Page 1 of 3
Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 5:19 pm
by vegasdom
What say you?
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 5:21 pm
by Duck24
I think beating Utah saved his job.
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 5:23 pm
by Phalanx
Duck24 wrote:I think beating Utah saved his job.
Same, although losing to the Beavers might lose it again.
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 5:24 pm
by pezsez1
Voted yes, on the condition we look good beating Oregon State.
I didn't expect us to look so overwhelmed so often this year. That said, I've repeatedly been surprised to see this team refuse to quit on the coaching staff. A gutsy win over a highly ranked team on the road -- especially with nothing to play for -- says something about the grit of this team. And as has been stated numerous times on this board, a team's character is a reflection of its coaching.
I'm still not sold on Lubick. Hoke is still a question mark, too.
Honestly, I think Helfrich keeps his job if we win the CW. But I'm at a point where I'm trusting the powers that be within the program will make the right choice when the season ends, whatever that may be.
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 5:35 pm
by EncinitasDuck
I think a win next weekend saves his job. Close to the end of the game the announcers mentioned that 24 of the 44 players on the two deep are freshman or redshirt freshman so our struggles on both sides of the ball are hardly surprising even though annoying. I doubt we'll be that much better on defense next year but maybe the offense can get back to scoring in the 40s consistently again since it appears we now have a QB again.
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 5:53 pm
by DAT_man_again
It shouldn't.
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 6:03 pm
by DAT_man_again
Don't let the emotion of a big win influence what you think of Helf. Fact is, we've lost by 50, 18, 25, and 25 and are 4-7. With all of the talent we have, there is no way we should have the worst defense in the power five conferences.
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 6:12 pm
by vegasdom
I say he stays if they beat the Beavers. Texas lost to Kansas today so their probably looking for a new coach and there is one right down in Houston. LSU might need a coach too. Unless Kelly or some other Big name coach wants the job, he stays.
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 6:59 pm
by OregonFan4Life
DAT_man_again wrote:Don't let the emotion of a big win influence what you think of Helf. Fact is, we've lost by 50, 18, 25, and 25 and are 4-7. With all of the talent we have, there is no way we should have the worst defense in the power five conferences.
This. This is Helf's fourth year and since he took over there's been too many failures on his part to let one big win overtake that. I said before the year keep Helf unless they have a losing record then fire him, and I'm going to stick with that. It was cool to see the Freshmen play hard today, but we need a solid coach who can lead and build a culture to take them far, and that's simply not Helf. Besides, despite the win, the coaching almost lost it today with the dumb timeout for an extra point and poor clock management, this wasn't a coaching win, this was the players making great plays including the game winner.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 7:01 pm
by woundedknees
It probably depends on if the Ducks obviously build on today's game and smother osu... If Oregon stumbles severely, and stinks up the field, all bets are off!
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 7:16 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
I get the feeling that those in charge are looking for an excuse to bring him back. I doubt he'll be let go at this point.
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 8:41 pm
by SuperDuck
dthomas=ddixon wrote:I get the feeling that those in charge are looking for an excuse to bring him back. I doubt he'll be let go at this point.
I think so too. There are several problems with firing Helfrich.
1. The Don Pellum hire that he was supposedly forced into and the whiffs on recruiting that resulted in it.
2. The new Coordinators on both sides of the ball. Both of them should improve next year and afterward.
3. The youth across the board on both sides of the ball. The two-deep is loaded with freshman, redshirt freshman and sophomores.
4. Injuries, suspensions and dismissals, particularly on the front-7 of the defense where we only had six starters returning in the first place.
5. The 3 close losses against Nebraska, Colorado and Cal. We could easily be 7-4 instead of 4-7.
6. Helf's buyout
7. In addition, the number of quality head coaches vs the number of jobs that will likely be available is scarce. There'll be openings at LSU, Texas, Purdue, possibly USC, possibly UCLA, possibly Florida State, if Jimbo Fisher jumps to LSU, Baylor, probably Texas Tech and more.
Looking at the potential available coaches, other than guys like Tom Hermann, Les Miles, the guy from Western Michigan, Charlie Strong, etc the Ducks may have stiff competition finding the "right" guy.
One concern I have about letting Helfrich go, and this is HUGE, is that Mark Helfrich is an "Oregon guy". He's already stated that the Oregon job is "the pinnacle" for him. I can't imagine any of those other coaches who couldn't be lured away by a more elite program, more money, etc.
Yes, Helf has made some questionable decisions and this season hasn't lived up to the expectations of the fans OR the team, but that doesn't necessarily mean that the grass will be greener if he's fired and someone else is brought in.
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 9:17 pm
by Everythingsducky
SuperDuck wrote:dthomas=ddixon wrote:I get the feeling that those in charge are looking for an excuse to bring him back. I doubt he'll be let go at this point.
I think so too. There are several problems with firing Helfrich.
1. The Don Pellum hire that he was supposedly forced into and the whiffs on recruiting that resulted in it.
2. The new Coordinators on both sides of the ball. Both of them should improve next year and afterward.
3. The youth across the board on both sides of the ball. The two-deep is loaded with freshman, redshirt freshman and sophomores.
4. Injuries, suspensions and dismissals, particularly on the front-7 of the defense where we only had six starters returning in the first place.
5. The 3 close losses against Nebraska, Colorado and Cal. We could easily be 7-4 instead of 4-7.
6. Helf's buyout
7. In addition, the number of quality head coaches vs the number of jobs that will likely be available is scarce. There'll be openings at LSU, Texas, Purdue, possibly USC, possibly UCLA, possibly Florida State, if Jimbo Fisher jumps to LSU, Baylor, probably Texas Tech and more.
Looking at the potential available coaches, other than guys like Tom Hermann, Les Miles, the guy from Western Michigan, Charlie Strong, etc the Ducks may have stiff competition finding the "right" guy.
One concern I have about letting Helfrich go, and this is HUGE, is that Mark Helfrich is an "Oregon guy". He's already stated that the Oregon job is "the pinnacle" for him. I can't imagine any of those other coaches who couldn't be lured away by a more elite program, more money, etc.
Yes, Helf has made some questionable decisions and this season hasn't lived up to the expectations of the fans OR the team, but that doesn't necessarily mean that the grass will be greener if he's fired and someone else is brought in.
Apologist...JK...kinda.
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 10:43 pm
by lukeyrid13
He has now coached 52 games. In my mind, one game shouldn't sway your opinion on him either way. Instead, one should take a glimpse at he overall picture of helf as a head coach and for me personally I would have already and still be looking into replacement options.
I love the win today but I hope that mullens and the powers that be wouldn't be so hasty and flippant in letting a singular game drastically impact such a huge decision.
Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?
Posted: Sat Nov 19, 2016 11:40 pm
by pezsez1
Instead, one should take a glimpse at he overall picture of helf
This is so hard to do with Helfrich. No other coach in Oregon's FB program history has had to overcome such massive transitions, including following behind a once-in-a-generation coach (made possibly by the moment as much as the man) and also the loss of a Heisman QB. Throw in sanctions from the previous coach, recruiting whiffs, coordinator changes and this year's unfortunate rash of injuries, and you have... well, three winning seasons and a losing season. Not all bad.
I recently hopped on the "Fire Helf" bandwagon because of how we got embarrassed at home against Stanford. We just seemed to look too discombobulated to have decent coaching, and after awhile the excuses of youth/injuries/new schemes start getting old. But then we win a game like this, which proves the coaches have control and the players haven't quit, and suddenly it seems injuries/youth might really be a big part of the problem.
As I said above, I'm glad I'm not the one getting paid big bucks to make this decision, and I trust that those who do have far more information than we do. If Helfrich stays, then he'll deserve another chance. If he's fired, then he'll deserve that too. We just don't know.
Hell of a game today, though. Helfrich and his staff must be doing something right. Is it enough? We'll find out soon, I'm sure.