Page 1 of 1
Recruiting for the next two years
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 10:21 am
by Alan
I thought this was a good discussion and needed it's own thread. Helf and the coaches are all out recruiting now with things hanging in the air. My opinion is Mullens is obviously shopping for coaches, but won't settle for less than great. If they planned on keeping Helf and not shop around he would have had the vote of confidence a couple of weeks ago..... JMO.
With that said this will take a hit on recruiting and Mullens is to blame, Helf and staff are sitting in front of recruits and parents and can only say they hope things will be okay..... not good. Helf gets another year, recruits and parents know how hot his seat is and can only wonder if they are signing with a program were they may face a new coaching staff in a year and can expect a down year or two. I would think a recruit would rather play for a Utah, Washington, Colorado...he'll even a Washington St were they can get some wins and have a good chance at being coached by the same guys for their time at the school.
Helf made plenty of coaching errors and was handicapped plenty by youth, injuries and new coordinators. But Mullens just set the program back at least a year or two.
Re: Recruiting for the next two years
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 10:34 am
by duckfan22
Alan wrote:I thought this was a good discussion and needed it's own thread. Helf and the coaches are all out recruiting now with things hanging in the air. My opinion is Mullens is obviously shopping for coaches, but won't settle for less than great. If they planned on keeping Helf and not shop around he would have had the vote of confidence a couple of weeks ago..... JMO.
With that said this will take a hit on recruiting and Mullens is to blame, Helf and staff are sitting in front of recruits and parents and can only say they hope things will be okay..... not good. Helf gets another year, recruits and parents know how hot his seat is and can only wonder if they are signing with a program were they may face a new coaching staff in a year and can expect a down year or two. I would think a recruit would rather play for a Utah, Washington, Colorado...he'll even a Washington St were they can get some wins and have a good chance at being coached by the same guys for their time at the school.
Helf made plenty of coaching errors and was handicapped plenty by youth, injuries and new coordinators. But Mullens just set the program back at least a year or two.
I agree to a point..Coaching college athletics is money driven. How many seats are filled in the stands.. Nothing is a given in this
day and age.What happens if Alabama or Ohio State has a couple of down years back to back, 9-4 and then 4-8 their boosters would
be up in arms and wanting the next big coaching star. But keeping Helfrich wondering is crap. Does not help in Recruiting. If Helfrich stays
what do they do with Hoke.. would it be good to have another new DC ? Hoke im not sure is the answer but you need some continuity in
the coaches. Its a interesting time with Oregon.. Can the ship be brought back up or will they sink more ?
Re: Recruiting for the next two years
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 10:49 am
by Alan
duckfan22 wrote:Alan wrote:I thought this was a good discussion and needed it's own thread. Helf and the coaches are all out recruiting now with things hanging in the air. My opinion is Mullens is obviously shopping for coaches, but won't settle for less than great. If they planned on keeping Helf and not shop around he would have had the vote of confidence a couple of weeks ago..... JMO.
With that said this will take a hit on recruiting and Mullens is to blame, Helf and staff are sitting in front of recruits and parents and can only say they hope things will be okay..... not good. Helf gets another year, recruits and parents know how hot his seat is and can only wonder if they are signing with a program were they may face a new coaching staff in a year and can expect a down year or two. I would think a recruit would rather play for a Utah, Washington, Colorado...he'll even a Washington St were they can get some wins and have a good chance at being coached by the same guys for their time at the school.
Helf made plenty of coaching errors and was handicapped plenty by youth, injuries and new coordinators. But Mullens just set the program back at least a year or two.
I agree to a point..Coaching college athletics is money driven. How many seats are filled in the stands.. Nothing is a given in this
day and age.What happens if Alabama or Ohio State has a couple of down years back to back, 9-4 and then 4-8 their boosters would
be up in arms and wanting the next big coaching star. But keeping Helfrich wondering is crap. Does not help in Recruiting. If Helfrich stays
what do they do with Hoke.. would it be good to have another new DC ? Hoke im not sure is the answer but you need some continuity in
the coaches. Its a interesting time with Oregon.. Can the ship be brought back up or will they sink more ?
I think the way Mullens handled it he basically punched a hole in the ship. My opinion and it's looking back on things after the fact, he should have either fired or giving Helf his support before the Utah game. It would have at least helped steady the ship with either way. Mullens had a week before the game to meet with Helf and tell him what was going to happen. Leaving Helf and staff dangling in the wind seems like he's (Mullens) is trying to sink the ship..... i don't think he's trying but in my eyes it's a far bigger mistake than Helf ever made during a game.
Re: Recruiting for the next two years
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 10:56 am
by dthomas=ddixon
We don't know what's going on behind the scenes but it does seem as though Mullens is dragging his feet. That perception could be completely wrong though as we really have no insight to what's actually happening.
Let's be real though, the only person actually responsible for this is Helfrich. He's responsible for the worst season in 25 years and two poor DC hires, as well as a drop off in recruiting. Mullens may not be helping (we don't know this for sure) but he is not the one setting the program back.
Re: Recruiting for the next two years
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 11:05 am
by Alan
dthomas=ddixon wrote:We don't know what's going on behind the scenes but it does seem as though Mullens is dragging his feet. That perception could be completely wrong though as we really have no insight to what's actually happening.
Let's be real though, the only person actually responsible for this is Helfrich. He's responsible for the worst season in 25 years and two poor DC hires, as well as a drop off in recruiting. Mullens may not be helping (we don't know this for sure) but he is not the one setting the program back.
I agree to a point, to stay with the analogy, Helf certainly put the ship in very rough waters. But Mullens is risking sinking the ship.
Re: Recruiting for the next two years
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 11:20 am
by StevensTechU
I think assessing how well Mullens has handled the situation at this juncture is premature. First data point doesn't appear until February (high school recruits' signing day), and the most important data points are the 2017 and 2018 seasons.
Re: Recruiting for the next two years
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 11:23 am
by dthomas=ddixon
Alan wrote:dthomas=ddixon wrote:We don't know what's going on behind the scenes but it does seem as though Mullens is dragging his feet. That perception could be completely wrong though as we really have no insight to what's actually happening.
Let's be real though, the only person actually responsible for this is Helfrich. He's responsible for the worst season in 25 years and two poor DC hires, as well as a drop off in recruiting. Mullens may not be helping (we don't know this for sure) but he is not the one setting the program back.
I agree to a point, to stay with the analogy, Helf certainly put the ship in very rough waters. But Mullens is risking sinking the ship.
That's fair.
I think we have to emphasize the fact that we don't actually know what Mullens has or hasn't done though. It certainly looks like a decision hasn't been made but it very well could a done deal and Mullens is doing this to keep it from looking that way. Minimizing the time between firing and hiring is ideal. If they're using this time to hire a coach and can announce a hire soon after the firing then it will end up being handled quite well, IMO.
Re: Recruiting for the next two years
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 12:11 pm
by GoDucksIn09
I don't buy the fact that Helfrich does not know. I am sure Mullens has talked with him prior to Oregon State. Mullens has obligations and commitments that Helfrich am sure was well aware of. I am not saying Mullens is a saint. I am just saying there is a lot of unknowns when it comes to just how much is known between Mullens and Helfrich. If Mullens has clearly left Helfrich in the dark then I think the handling of this is crap. Right now all we have is wild speculation. We only are making assessments on what we see. Mullens has obligations and commitments that he must fulfill. He can't be there to hold Helfrich's hand all the time. Maybe are things Mullens could have done better... but is so much we do not know to assume he is trying to sink the ship is premature and based on very little facts.
Re: Recruiting for the next two years
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 12:46 pm
by maxduck
It is a short list of elite coaches that are worth a $20+ million expenditure. Most of them aren't coming to Eugene. If you can hire an exceptional replacement you pull the trigger but to spend that amount of money to replace a Jeff Tedford type with a Sonny Dykes type would be lunacy.
Re: Recruiting for the next two years
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 12:47 pm
by rockthief
Consider two kinds of recruits: 1. won't go to Oregon because of the current travails. 2. will gladly go to Oregon because his chance to play and influence the game are high.
Give me #2, a guy who really wants to play, a guy who has energy and zest. Go Ducks!