Page 1 of 2
I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to raid UH
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2016 12:52 pm
by GrandpaDuck
First the thought that you could get both Herman and Orlando is a pipe dream. Orlando is going to get 2-4 times more money than Oregon could pay him as DC, as a head coach somewhere.
Second, You could wave a huge pay raise at Orlando to be an HC, with Herman he is already extremely well paid for a non power 5 HC and is in a huge recruiting hot bed and at a school that may soon become a Power 5.
Orlando could be the Head Coach and defacto DC like Kelly was with the offense. We already have good offensive coaches so we wouldn't need Houston's who probably wouldn't come anyway.
Read here and discuss at Fishducks. Wait ... strike that.
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2016 12:57 pm
by duckfan22
I agree even tho i love offense i believe the head coach should be defensive minded.
Defense is what has been winning championships..Orlando is an excellent coach
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2016 1:06 pm
by Phenom
duckfan22 wrote:I agree even tho i love offense i believe the head coach should be defensive minded.
Defense is what has been winning championships..Orlando is an excellent coach
Not true. Last 4 NCG scores:
2015 January 11, 2016 2 Alabama 45 1 Clemson 40
2014 January 12, 2015 4 Ohio State 42 2 Oregon 20
2013 January 6, 2014 1 Florida St. 34 2 Auburn 31
2012 January 7, 2013 2 Alabama 42 1 Notre Dame 14
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2016 1:40 pm
by GrandpaDuck
Phenom wrote:duckfan22 wrote:I agree even tho i love offense i believe the head coach should be defensive minded.
Defense is what has been winning championships..Orlando is an excellent coach
Not true. Last 4 NCG scores:
2015 January 11, 2016 2 Alabama 45 1 Clemson 40
2014 January 12, 2015 4 Ohio State 42 2 Oregon 20
2013 January 6, 2014 1 Florida St. 34 2 Auburn 31
2012 January 7, 2013 2 Alabama 42 1 Notre Dame 14
Defensive rank DR / points per game. Offensive Rank / points per game
2015 Alabama Defense: 2 / 15.1 Offense 30 / 35.1
2015 Clemson Defense: 24/21.7 Offense 16 / 38.5
2014 OSU Defense: 26 / 22 Offense 5 / 44.8
2014 UO Defense: 31 / 23.6 Offense 4 / 45.6
2013 FSU Defense: 1 / 12.1 Offense 2 / 51.6
2013 AU Defense 47 / 24.7 Offense 12 / 39.5
2012 Alabama Defense 1 / 10.9 Offense 12 / 38.7
2012 Notre Dame Defense 2 / 12.8 Offense 80 / 25.8
Trend seems to be to have the mix of offense and defense that yields a plus 20 point differential, with just a couple of exceptions to get to the finals. Only one team made the finals averaging less than 35 per game offense. 3 of the 4 winners were the 1st or 2nd ranked defense in the country.
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2016 5:02 pm
by UOducksTK1
I'd take either.
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 1:36 am
by woundedknees
I'd take either one as well... In Herman, you get a coach who obviously recognizes the value of having an excellent defensive mind at his elbow. With Orlando, you have that defensive mind.
It would seem to be pretty much a win-win situation.
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 10:40 am
by Phenom
There is no guarantee that Orlando would be a good HC. I think he has the makings of one but I don't think a program like ours needs to take that risk. I would only take an NFL coordinator not a college one.
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 11:00 am
by Oregonian
Herman or bust. I get that we need something fresh and help defensively, but we're still Oregon - you can't drop a coach that took you to a NC for a G5 coordinator. If he doesn't bail for his own HC job after this season, there's still a chance Orlando wants to follow Herman wherever he goes so he can get a year of P5 coaching under his belt.
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 12:56 pm
by SuperDuck
Phenom wrote:There is no guarantee that Orlando would be a good HC. I think he has the makings of one but I don't think a program like ours needs to take that risk. I would only take an NFL coordinator not a college one.
This^^^^
We need a proven head coach - period. If we could get Orlando too, great! But Hermann is the guy we want.
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Sun Nov 20, 2016 12:33 pm
by GrandpaDuck
There is also no guarantee that Herman would be a good coach without his current coordinators. He has no track record without them.
With Orlando at least you have a track record of putting out good defenses regardless of head coach.
Both would be a larger risk them hiring a head coach with a larger more diverse resume but the topic was if you were focing on UH which would be the better hire.
I go with Orlando as much easier to actually hire him and about the same risk factor based on their histories. Also, we have proven offensive coaches we can keep. Adding just a new defense would be less disruptive to the brand.
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Sun Nov 20, 2016 12:35 pm
by GrandpaDuck
An NFL coordinator for what? DC or HC? That's like hiring a college coach for the NFL, the track record is not good despite some exceptions.
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Sun Nov 20, 2016 12:45 pm
by buckmarkduck
Im not buying that Phil Knight will be ok with a coordinator. First off name a NFL coach who's been successful in college in the last 20 years who had not college experience? Nick Saban is the closest thing, but he actually spent most of his career in college except for a few years in the NFL. And we've seen HC after HC fail when coming from the NFL. Give me a bonafide legit college HC. At this point we can't gamble anymore. Preferably one who runs a similar O so we don't have to change everything and suck next year also.
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Sun Nov 20, 2016 12:57 pm
by pezsez1
Bigger question is why would Herman choose Oregon if Texas comes knocking?
Texas wouldn't require as big of a move. He'd have recruiting inroads into a much bigger recruiting base. He'd already have tons of talent to work with.
Seems like Oregon would have to offer substantially more money to win that battle.
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Sun Nov 20, 2016 12:59 pm
by buckmarkduck
Herman and his wife are from California, so he's a west coast guy.
Re: I'd go after Orlando over Herman if you are going to rai
Posted: Sun Nov 20, 2016 1:14 pm
by GrandpaDuck
buckmarkduck wrote:Im not buying that Phil Knight will be ok with a coordinator. First off name a NFL coach who's been successful in college in the last 20 years who had not college experience? Nick Saban is the closest thing, but he actually spent most of his career in college except for a few years in the NFL. And we've seen HC after HC fail when coming from the NFL. Give me a bonafide legit college HC. At this point we can't gamble anymore. Preferably one who runs a similar O so we don't have to change everything and suck next year also.
I agree with this, but there was a ton of speculation about getting a coach from UH and I am addressing which of the two would be more realistic and perhaps the better fit.