Page 1 of 1

Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 6:44 am
by StevensTechU
I was talking football with a friend last night, and he asked me who the best coaches in football are. My answer probably looks a lot like other people's (Urban Meyer, Nick Saban, Jim Harbaugh, etc.). It turned interesting when I said to him "Urban Meyer's success at Florida and Ohio State is obviously greater than the success Bill Snyder has had at Kansas State, but I would listen to an argument that Snyder is the better coach because of what he's achieved with less."

I think there are coaches who are great coaches, and there are coaches who have built themselves into a 'brand,' if you will. Saban, Harbaugh, Meyer are all brands. Bill Snyder, Gary Patterson, Chris Petersen -- they aren't brands, but they're damn good football coaches.

It would be great and all if Oregon went out and got a guy who has an aura about him that we can all rally around, but frankly, I'm going to be more than happy if Oregon just gets a damn good football coach. The 'Oregon brand' is good enough for me. Give me a no-name guy who gets the job done on the field and I'll be happy.

Re: Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 7:06 am
by StevensTechU
As it relates to Oregon, here are some non-sexy hires who are damn good football coaches:

Mike Macintyre - Turned trash into champions at both SJSU and Colorado
Phillip Montgomery - Inherited a 2-10 Tulsa team that has arguably the worst recruiting base in the AAC, immediately improved to 6-7 and has them 9-3 in his second season.
Dave Clawson - Turned trash into champions 3 different times (Fordham, Richmond, Bowling Green), and has Wake Forest (hardest job in the ACC) turning around right now.
Kyle Whittingham - Utah shouldn't compete with USC and UCLA every year. Yet every year they do. Give him Oregon's resources, and I'm very intrigued what would happen.
Dino Babers - Similar to Montgomery, there's a little projection here as he's in his first year at Syracuse, but he did phenomenal jobs at Eastern Illinois and Bowling Green. Babers' offense is one of the best in football, so a pairing of him and a good DC could make Oregon look like Chip's Oregon.

Re: Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 7:36 am
by Alan
Sure feels like,a loaded question, I don't think there is a correct answer. Urban is an elite coach who will get he Ohio St team in the playoffs,this,year, without winning his conference, but that's another thread. Snyder is a great coach who took little and made,it,into something good, not great but,good, much like what's happened at Washington St the last few,years. How do you talk kids from big cities to go to the wheat fields of Pullman Wa, yet he does and wins.

Re: Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 7:42 am
by StevensTechU
Alan wrote:Sure feels like,a loaded question, I don't think there is a correct answer.
The easy questions are boring and not worth talking about :lol:

Re: Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 7:50 am
by Alan
StevensTechU wrote:
Alan wrote:Sure feels like,a loaded question, I don't think there is a correct answer.
The easy questions are boring and not worth talking about :lol:
Very true!

Re: Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 8:40 am
by GoDucksIn09
It would be interesting to put Snyder at a traditional powerhouse and see if he could recruit and win there. I think it is really tough to answer because of that. With Meyer he left Utah for Florida and then quit for a year before going to Ohio State. Is a lot easier to recruit to Florida or Ohio State than Kansas State. I know Snyder has no desire to coach at a big name school. If he did and could see what he could do with the 4 and 5 star kids then could make a projection as to who is better. Otherwise it is like comparing apples to oranges.

Re: Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 8:54 am
by bdkipe
That is a great question and a great topic STU.

I would be perfectly fine with finding the football version of Altman. IE, not the sexiest-name-hire, but one of the best, most organized teachers of the game in the country, an underrated recruiter and able to make the talent play above it's level.

Ultimately I think that is what undid Helfrich. Talent never reached it's ceiling, while under Brooks, Bellotti and Chip the players exceeded expectations.

I remember Colin saying something about that back in the very early 2000's when he was still here at The FAN. He was talking about Oregon's success with the Joey teams of 99-01 and how they succeeded in spite of their lack of traditional "studs" in recruiting. Obviously, this was before Rivals, Scout, etc. blew up all over that world wide interweb thingy. Recruiting rankings were based on Parade and a bunch of fledgling newsletters and shady chat rooms. I digress...anyway, the point is that the NFL told Colin when it came to the mid-lower rounds, they would always be happy to take an Oregon guy because they were so "coached up" and "well-taught", a team "knew what they were getting". They didn't have to waste the all important, roster-filling draft picks on boom or bust projects, they could just take Ducks and know they knew the game.

Re: Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 8:57 am
by lmduck
Good post ST. Nice to see some thought provoking discussion.

Re: Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 9:04 am
by Duck24
Urban Meyer also had unparalleled success at Bowling Green and Utah so it's not like he only succeeds at schools with a natural following/recruiting base.

I think Snyder has flourished at Kansas State because they never have expectations. He takes the guys nobody wanted, turns into their father figures and finds a way to get the most out of them by leveraging that relationship. I don't know how he would do if he got guys who came with the entitlement that is so pervasive amongst elite recruits. Snyder is a damn good coach and there is no denying that. He built KSU from the ground up twice. They are decent to good every year with a few outliers every 5 years or so when they end up competing for a BIG 12 championship and playing in a BCS/New Years 6 type game.

Re: Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 10:51 am
by fpsduck
Urban Meyer

Re: Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 11:22 am
by StevensTechU
Duck24 wrote:Urban Meyer also had unparalleled success at Bowling Green.
Dave Clawson, Dino Babers both were more successful at Bowling Green.

Re: Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 11:40 am
by Duck24
Biggus Duckus wrote:If I wanted a coach for the long-term it would be Bill Snyder. If I was Phil Knight and wanted to see a championship before I die it would be Urban Meyer.
Bill Snyder is one year younger than Uncle Phil. Crazy to think about.

Re: Who is a better coach: Urban Meyer or Bill Snyder?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 11:48 am
by UOducksTK1
Duck24 wrote:Urban Meyer also had unparalleled success at Bowling Green and Utah so it's not like he only succeeds at schools with a natural following/recruiting base.

I think Snyder has flourished at Kansas State because they never have expectations. He takes the guys nobody wanted, turns into their father figures and finds a way to get the most out of them by leveraging that relationship. I don't know how he would do if he got guys who came with the entitlement that is so pervasive amongst elite recruits. Snyder is a damn good coach and there is no denying that. He built KSU from the ground up twice. They are decent to good every year with a few outliers every 5 years or so when they end up competing for a BIG 12 championship and playing in a BCS/New Years 6 type game.
Ding ding. Most (if not all) big name coaches had success at smaller schools in order to get to where they are. Not to undermine what Snyder has done, but Meyer can win anywhere.