they should compete.
These coaches are in over their heads with what they know versus what they think they know.
What kind of game plan did you see last night? Missed tackles is a youth and experience thing. Out of alignment and no where near the ball is a gameplanning issue.
I would think the coaches on the O side went into the season optimistic. But I doubt they could tell Prukop would be under water at this level, they were simply competing with Bama for him at that point. I would hope they knew the potential number 2 QB could fall to #4. They certainly could see the best O lineman would be out early same for their Olympian. Can't put that on the coaches. As I said in another thread I need to see a QB recruited out of high school developed by next year.
I have beat the drum enough on my thoughts on our new D and the time needed to mature.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 8:59 am
by buckmarkduck
Of course the coaches on the O side went into the year optimistic, they went against our D everyday.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 9:00 am
by Alan
dthomas=ddixon wrote:I'm sure Helf appreciates the pass from you, Alan..
You obviously impressed someone here enough to become a Mod. You really should hold off from dumb azz statements like that.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 9:00 am
by rentdodger1
dthomas=ddixon wrote:I'm sure Helf appreciates the pass from you, Alan.
Here's a different perspective: He and his complacent staff are doing a major disservice to the veteran players like Pharoah Brown, Freeman, Prukop, Carrington, etc, etc. They get to spend their last year of college football playing for a HC who has no idea what he's doing and with an entire crop of his players that are mailing it in every Saturday. They deserve a coach who's going to put them and the rest of their teammates in a position to be their very best.
That is why Helfrich won't get a pass.
Re: I'm giving Helf a pass this year
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 9:01 am
by Duck07
Alan you're in a class by yourself at this point man. The QB recruited out of hs is on the roster right now and rather than acknowledge a growing season this year, they tried to pull the wool over their own eyes by relying on Prukop too much.
That ultimately is the problem. This would have occured last season were it not for Vernon and that says to me the coaches and not the players are part of the problem.
Jason Fife would have this team 4-1.