Page 1 of 2
Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 7:49 am
by Alan
For the guys wanting Helf's head during or after this season, our anyone. Just a hypothetical, let's say DP was never made DC when NA retired and they hired a top name like a Hoke or proven defensive coach who came in a went to a 4-3. Now flash forward and with two + years of the 4-3, recruiting for a 4-3, we are seeing the defense coming together, not top notch but coming around. The Ducks win one of the 3 point loss games and are 3-2 instead of 2-3. Do you give Helf a little more rope?
In short how much did DP's performance put Helf on the hot seat, I'm under the impression promoting DP was not Helf's decision.
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 7:57 am
by dthomas=ddixon
I don't deal with hypotheticals.
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 8:05 am
by Alan
dthomas=ddixon wrote:I don't deal with hypotheticals.
Okay, how much did Hiring DP have to do with HelF's hot seat?
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 8:06 am
by rockthief
The problems I see began as soon as Coach Helfrich took over. Giving Pellum the defense was only one thing albeit a big boo boo.
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 9:09 am
by OregonFan4Life
I've been wondering if DP has taken too much of the blame and really Helf is the problem, cause the defense isn't any better and we still see the same issues, disorganization and poor communication.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 9:13 am
by buckmarkduck
Hoke isn't a top name. Helf could have survived the Pellum debacle, but he compounded it by hikring a guy who wanted to go to a 4-3. He had to get this hire right, and didn't. Imagine if Bellotti hadn't hired a decent OC after getting rid of Ludwig? While he didn't hire the greatest OC in the world, it was good enough to get UO back to 10-2, allowed us to get to know the spread and land Chip. Helf hired a guy who had no experience as a DC, over multiple Ducks all of who would have had a much better chance of having our d being in the top 70 at least right now. Wilcox, Sirmon and especially Nolan would have all been better hires right now. To bad he wouldn't part with any coaches to make the hire of Nolan official, that's all a successful NFL DC asked for, and Helf blew it.
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 9:47 am
by gofightingducks
DP promotion, Lubick promotion aside, the problem I see with Helf is he doesn't have the CEO mentality and that is what this program needs right now. He is too nice and is not saying the right things to motivate these guys, he doesn't seem to be hands on enough with the coaches and players, he is apparently not even communicating things well even to the other coaches. He doesn't have control of this program, players are blaming each other, coaches are making mistakes, there is no discipline, seemingly a sense of entitlement by not just players but coaches as well. This team is getting worse not better, Herbert should have been put in sooner, stupid play calls are being made, stupid mistakes, lack of discipline, players are not playing with fire, passion, desire, with a good head coach, things would improve not worsen, if coordinators or position coaches are not doing their job you step in to help. He keeps saying "it all starts with me" yeah, it does and what is he doing about it, apparently nothing. It was expected the defense would struggle with youth and a new system, it was expected there would be some drop off with a new QB and a young line, a new QB coach and coordinator but you would expect to see some improvement as the season progresses, the team is getting worse, not better. It is time to become more hands on and light a fire under the coaches and players, put in some young guys and let them get the experience necessary to get this program back to where it should be because as things are why waste anymore time with a graduate transfer QB and others who are not performing to expectations, there is not another winnable game outside of the civil war with this kind of play, at this point you have to "win the day" and the program is not doing that.
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 9:56 am
by fpsduck
In that scenario we are still stuck with Lubick @ OC.
Helf's hirings have been awful. I have to question his judgement.
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 3:10 pm
by jefflockie
Lubick is not impressive either. This is the guy who decieded to play Jeff Lockie the whole second half of the Alamo bowl. Why didn't he try the wildcat? Royce Freeman and Addison taking direct snaps would have been better offense than Lubick + a QB.
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 3:13 pm
by pezsez1
I'm actually shocked that Lubick has been so disappointing. He was such a great WR coach, and he seemed like such a natural candidate to take over at OC. I don't think a single person on this forum raised questions when he was promoted.
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 3:16 pm
by buckmarkduck
jefflockie wrote:Lubick is not impressive either. This is the guy who decieded to play Jeff Lockie the whole second half of the Alamo bowl. Why didn't he try the wildcat? Royce Freeman and Addison taking direct snaps would have been better offense than Lubick + a QB.
You can put a lot on Lubick this year, but the HC still decides who plays qb. I'd also think at some point Helfrich would start calling the plays, since the O has been stuck in about 3rd gear.
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 4:04 pm
by GoDucksIn09
I agree the play calling has been horrible. It has been all year but we are also starting 4 freshman on the offensive line which is unheard of and not ok with. They make holding mistakes or personal fouls that compound the problem because they do not have the discipline to not do it. The problems on offense have several contributing factors. I am not saying that the OC is doing a great job but am recognizing the deficiencies the offense has. I am not qualified as to how much those issues are contributing to the play calling.
In terms of Helfrich it is the decision making. He knew was issues with the center snapping ball against TCU and did nothing to correct it. It was on his watch we lost to Utah at home by largest ever margin at Autzen. We lost two games at Autzen in the same year since 2007. We have lost 3 in row as stands right now soon to be 4th. The next one will be against a team we have beat 12 straight times. This is all on his watch. The communication not there between the coaches. Hoke did not know Dye would not be playing at WSU... yet Dye plays defense. The list goes on and on and Saturday will probably add more to the list why Helfrich needs to go. I could add more reasons but those are enough to warrant being fired. The product Oregon is putting on the field is not worth what the university is charging people to watch the game.
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 4:25 pm
by buckmarkduck
What sucks about this holds and personal fouls on the OL. Half of them have been on the lone sr.
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 4:32 pm
by pezsez1
Hoke did not know Dye would not be playing at WSU.
Is that true?
The only statement I saw was Hoke basically saying, "I don't want to talk about it, that's the head coach's business." I didn't see him say "I wasn't aware he didn't make the trip, nobody told me."
Re: Question for guys who want Helf's head.
Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 4:34 pm
by Sooth
I remember the day Oregon announced the promotion of Pellum to DC my brother called me and said Helfrich just cost himself his job. Everyone knew that was an atrocious hire from the word go. Hard to believe Helf bungled that so badly. But the man is impressive with the backups though, I'll give him that.
I'm still a believer in Lubes. First year as a playcaller, freshman o-line, statue for a quarterback. He'll put it together. That one drive against Colorado where we drove the length of the field riding Tony James the whole way felt like vintage Oregon. I'd like to see more bullheadedness when it comes to establishing the ground game like he who shall not be named used to do.