When did you start to feel the program slipping? (Long)
Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2016 10:26 am
Two years removed from a Rose Bowl victory, a National Championship appearance, and a Heisman Trophy winner, Oregon now appears to be one of the worst, if not *the* worst, team in the PAC-12. What the hell happened?
Like many of you, I believe the downfall started the moment Chip left for the NFL and the coaching job was essentially handed over to Helf. We all love Chip and yearn for the glory days to return, but let's not forget that he was adamant that the AD hire Helf to replace him, which was the first domino to fall. I've heard reports that Chris Peterson was interested in the job back in 2013 and we even interviewed Stanford OC Pep Hamilton, but it was a foregone conclusion the job would be passed along to Helf, just as it was from Chip and Bellotti before him.
I will say that it wasn't Helf why we lost the Natty in 2014 and that he was probably the correct short-term hire since the 2012 team finished the season 12-1 and was loaded for the near future with Marcus being just a RS Freshman at the time. However, Marcus could've made anyone look amazing at Head Coach and we'd likely not be in the position now had we thought bigger picture.
But when did it start to slip?
A lot will point to recruiting, but all things considered, Helf has done a better job of offering kids earlier in the process, securing more verbals in the off-season, and keeping our recruiting ranking in the Top 25. (*NOTE* I made this statement before looking up their class rankings. I was surprised to find out that Helf has never had a Top 15 Class on Rivals, even after a Heisman winner and Natty appearance. I take it back, recruiting is a key turning point.)
Recruiting Ranking (Rivals)
Chip-
2009: 34
2010: 13
2011: 9
2012: 16
Average: 18
Helf-
2013: 22
2014: 23
2015: 17
2016: 28
Average: 22.5
The biggest difference is Chip was able to capitalize off of our early BCS successes, especially the Fiesta Bowl vs Auburn. We're no longer in the running for the 5*'s on the West Coast like DAT and Arik Armstead. Any while I mentioned earlier that Helf is throwing out more early offers and securing earlier commitments, Kelly's staff was better at evaluating talent, especially on defense. Outside of Troy Dye, who's the last impact linebacker we've recruited? Michael Clay? Bo Lokombo?
Recruiting aside, the first red flag occurred in a late-season contest down in Tucson against the Wildcats of Arizona. After Stanford lost to USC, the Ducks were now in position to get back to the Rose Bowl for the third time in five years. All we had to do was beat UA and OSU and we'd be in the PAC-12 title game. Fortunately, I was not able to watch this game as a I was attending a good friend's wedding, but we got clobbered, clobbered like no Duck team has been clobbered since the 2004 Civil War or 2006 Vegas Bowl. Ka'Deem Carey ran wild on our defense and the Top 5 Ducks got blown out, 42-16 against a mediocre-at-best Wildcats team.
Since that game in 2013, Oregon has lost by 22 to Ohio State in 2014, 42 to Utah in the worst defeat at Autzen to Utah in 2015, blew a 31-0 halftime lead in the Alamo Bowl against TCU in 2015, lost three straight for the first time since 2007, including an 18-point loss to Washington State (the second straight year WSU has lost to an FCS school at home but defeated Oregon).
That was the first red flag. With everything on the line, a Chip Kelly team would NEVER have failed to show up like that. The Boise St. game in 2009 aside, which we only lost by 11 points by the way, Oregon was beat by double-figures just ONCE in his four seasons at the helm - a 40-27 loss to one of the best LSU teams during the 2011 season opener.
Red Flag No. 2: If Marcus was dinged or bruised or hurt in any way shape or form, the team went south. Marcus was plan A, B, C, D, E, etc. While all Duck fans should be eternally grateful that Helf discovered Mariota and urged Chip to offer him, it was under his watch that no other quarterback has been developed to this day. Marcus took the reigns in 2012 and our most capable backup to date has been Bryan Bennett.
Our 2013 season went down the drain after Marcus was hurt (that Stanford game was one to forget) and so was 2015 when Vernon was injured. For a program who has a reputation for putting out elite college quarterbacks (Fouts, Akili, Joey, Kellen, Dennis, DT, Marcus), especially recently, to only have one capable quarterback on the roster is unfathomable. Now we're two years removed from Mariota and we've had to go the graduate transfer route for the second consecutive year. To be clear: I know not every QB will be Marcus and that we'll likely never, ever see anyone like him ... but it needs to be better.
Red Flag No. 3: This post is getting long, even for my liking, so I'll keep this one short and sweet. Oregon has a tendency to hire from within, to a fault. It's worked before (Bellotti, Kelly, etc), but it feels like they've went to the well once too often. Pellum felt more like a lifetime achievement promotion than anything else, Helf was given the job without really even considering anyone else, and Lubick feels like he should've stayed as a positions coach as his play-calling has been abysmal.
Final Red Flag: Our swagger is gone. There's no more Win The Day mantra. Sure, Win The Day is still on the walls of Autzen Stadium, but do you think it really embodies the Oregon program anymore? I don't. We're more undisciplined on the football field than ever (I will give Helf credit that his players are good members of the community outside the field *knock on wood*). The tempo is gone. "Big Balls" Chip-mentality is gone. Yes, Helf goes for two, but it's not the right timing. We're punting way too often, playing way too conservative. No one fears Oregon anymore.
I think it was TK1 who stated last week that this downward spiral wouldn't be so bad had we won it all in 2010 or 2014, but we've been so close in chasing that elusive Natty that it feels like we may never get back. After all, we are in Oregon and we're not on fertile recruiting grounds. The question does come up: Are the best days of Oregon football behind us? The answer scares the living daylights out of me.
Like our uniforms lately, Oregon has no identity on the field and that's the scariest of all. I've wanted to like the Helf hire and am thankful for what's he achieved early on in his head coaching stay at Oregon, but it's time to move on. It's time to find our identity again.
Like many of you, I believe the downfall started the moment Chip left for the NFL and the coaching job was essentially handed over to Helf. We all love Chip and yearn for the glory days to return, but let's not forget that he was adamant that the AD hire Helf to replace him, which was the first domino to fall. I've heard reports that Chris Peterson was interested in the job back in 2013 and we even interviewed Stanford OC Pep Hamilton, but it was a foregone conclusion the job would be passed along to Helf, just as it was from Chip and Bellotti before him.
I will say that it wasn't Helf why we lost the Natty in 2014 and that he was probably the correct short-term hire since the 2012 team finished the season 12-1 and was loaded for the near future with Marcus being just a RS Freshman at the time. However, Marcus could've made anyone look amazing at Head Coach and we'd likely not be in the position now had we thought bigger picture.
But when did it start to slip?
A lot will point to recruiting, but all things considered, Helf has done a better job of offering kids earlier in the process, securing more verbals in the off-season, and keeping our recruiting ranking in the Top 25. (*NOTE* I made this statement before looking up their class rankings. I was surprised to find out that Helf has never had a Top 15 Class on Rivals, even after a Heisman winner and Natty appearance. I take it back, recruiting is a key turning point.)
Recruiting Ranking (Rivals)
Chip-
2009: 34
2010: 13
2011: 9
2012: 16
Average: 18
Helf-
2013: 22
2014: 23
2015: 17
2016: 28
Average: 22.5
The biggest difference is Chip was able to capitalize off of our early BCS successes, especially the Fiesta Bowl vs Auburn. We're no longer in the running for the 5*'s on the West Coast like DAT and Arik Armstead. Any while I mentioned earlier that Helf is throwing out more early offers and securing earlier commitments, Kelly's staff was better at evaluating talent, especially on defense. Outside of Troy Dye, who's the last impact linebacker we've recruited? Michael Clay? Bo Lokombo?
Recruiting aside, the first red flag occurred in a late-season contest down in Tucson against the Wildcats of Arizona. After Stanford lost to USC, the Ducks were now in position to get back to the Rose Bowl for the third time in five years. All we had to do was beat UA and OSU and we'd be in the PAC-12 title game. Fortunately, I was not able to watch this game as a I was attending a good friend's wedding, but we got clobbered, clobbered like no Duck team has been clobbered since the 2004 Civil War or 2006 Vegas Bowl. Ka'Deem Carey ran wild on our defense and the Top 5 Ducks got blown out, 42-16 against a mediocre-at-best Wildcats team.
Since that game in 2013, Oregon has lost by 22 to Ohio State in 2014, 42 to Utah in the worst defeat at Autzen to Utah in 2015, blew a 31-0 halftime lead in the Alamo Bowl against TCU in 2015, lost three straight for the first time since 2007, including an 18-point loss to Washington State (the second straight year WSU has lost to an FCS school at home but defeated Oregon).
That was the first red flag. With everything on the line, a Chip Kelly team would NEVER have failed to show up like that. The Boise St. game in 2009 aside, which we only lost by 11 points by the way, Oregon was beat by double-figures just ONCE in his four seasons at the helm - a 40-27 loss to one of the best LSU teams during the 2011 season opener.
Red Flag No. 2: If Marcus was dinged or bruised or hurt in any way shape or form, the team went south. Marcus was plan A, B, C, D, E, etc. While all Duck fans should be eternally grateful that Helf discovered Mariota and urged Chip to offer him, it was under his watch that no other quarterback has been developed to this day. Marcus took the reigns in 2012 and our most capable backup to date has been Bryan Bennett.
Our 2013 season went down the drain after Marcus was hurt (that Stanford game was one to forget) and so was 2015 when Vernon was injured. For a program who has a reputation for putting out elite college quarterbacks (Fouts, Akili, Joey, Kellen, Dennis, DT, Marcus), especially recently, to only have one capable quarterback on the roster is unfathomable. Now we're two years removed from Mariota and we've had to go the graduate transfer route for the second consecutive year. To be clear: I know not every QB will be Marcus and that we'll likely never, ever see anyone like him ... but it needs to be better.
Red Flag No. 3: This post is getting long, even for my liking, so I'll keep this one short and sweet. Oregon has a tendency to hire from within, to a fault. It's worked before (Bellotti, Kelly, etc), but it feels like they've went to the well once too often. Pellum felt more like a lifetime achievement promotion than anything else, Helf was given the job without really even considering anyone else, and Lubick feels like he should've stayed as a positions coach as his play-calling has been abysmal.
Final Red Flag: Our swagger is gone. There's no more Win The Day mantra. Sure, Win The Day is still on the walls of Autzen Stadium, but do you think it really embodies the Oregon program anymore? I don't. We're more undisciplined on the football field than ever (I will give Helf credit that his players are good members of the community outside the field *knock on wood*). The tempo is gone. "Big Balls" Chip-mentality is gone. Yes, Helf goes for two, but it's not the right timing. We're punting way too often, playing way too conservative. No one fears Oregon anymore.
I think it was TK1 who stated last week that this downward spiral wouldn't be so bad had we won it all in 2010 or 2014, but we've been so close in chasing that elusive Natty that it feels like we may never get back. After all, we are in Oregon and we're not on fertile recruiting grounds. The question does come up: Are the best days of Oregon football behind us? The answer scares the living daylights out of me.
Like our uniforms lately, Oregon has no identity on the field and that's the scariest of all. I've wanted to like the Helf hire and am thankful for what's he achieved early on in his head coaching stay at Oregon, but it's time to move on. It's time to find our identity again.