Page 1 of 1

Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 9:59 am
by Bighonkingduck

Re: Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 10:11 am
by pezsez1
Helfrich takes heat for not developing a QB behind Mariota, even though the recruiting was actually pretty good and some guys simply didn't pan out.

This is actually an area where I think Helfrich deserves praise. When it became clear our stable of QBs wasn't good enough to compete in the Pac-12, he went outside the box and recruited VA/Prukop to Oregon. While Prukop wasn't good enough to single-handedly keep the Ducks in the CFP hunt, Vernon Adams was a HUGE get who helped us avoid a serious letdown last year. We were the class of the Pac-12 when VA was healthy.

In the meantime, Helfrich hired Yost, a proven QB guru with a track record of developing studs. Recruiting at the QB position hasn't skipped a beat, either, and from what we know of Herbert (and the line he'll be playing behind) the future seems very bright.

Re: Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 10:17 am
by Alan
I have never been on the VA bandwagon, but I shutter think what last year would have been without him, just Lockie, Alie and anyone else that wanted to try playing it. Can't remember who the wr was that took a few snaps.

Re: Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 11:14 am
by hjpop
Think it was Braylon Addison that took snaps last year.

Speaking of Lockie, what is he doing now? Is he the sign holder and Alie is the holder for PATs?

Re: Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 11:18 am
by Alan
hjpop wrote:Think it was Braylon Addison that took snaps last year.

Speaking of Lockie, what is he doing now? Is he the sign holder and Alie is the holder for PATs?
Yes to both, Alie went back to holding PAT's after the 2 point fiasco.

Re: Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 11:26 am
by FlDuckFan
Alan wrote:
hjpop wrote:Think it was Braylon Addison that took snaps last year.

Speaking of Lockie, what is he doing now? Is he the sign holder and Alie is the holder for PATs?
Yes to both, Alie went back to holding PAT's after the 2 point fiasco.
Lockie is just the clipboard guy now. He may not be the most talented guy but he knows the playbook and with Yost up in the box he could help Herbert with some small things during the game.

Re: Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 11:33 am
by buckmarkduck
This is one time I'll stick up for Helf. Have any of these bloggers or so called experts paid attention to the rest of the abs in the confrence? There was some bad talent for a couple years on the west coast, and most of the teams are now starting SO or Fr. You can't develop a crap sandwich at qb, which is what Jake Rod turned out to be and Morgan was. Neither are BCS level abs, both where way overrated coming out of HS.

Re: Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 12:21 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
buckmarkduck wrote:This is one time I'll stick up for Helf. Have any of these bloggers or so called experts paid attention to the rest of the abs in the confrence? There was some bad talent for a couple years on the west coast, and most of the teams are now starting SO or Fr. You can't develop a crap sandwich at qb, which is what Jake Rod turned out to be and Morgan was. Neither are BCS level abs, both where way overrated coming out of HS.
This brings up something I was thinking about yesterday after Duck07 brought up how much talent we had on some of the older teams ('05 for example).

Has the staff dropped the ball a bit on doing their own talent evaluation? Recruiting has changed a lot since even 5 years ago and it seems like it would be easy for a staff, especially now that Oregon has so much more sway with recruits, to rely too much on chasing stars.

Just look at Herbert. Every QB we've recruited since Mariota was a top flight Elite 11 guy. They all sucked. Now, the first QB we bring in that's an under the radar "find" looks to be a complete stud.

Re: Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 12:45 pm
by QuackininBama
Good coaches are able to overcome a position deficiency, even at the quarterback spot.
  • Brodie Croyle
    John Parker Wilson
    Greg McElroy
    AJ McCarron
    Blake Sims
    Jake Coker
    Jalen Hurts
Saban has never had a truly elite quarterback at Bama and he doesn't even care. He still wins titles. Heck we got beat by a backup quarterback in the national championship. A good coach, a coach of a top tier football program should be prepared and have a guy ready, even if he doesn't have the skills of a Mariota, Watson or Barrett. I am fully aware that Helf has forgotten more about football then I will ever know, but I can spot a coach who is simply in over his head as well. I like him, hes a really nice guy but the fact is, the program is bigger than him and hes screwing it up, badly.

Re: Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 12:50 pm
by buckmarkduck
QuackininBama wrote:Good coaches are able to overcome a position deficiency, even at the quarterback spot.
  • Brodie Croyle
    John Parker Wilson
    Greg McElroy
    AJ McCarron
    Blake Sims
    Jake Coker
    Jalen Hurts
Saban has never had a truly elite quarterback at Bama and he doesn't even care. He still wins titles. Heck we got beat by a backup quarterback in the national championship. A good coach, a coach of a top tier football program should be prepared and have a guy ready, even if he doesn't have the skills of a Mariota, Watson or Barrett. I am fully aware that Helf has forgotten more about football then I will ever know, but I can spot a coach who is simply in over his head as well. I like him, hes a really nice guy but the fact is, the program is bigger than him and hes screwing it up, badly.
Yeah give any coach the D and OL Sabah had, and they would win. Is this a joke? He's not some great coach because he beats team with equal talent, when all things are equal he's a 7-9 win team, see Michigan St. Saban is Bellichick, he just has far superior talent.

Re: Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 12:54 pm
by Duck24
Bama also has dominant OL and skill guys surrounding those game managers, not to mention defenses. They rarely need big time QB play to win games, unlike Oregon. Would I like Oregon to get that point? Absolutely but I would also like to win the lottery and those two things have approximately the same chances of happening.

Re: Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 1:09 pm
by QuackininBama
buckmarkduck wrote:
QuackininBama wrote:Good coaches are able to overcome a position deficiency, even at the quarterback spot.
  • Brodie Croyle
    John Parker Wilson
    Greg McElroy
    AJ McCarron
    Blake Sims
    Jake Coker
    Jalen Hurts
Saban has never had a truly elite quarterback at Bama and he doesn't even care. He still wins titles. Heck we got beat by a backup quarterback in the national championship. A good coach, a coach of a top tier football program should be prepared and have a guy ready, even if he doesn't have the skills of a Mariota, Watson or Barrett. I am fully aware that Helf has forgotten more about football then I will ever know, but I can spot a coach who is simply in over his head as well. I like him, hes a really nice guy but the fact is, the program is bigger than him and hes screwing it up, badly.
Yeah give any coach the D and OL Sabah had, and they would win. Is this a joke? He's not some great coach because he beats team with equal talent, when all things are equal he's a 7-9 win team, see Michigan St. Saban is Bellichick, he just has far superior talent.
I guess you didn't see the records of DuBose (24-23), Franchione (17-8) and Shula (26-23) before Saban got there. Being the head coach of Bama is no guarantee, HE RECRUITED THEM. All things are not equal because he recruits the best kids in the country and they want to play for him because he wins football games. Recruiting and coaching go hand in hand.

Re: Helfrich's quarterback mess at Oregon

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 1:19 pm
by FlDuckFan
QuackininBama wrote:Good coaches are able to overcome a position deficiency, even at the quarterback spot.
  • Brodie Croyle
    John Parker Wilson
    Greg McElroy
    AJ McCarron
    Blake Sims
    Jake Coker
    Jalen Hurts
Saban has never had a truly elite quarterback at Bama and he doesn't even care. He still wins titles. Heck we got beat by a backup quarterback in the national championship. A good coach, a coach of a top tier football program should be prepared and have a guy ready, even if he doesn't have the skills of a Mariota, Watson or Barrett. I am fully aware that Helf has forgotten more about football then I will ever know, but I can spot a coach who is simply in over his head as well. I like him, hes a really nice guy but the fact is, the program is bigger than him and hes screwing it up, badly.
He had sub par QB's to go along with his elite Defense. When we had Mariota we had a sub par Defense to go along with out elite QB...