Page 1 of 1
Is Charles Nelson worth the risk?
Posted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 9:13 am
by DuckMastaFunk
So I'm sure this won't be a popular topic; we all love Charles Nelson; but do his big-play potential positives outweigh his game-changing negatives?
This year we've seen fumbles, dropped passes, deflections resulting in interceptions, etc. Of course Nelson still has big play possibility, but we've seen more missteps than big plays.
At what point do coaches decide to move him down the depth chart? At what point do coaches tell him he needs to be on defense if he wants to help the team, regardless of what he wants to do?
Re: Is Charles Nelson worth the risk?
Posted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 9:21 am
by Duck24
He just seems to be trying too hard to make the big play on every play. Last year, it was paying off for him, this year like everything else with this team, it's going sideways for him. I wouldn't advocate for him being moved down because he is one of the guys who obviously cares. You can never say he isn't giving his all, hopefully more people follow suit.
Re: Is Charles Nelson worth the risk?
Posted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 10:14 am
by pezsez1
He would be such a phenomenal safety if he actually made that his focus!
Re: Is Charles Nelson worth the risk?
Posted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 2:41 pm
by DuckMastaFunk
Back to the Helf being too nice criticism, anyone think if Saban was HC that Nelson would be at WR?
As a side not Saban autocorrected to "Satan" .

!!!
Re: Is Charles Nelson worth the risk?
Posted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 3:02 pm
by pezsez1
Back to the Helf being too nice criticism, anyone think if Saban was HC that Nelson would be at WR?
To be fair, this is something where I completely back Helfrich.
In the past, a big part of our recruiting pitch is we'll be somewhat flexible in letting guys play where they want to play... good examples would be Lyerla playing offense and Armstead playing defense. That offer of flexibility gives us leverage with recruits. And if we suddenly took that away from a guy, then we'd no longer be able to make that pledge on the recruiting trail while keeping a straight face.
Sure, that whole mentality might go away if we get a new coach, but giving players some control over their football careers has worked out well for us since at least the start of the Chip era. This isn't remotely our biggest problem right now, and it really has nothing to do with whether coaches are too nice. It's a matter of integrity, which is perhaps where our coaching staff has an advantage over the Meyers/Sabans of college football.
Re: Is Charles Nelson worth the risk?
Posted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 5:53 pm
by GoDucksIn09
I truly agree with the notion he is trying to hard. The thing has become to mental. Instead of just using his abilities to let things happen and come to him he is trying to hard and the end result is the miscues... the fumbles.. dropped passes... deflections. I think he has great attributes he just needs to take it down a notch and allow it to come instead of trying so hard. I also agree that lots of his teammates should also be trying as hard as him.
Re: Is Charles Nelson worth the risk?
Posted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 6:12 pm
by buckmarkduck
pezsez1 wrote:Back to the Helf being too nice criticism, anyone think if Saban was HC that Nelson would be at WR?
To be fair, this is something where I completely back Helfrich.
In the past, a big part of our recruiting pitch is we'll be somewhat flexible in letting guys play where they want to play... good examples would be Lyerla playing offense and Armstead playing defense. That offer of flexibility gives us leverage with recruits. And if we suddenly took that away from a guy, then we'd no longer be able to make that pledge on the recruiting trail while keeping a straight face.
Sure, that whole mentality might go away if we get a new coach, but giving players some control over their football careers has worked out well for us since at least the start of the Chip era. This isn't remotely our biggest problem right now, and it really has nothing to do with whether coaches are too nice. It's a matter of integrity, which is perhaps where our coaching staff has an advantage over the Meyers/Sabans of college football.
Yeah, I've talked to quite a few HS coaches who played against Lyerla, and all agree he wasn't a great LB. One told me he would have been a lot like Mattingly. So I don't think we really "let" Colt decide what he wanted to play.
Re: Is Charles Nelson worth the risk?
Posted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 8:48 pm
by DuckMastaFunk
pezsez1 wrote:Back to the Helf being too nice criticism, anyone think if Saban was HC that Nelson would be at WR?
To be fair, this is something where I completely back Helfrich.
In the past, a big part of our recruiting pitch is we'll be somewhat flexible in letting guys play where they want to play... good examples would be Lyerla playing offense and Armstead playing defense. That offer of flexibility gives us leverage with recruits. And if we suddenly took that away from a guy, then we'd no longer be able to make that pledge on the recruiting trail while keeping a straight face.
Sure, that whole mentality might go away if we get a new coach, but giving players some control over their football careers has worked out well for us since at least the start of the Chip era. This isn't remotely our biggest problem right now, and it really has nothing to do with whether coaches are too nice. It's a matter of integrity, which is perhaps where our coaching staff has an advantage over the Meyers/Sabans of college football.
I hear what you're saying Pez. However, players down on the depth chart are told to switch positions all the time. You are right, the top recruits have received star treatment. Personally, it feels more lie a double standard than a matter of integrity.
Personally I'd rather see Nelson be told that it's about the team, not him. Besides, I believe his pro prospects are better at Safety.