Page 1 of 1

Is it time to dump the spread?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 7:18 am
by QuackininBama
More specifically, is it time to just let the new coach institute his own gameplan and not try to force him to be the next Chip Kelly (assuming Chip doesn't return, which I actually think he will). One thing we can all agree on, I believe, is Helf was FORCED to just continue with Chips gameplans rather than let Helf decide the style of gameplay. Are we going to do it again with whomever we hire? "Welcome to Oregon, by the way, we run the hurry up no huddle spread offense and you will to".

Considering everyone has caught onto how to defend it now I would be all for just letting the new coach dictate his teams own style of play.

Re: Is it time to dump the spread?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 11:45 am
by UOducksTK1
I feel like all season we never really reached the spread's potential. There was no zone read option. There were so few WR screen passes. There was little creativity. Just spreading out and running a play IMO doesn't really mean much. We underutilized our offensive talent in over half the games because IMO we didn't have a competent enough coach.

Re: Is it time to dump the spread?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 11:47 am
by greenyellow
QuackininBama wrote:More specifically, is it time to just let the new coach institute his own gameplan and not try to force him to be the next Chip Kelly (assuming Chip doesn't return, which I actually think he will). One thing we can all agree on, I believe, is Helf was FORCED to just continue with Chips gameplans rather than let Helf decide the style of gameplay. Are we going to do it again with whomever we hire? "Welcome to Oregon, by the way, we run the hurry up no huddle spread offense and you will to".

Considering everyone has caught onto how to defend it now I would be all for just letting the new coach dictate his teams own style of play.
But what you're suggesting is that Oregon basically go to a pro-style offense, which wouldn't work because that is an offense that's hard to recruit to now, especially with most HS programs having gone to some version of the spread.

Re: Is it time to dump the spread?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 11:48 am
by duckfan22
I would love to see the spread stay but also have some version of a power game with it.
Oregon just isnt tough enough when teams get physical on either side of the ball.

Re: Is it time to dump the spread?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 11:59 am
by pezsez1
I would love to see the spread stay but also have some version of a power game with it.
Actually, I believe this was Helf's vision for how the spread would operate... stretch the defense with a strong vertical passing game, then plow the rock through the middle for chunks of yards on the ground.

Gotta admit, Helf's offenses were dynamite when we had a QB who could hit the deep ball. Mariota benefited from a more seasoned (though often injured) offensive line, and VA made his own opportunities with his insane scrambling abilities. Herbert has the arm, but he didn't have the OL, the scrambling ability or the experience.

Paired with that strong vertical passing game, our RBs under Helf thrived.... and they did so in a way that was different than when Chip was here -- much more north/south running, less stretching defensive east and west.

Things only fell apart this year without a QB/OL able to really work the deep ball.

All that said...

I don't think we should give up on the spread. And while Helf's offense was EPIC when it worked, he (and his staff) seemed reluctant to adjust when the deep ball wasn't a reliable part of the arsenal. It blows my mind that we didn't see more of the misdirection that can be so powerful when your greatest asset is speed. Maybe that was a result of Herbert not knowing enough of the playbook, or maybe it was a result of the OL's inexperience, or maybe injuries to Royce and Taj.... who knows.

Bottom line, we can't have our offense live and die on the deep ball... that's not a sustainable game plan. That's like any NBA team other than the Warriors living and dying on the 3.

If we're going to run the spread, we need to get back to "destroying with speed." That's when the spread is at its best.

Re: Is it time to dump the spread?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 12:07 pm
by Duck07
It became obvious to me that we moved from a running team to a passing team the last three years. Sure, Marcus was a reason but I feel the comments about not being pro ready in this offense were taken to heart by Helfrich to employ more pro passing concepts. Helfs hands are all over this team and sadly not for the better.

Re: Is it time to dump the spread?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 12:28 pm
by rsbgduck
To seriously change the offense you're looking at 3 years 2 if they recruit very well for it. I don't think any coach they bring in will be handed that kind of time by the AD, school or fans. Add to that this year you would be hard pressed to change the recruiting direction for players who fit a particular offense. So the new coach could come in and implement his offense with the players he has and risk losing at the same time taking up a year and starting the rumors of the hot seat. I honestly feel they already have the guy they want and that would be IMO Chip or PJ. I'm not in the group wanting Chip back basically because I didn't think it had a chance but with how Mullins handled the firing of Helfrich I think it is a real possibility and would love to have him back. PJ because everything is in place as far as players go and probably wouldn't need a lot of coaching changess offensively.. Defensively it's a pure guessing game, if Chip comes back he brings his DC with him and probably see Brady go to DL coach and the guy we demoted last year and the rest of the D staff replaced. If it's PJ then I could see them keeping Brady Hoke but a dig change with all the D coaches. All of course IMHO and the scenarios I would like to see happen.

Re: Is it time to dump the spread?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 2:17 pm
by fpsduck
I'm fine with whatever offense our next HC/OC wants to run...just be efficient/effective.

Re: Is it time to dump the spread?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 2:29 pm
by pdxmallard
Hell no. Anyone know any other teams that started four freshman on the OL and had any kind of success? The last time I looked, Oregon was #19 in total offense, with a true freshman QB, four freshman on the OL, and a senior with an appetite for penalties. Offense coaching wasn't the problem this year, and neither was the spread. Many Duck fans, and some on this board, thought the media was hallucinating by projecting Washington to win the conference and Oregon finishing in the middle of the PAC, at best. Considering injuries (which you CAN do), Oregon wasn't THAT far off the projection. Any finger-pointing should consider the unrealistic expectations of the fans, the heavy toll of injuries, and the performance of a first-time DC with a new scheme. The spread offense is still fine, which is why so many use it. The only problem with the spread is it requires execution, and a functional defense.

Re: Is it time to dump the spread?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 5:15 pm
by BTJ201
I think it's simple, we go to the offense that the new coach brings and is most efficient at coaching.

Re: Is it time to dump the spread?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 5:39 pm
by pezsez1
I think it's simple, we go to the offense that the new coach brings and is most efficient at coaching.
Keep in mind that's what Brady Hoke attempted, and it didn't work out so well. Hopefully though Mullens hires a coach who can optimize the kinds of players we have.

Re: Is it time to dump the spread?

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 5:53 pm
by buckmarkduck
I'd hate to lose the spread, but I'd love a coach who's innovative enough to evolve beyond what we've seen everyone else copy.