Page 1 of 2
Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 11:17 am
by Alan
I feel Hoke is taking to much heat for this season and yes I know how bad the defense was.
Hoke was here basically 8 months before the season started, all he had was the mess DP had made for the past two seasons. None of the sophomores or older were his recruits, He was stuck with what DP had recruited. The Ducks knew when they hired him he was going to a 4-3 and none of the players were use to that system.
So basically none of the players were recruited for a 4-3, Hoke hasn't had many of his recruits play yet. Also I really not trying to defend Helf, but I don't think Helf had a whole lot of say in hiring DP or Hoke, he probably had some but maybe not enough..... I'm not sure he would have hired DP if he had more say. DP destroyed the defense not Hoke, Hoke was just left with the mess to try to clean up and about six or eight months to do it in. Part of the reason early on I was hoping for Helf to get another year.....but as of today I don't think it matters unless the Ducks can land a top five or six coach.
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 11:19 am
by StevensTechU
As much as we can heap on him.
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 11:25 am
by Alan
StevensTechU wrote:As much as we can heap on him.
?
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 11:28 am
by StevensTechU
Alan wrote:
?
The poor performance of the team is a combination of an issue that existed prior to Hoke's arrival and a bad series of injuries. That said, there has never been any indication that Hoke has made the situation better than it would've otherwise been without him. Zero.
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 11:40 am
by karlhungis
StevensTechU wrote:Alan wrote:
?
The poor performance of the team is a combination of an issue that existed prior to Hoke's arrival and a bad series of injuries. That said, there has never been any indication that Hoke has made the situation better than it would've otherwise been without him. Zero.
I don't really recall any times where you could see Hoke coaching up the players on the sideline. He really seemed like a spectator more than anything.
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 11:44 am
by Alan
Hindsight is a bad way to defend a point, but in hindsight...... I was one who wanted to go to a 4-3 a year ago, I still think a 4-3 can work. The Ducks went out and got a big name coach as DC who had zero experience as a DC (.i don't think that's all on Helf). I saw some improvement with the D in the last few games. For others here, I said some improvement not that they played well. Hoke was put in charge with a defense that was already under water, my thoughts are it will take more than 11 months to make it a respectable good defense again.
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 12:01 pm
by GoDucksIn09
I have been on the fence all year with Hoke. He had a lot of injuries... very young players... and very few players he actually had any say in recruiting. The cabinet that Pellum left him was empty. I am not an analyst or a coach so can not evaluate the job Hoke has done since getting here. I will say that so far recruiting this year on the defensive side I am not overly impressed. I guess at the end of the day am still hoping Helfrich gets fired and whoever replaces him if they want Hoke gone then I am fine with it. If they want him to stay then am trusting their judgement of his job that he has done.
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 12:22 pm
by Duck07
Substantial
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 12:27 pm
by pezsez1
I have been on the fence all year with Hoke. He had a lot of injuries... very young players... and very few players he actually had any say in recruiting. The cabinet that Pellum left him was empty. I am not an analyst or a coach so can not evaluate the job Hoke has done since getting here. I will say that so far recruiting this year on the defensive side I am not overly impressed. I guess at the end of the day am still hoping Helfrich gets fired and whoever replaces him if they want Hoke gone then I am fine with it. If they want him to stay then am trusting their judgement of his job that he has done.
Pretty much where I stand, too.
I place much more blame on Helfrich than I do on Hoke. He's a first-year addition to this staff who brought in an entirely new scheme without much talent in the cupboard. And we knew our defense would be thin before the season even started. Heck, Hoke had to scramble to catch up in recruiting just to get the bare-bones personnel needed to implement his scheme.
One of the biggest complaints I hear is that we shouldn't have gone to the 4-3 if we didn't have the personnel to do it, and I get that. But let's be honest -- we didn't really have the personnel to run much of anything, lol. Otherwise, our defense would have been better one of the past two seasons. On the defensive side of the ball, this was as good of a year as any to rebuild for a new scheme. Helfrich wanted to make the change. Hoke was hired to implement that change with the resources he had available. He can't be blamed too much for struggling with those resources; only a handful of players on that side of the ball are players he recruited.
Also, as a fan base, I think we should be extremely careful about adopting a "one strike, you're out" mob mentality when evaluating coaches. That's neither fair nor practical.
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 12:44 pm
by rockthief
Hoke made the best lemonade he could with the ingredients on hand. We need way more sugar though.
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 12:53 pm
by maxduck
After 5 months of practice the D doesn't know where they should be on the field, what their responsibilities are, or how to tackle. You could argue "wrong personnel" if players were in position but getting run over. That doesn't appear to be the case.
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 12:58 pm
by buckmarkduck
rockthief wrote:Hoke made the best lemonade he could with the ingredients on hand. We need way more sugar though.
Talent wise, this D had as much of more talent that the 94 bunch. They just couldn't do basic stuff, and that's coaching.
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 12:59 pm
by pezsez1
I feel like our D definitely improved regarding tackling/assignments as the year went on. Yeah, they missed some key tackles against OSU (or just got flat-out carried by Nall), but they don't look nearly as lost on a regular basis. I can see progress.
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 1:04 pm
by buckmarkduck
pezsez1 wrote:I feel like our D definitely improved regarding tackling/assignments as the year went on. Yeah, they missed some key tackles against OSU (or just got flat-out carried by Nall), but they don't look nearly as lost on a regular basis. I can see progress.
It probably didn't help that our starting DT for lost the year, was using meth.
Re: Hoke, how much blame does he deserve?
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2016 2:45 pm
by squintsdd
pezsez1 wrote:I feel like our D definitely improved regarding tackling/assignments as the year went on. Yeah, they missed some key tackles against OSU (or just got flat-out carried by Nall), but they don't look nearly as lost on a regular basis. I can see progress.
The Oregon D made 0 improvements this year, with the exception of maybe more passes defended. Teams ran at will against the defense, and it was no secret what they were going to do.
The fact that the Oregon defense continued to allow over 5ypc after the Arizona State game tells me that the tackling was no better, the reads were no better, and gap assignment was no better than at the start of the season. Even the Utah game that Oregon won, the defense allowed 5.9ypc. It took an Herbert playing out of his mind to win that game.
Hoke needs to go