Page 1 of 1

MADDER THAN HELL II: Lack of Defensive Talent?!!

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2016 9:47 am
by FishDuck
This contention about the lack of defensive talent is a CROCK. If you want a quick example of what the real problem is—from our best player on defense, (Troy Dye) then this article will help. It is an easy one to follow, (An Editorial) and read-it-there, and comment-here as usual.

http://fishduck.com/2016/11/madder-than ... ve-talent/

Re: MADDER THAN HELL II: Lack of Defensive Talent?!!

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2016 10:24 am
by maxduck
I wonder if the chemistry on the coaching staff has deteriorated. Under Nick Alioti what was essentially the same staff taught enough fundamentals that we could argue whether the defense was decent or not. Now the product on the field appears uncoached and players bicker among themselves. I have trouble believing the assistants suddenly forgot how to teach, perhaps the close knit family atmosphere of the football staff broken.

Re: MADDER THAN HELL II: Lack of Defensive Talent?!!

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2016 10:32 am
by Duck07
Well this only reinforces what I've said but one thing about Nicks D that was evident was he at least was trying to stop the run. I disagreed with how he went about it but it was a plan. For three years now I haven't been able to tell what their plan is in a given game or situation.

That Nick was competent in that regard isn't that big of a shock at this level of football. That we've declined this badly is shocking.

Re: MADDER THAN HELL II: Lack of Defensive Talent?!!

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2016 2:23 pm
by pudgejeff
Do you not include intelligence, technique, application part of talent? Talent is not equal to athleticsm, talent is all of the above. Just another lazy article/post. I'm not defending the defense, it's bad, but this isn't some insight.

Re: MADDER THAN HELL II: Lack of Defensive Talent?!!

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2016 2:25 pm
by karlhungis
Does he ever come back to discuss his articles or is it pretty much just blogspamming at this point?

Re: MADDER THAN HELL II: Lack of Defensive Talent?!!

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2016 2:27 pm
by pudgejeff
karlhungis wrote:Does he ever come back to discuss his articles or is it pretty much just blogspamming at this point?
I think he got tired of people bashing the articles. I had stopped even giving him clicks for a long time, but needed to go read if I was gonna post about it. Learned my lesson again, that will be the last time.

Re: MADDER THAN HELL II: Lack of Defensive Talent?!!

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2016 3:04 pm
by GrandpaDuck
I agree with the premise. Oregon is not the 126th team in terms of raw talent. Not top 10 or even top 25 but not 125 or worse.

I assume you want no dissenting discussion of the actual sample play presented.

I always check in....

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2016 8:12 pm
by FishDuck
I do check in and if someone has a question--I try to take time to answer. But after working for as many hours as I do on the analysis article and then the editorial--I sometimes just want to get recharged after an intense weekend.

Someone doesn't like my work? No sweat. But many have learned more football from my work right alongside me as I'm learning, and it has been fun.

Of course the big-talkers don't ever contribute anything--just criticize. I've seen that a lot over the last five years, so I generally don't respond to it.

Different views that are well thought out I do welcome as I learn from them...you can see that in the comments on the site.

And....if anyone thinks I get a lot of "hits" from this site? Dream on. There are some posters who I like here and thought I'd be courteous to them...

FD

Re: MADDER THAN HELL II: Lack of Defensive Talent?!!

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2016 8:58 pm
by pezsez1
Well this only reinforces what I've said but one thing about Nicks D that was evident was he at least was trying to stop the run. I disagreed with how he went about it but it was a plan. For three years now I haven't been able to tell what their plan is in a given game or situation.
Yep.

Obviously, I was a much bigger fan of NA, but everything he did started with stopping the run. Yeah, this bit us for a couple years after Harrington left when our secondary cupboard was bare, but even then, he left his corners out on islands to stop the run. Teams had to prepare for NA stacking the box and sending all kinds of blitzes, and if his corners got burnt deep, so be it, as long as the run was stopped.

This defense though... ????

God, I hate to say this... but the identity of this unit is trying not to give up touchdowns... which is NOT the same as trying to get stops. And even that's not an identity. It's just hard to watch.

Re: MADDER THAN HELL II: Lack of Defensive Talent?!!

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2016 9:55 pm
by GoDucksIn09
If took a top tiered high school team and put it against our defense I think our defense would probably still give up touchdowns. That is how bad our defense is.

Re: MADDER THAN HELL II: Lack of Defensive Talent?!!

Posted: Wed Nov 16, 2016 11:13 am
by Duck07
GoDucksIn09 wrote:If took a top tiered high school team and put it against our defense I think our defense would probably still give up touchdowns. That is how bad our defense is.
We could beat Linfield...in a shoot-out. I'm totally cool with the ghost of Dewey Sullivan as coach, lol.