Page 1 of 1
Nemec article on defensive slide
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2016 11:31 am
by greenyellow
Andrew Nemec has put up an interesting article that analyzes Oregon's defensive woes by comparing the recruiting of the past 5 classes. Main conclusion from it is that Oregon severely underrecruited the LB and DB spots in the 2012 and 2013 classes, leaving the younger classes to shoulder much more of the load than they probably should have. You could say this is sort of an indictment of Chip, Helf, and every defensive coach for not recruiting better talent and/or developing it.
http://www.oregonlive.com/recruiting/in ... ncart_2box
Re: Nemec article on defensive slide
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2016 11:46 am
by QuackininBama
That was a very good article, great read:
During that timeframe, Oregon signed a total of four high school, three junior college and one FBS transfer at linebacker – just enough to fill out a true two-deep for its 3-4 defense (8) and the fewest in the Pac-12.
Here's a look at how many linebackers other programs recruited in that timeframe (Of note: "Athlete" recruits who play linebacker at Oregon were counted toward the Ducks' total, but were not for the programs listed below):
Alabama – 14
Arizona – 11
Arizona State – 15
Cal – 13
Colorado – 5* (*signed multiple "athletes" who played linebacker exclusively in college)
Ohio State – 14
Oregon State – 9
Stanford – 10
UCLA – 13
USC – 9
Utah – 9
Washington – 9
Washington State – 9
WOW
Re: Nemec article on defensive slide
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2016 11:51 am
by greenyellow
That LB stat is probably the most shocking. Basically, Oregon failed to plan ahead for when all their talented LBs would be gone. That's a big reason why I think Pellum should be one of the first people gone should they do a staff change.
Re: Nemec article on defensive slide
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2016 12:43 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
It still doesn't justify having the worst defense in the entire nation. That is an absurdity.
Re: Nemec article on defensive slide
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2016 12:56 pm
by QuackininBama
dthomas=ddixon wrote:It still doesn't justify having the worst defense in the entire nation. That is an absurdity.
I don't think its necessarily a justification as much as a "how did we get here".
Re: Nemec article on defensive slide
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2016 2:01 pm
by pezsez1
Is this really a big surprise though?
Combine those recruiting woes with the fact we've struggled to get monster defensive linemen. Now that Buckner's gone, not a single person on our D line commands a double team, and nobody is an every-down threat to blow up the other team's line -- just as big of a reason why we have zero pass rush this season.
I don't care how good our corners are. If there's zero pass rush (to the point our coaches gave up on trying against WSU), then receivers eventually get open and the QB eventually finds them. Or, while nobody is trying to rush, the QB can just run for easy yardage.
Our D has now played under two schemes and two coaches. The results look the same. I have no interest on weighing in on the quality of fundamentals/schematics being taught -- none of us really knows those things -- but I do think Oregon's biggest problem on D is an issue of Billies and Joes.
Whiffs, coaching changes, sanctions and some bad press all joined together to damage our recruiting in recent years.
Re: Nemec article on defensive slide
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2016 2:31 pm
by karlhungis
pezsez1 wrote:Is this really a big surprise though?
Combine those recruiting woes with the fact we've struggled to get monster defensive linemen. Now that Buckner's gone, not a single person on our D line commands a double team, and nobody is an every-down threat to blow up the other team's line -- just as big of a reason why we have zero pass rush this season.
I don't care how good our corners are. If there's zero pass rush (to the point our coaches gave up on trying against WSU), then receivers eventually get open and the QB eventually finds them. Or, while nobody is trying to rush, the QB can just run for easy yardage.
Our D has now played under two schemes and two coaches. The results look the same. I have no interest on weighing in on the quality of fundamentals/schematics being taught -- none of us really knows those things -- but I do think Oregon's biggest problem on D is an issue of Billies and Joes.
Whiffs, coaching changes, sanctions and some bad press all joined together to damage our recruiting in recent years.
Are we really blaming sanctions?
Re: Nemec article on defensive slide
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2016 2:51 pm
by pezsez1
Are we really blaming sanctions?
Uh, yes?
The sanctions gutted the number of official visits we could offer to recruits... from 56 to 37 for three academic years. That's HUGE. We also had fewer evaluation days and couldn't use recruiting services, putting us at a disadvantage to virtually every other program in the country.
Don't be distracted by the one-scholarship reduction... that wasn't what hurt us.
Re: Nemec article on defensive slide
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2016 6:00 pm
by Kimber45
pezsez1 wrote:Combine those recruiting woes with the fact we've struggled to get monster defensive linemen. Now that Buckner's gone, not a single person on our D line commands a double team, and nobody is an every-down threat to blow up the other team's line -- just as big of a reason why we have zero pass rush this season.
This is the part that baffles me.
The following bodies are available to play NT/DT: Manu, Maolata, Carlberg, George, Tei-Kirby, Kamatule, Baker, Ratu and probably another fatty or two. If the roster weights are to be believed these are not small men. Mondeaux has also been taking some snaps on the interior. Which is fine, though it seems like we are still experimenting with positions six games in.
All we need is to find/develop a two deep of four guys who can smoosh-up the interior of the opposing team's offensive line and get pressure to the QB. Not every play, just consistent pressure from the interior of the D line.
I'm not suggesting that playing NT against Stanford is some sort of gentle jog on the park followed by a cigarette and a brandy. But I sort of want to overnight Canton a package with a Red Bull and a note that says "Dear Canton, before you take your five third string snaps in the upcoming game please drink the enclosed beverage and remember that your job is not to play slap and tickle with the guard but to move him out of your way and tackle the tall, skinny guy behind him with that hand egg thing. Best wishes, Kimber."
I'm not trying to pick on Mr. Kamatule specifically, I'd just like to see one of the interior D linemen start putting it together and decide that they are going to be wrecking ball in the middle of the D line which makes almost everything about the rest of the defense a little bit better/easier.
Re: Nemec article on defensive slide
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2016 8:35 pm
by buckmarkduck
Being fat doesn't matter at DL. People put to much stock in size, rather than a kid just being a player. I'd take a DL that weighs 280 across the board, but are quick twitch athletes who can beat the OL. Our guys right now just let the OL block them, which is opposite of what Hoke was preaching all summer about being an attacking D.
As for Canton, he should move to Right Tackle immediately and stop trying to be a DL. Kid could be a monster on the OL, but he's not a DT.
Re: Nemec article on defensive slide
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2016 8:38 pm
by FlDuckFan
buckmarkduck wrote:Being fat doesn't matter at DL. People put to much stock in size, rather than a kid just being a player. I'd take a DL that weighs 280 across the board, but are quick twitch athletes who can beat the OL. Our guys right now just let the OL block them, which is opposite of what Hoke was preaching all summer about being an attacking D.
As for Canton, he should move to Tackle immediately and stop trying to be a DL. Kid could be a monster on the OL, but he's not a DT.
That's what everyone said about Armstead who took 2 years to make an impact.
Re: Nemec article on defensive slide
Posted: Mon Oct 10, 2016 8:42 pm
by buckmarkduck
Armstead was still much further along at this point that what Canton is. Right now if we had that Armstead, he'd be the best player on the D not named Dye.