Page 1 of 2
Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Thu Dec 29, 2016 6:12 pm
by OregonFan4Life
Instead of Helf? Where would we be now? I know Aliotti retired and all, but he made it clear he wanted to be coach. How would the team have done these last four years if Aliotti was coach and Helf stayed as OC? Just thought I'd throw out this question since it's been slow lately.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Thu Dec 29, 2016 6:16 pm
by UofDuck
Marginally better
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 9:51 am
by StevensTechU
I was thinking about this last night, actually, so it's funny you bring it up.
I think the team would look a lot like Muschamp's Florida teams. Play hard, but not especially smart or creative. In college football, you're either ahead of the curve or behind it, and I don't see Aliotti doing anything to stay ahead of it. Would the team still have played for a national championship? Maybe, maybe not. Would they have gone 4-8 this year? Quite possible, but maybe they're 6-6 or 7-5, but is that really all that better.
Aliotti would've been a terrible hire, in my opinion. Just doesn't have the capacity to be a head man.
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 10:19 am
by Alan
While I liked Aliotti I agree not HC material. Nick let his mouth get him in trouble a little too often, could get pretty emotional which works on the sideline but not in front of the camera.
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 10:31 am
by duckfan96
Would probably have done the same as helfrich. Fans reaction the same too..1/2 way thru his first quarter as coach people would be dying he sucked, needed to be fired, worst coach ever etc etc. I wonder if people are going to treat taggart the same as they did helfrich? Only success was cause of someone else, all failures his fault.
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 1:40 pm
by pezsez1
Loved NA as a DC and a coach, and I think he could have led Oregon to big things. That said, I now feel like we needed a coaching reset to connect better with today's recruits. NA was old school.
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 1:49 pm
by chapelhillduck
This board hated Aliotti...just a reminder
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 2:10 pm
by pezsez1
Not me! Loved his fire and attacking mentality. But yeah, many here couldn't stand when we'd bend but not break, all other metrics outside total yardage be damned.
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 2:39 pm
by buckmarkduck
pezsez1 wrote:Loved NA as a DC and a coach, and I think he could have led Oregon to big things. That said, I now feel like we needed a coaching reset to connect better with today's recruits. NA was old school.
No he wouldn't have, or Bellotti and Kelly would have tagged him as HC.
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2016 1:05 am
by pezsez1
No he wouldn't have, or Bellotti and Kelly would have tagged him as HC.
Oregon's brand was offense, not defense. Bellotti wasn't going to tap a defensive guru when he had an obvious offensive-minded star-in-waiting under his wing, and Chip's ego was too big to lobby for anyone but his right-hand-man. Besides, Phil Knight wanted continuity, making Helf the obvious choice for replacing Chip.
In no way, shape or form did these decisions indicate the results NA would have had. We'll never know. Guarantee though his program would have been run different than either Chip's or Helfrich's. NA marched to the beat of a different drum.
EDIT: One more thought, NA was ready to retire when Chip left and only stayed another year because Helf talked him into it. So the very notion of him being promoted at that point is flawed.
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2016 1:46 am
by Phenom
I don't know about that. Many people believe that Helf pushed Aliotti out.
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2016 8:51 am
by buckmarkduck
Not true at all. A few things, NA always wanted to be the HC forever. It was between he and Bellotti in 1995, he didn't get it and got mad and left for the NFL. Finally after failing in St Louis and then failing at UCLA, MB being a real friend gave him his old job back. Side note Tedford and NA really disliked each other.
Over the years NA tried and tried to get a HC job, he was even passed up for 1-AA jobs. He has also said, even when he retired, he would only come back to be a HC. If all these schools passed on him, what makes anyone think he would have been a good HC for the ducks?
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2016 8:55 am
by pezsez1
NA was a solid recruiter, a motivational personality and a great game planner. Good chance he would have been a great HC. For all the reasons I already stated, though, it just wasn't going to happen at Oregon with its tradition of promoting offensive-minded coaches from within. He didnt fit the brand. None of that is a slight on NA. If he was hated on that much internally, he would have left long ago.
Crazy how much our D fell apart after NA retired, and STILL folks look for reasons to say he couldn't coach.
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2016 11:33 am
by buckmarkduck
So you're trying to convince me that in 1995, after having a defensive HC for 18 years, UO tradition was hiring offensive coaches? A big problem I have with Nick is how he handled that entire process, he got mad and took his ball and left.
Re: Hypothetical: What if Aliotti was promoted?
Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2016 12:11 pm
by SuperDuck
buckmarkduck wrote:So you're trying to convince me that in 1995, after having a defensive HC for 18 years, UO tradition was hiring offensive coaches? A big problem I have with Nick is how he handled that entire process, he got mad and took his ball and left.
But he left with Rich Brooks to be on his staff in St. Louis, right? So rather than looking at it like that, he may have just thought "okay, this didn't pan out, so I'll go with Coach Brooks, get some NFL experience and improve my resume".
Chip Kelly took a few guys with him when he left, too. It happens.
Just sayin'. I don't know anything for a fact.