Page 1 of 3
Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 5:29 pm
by DmoneyDuck
Apologies if this should be put in the game thread, but I thought this is an interesting subject to keep an eye on over the course of the Willie Taggert era.
I have to say that I'm not feeling super stoked after eeking out a home victory over a Nebraska team that we had dead to rights at halftime. Give Nebraska credit for fighting back to start the 3rd, but when the game got tight, so did the play calling. Herbert was 25-33 for 365 yards, 3 TDs and made only only bad decision all game on the interception. Yet, as we hung on to a 14-point 4th quarter lead, we took the ball completely out of his hands and become ultra-conservative. Run, run, run up the middle and then punt. We started milking the clock with over 10 minutes left in that game!
The coaches coached scared and not to lose. Had it not been for an opportunistic defense, we would have been the laughing stock of college football, essentially telling Texas A&M to "hold our beer" after their performance last week.
I grew up watching Oregon football in the mid-90s and am more than familiar with how conservative Mike Bellotti could be at times but this felt next level. My only hope is the coaches watch the film and learn from their mistakes but play-calling and being aggressive seem to be instincts and more of a state of mind than anything else. Are we in for more of this over the next few years? I sure hope not. I know we're all spoiled from Chip's uber-aggressive play calling, but there has to be a happy medium right? Too many times we punted on either 4th and inches or in Nebraska territory. Have some faith in your offense! They are pretty damn good.
Look, I know we're not winning the title or conference title this year. Our team is young and we made a lot of mistakes this afternoon, but we're also very talented and we need to let them play! 42 points in the first half? There's absolutely no reason to put the reigns on that type of production.
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 5:34 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
I'd be interested to know if this is ever a strategy he employed at USF or WKU. Nothing about his style said "conservative" before today.
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 5:43 pm
by DmoneyDuck
dthomas=ddixon wrote:I'd be interested to know if this is ever a strategy he employed at USF or WKU. Nothing about his style said "conservative" before today.
Agreed. Which is why it caught me by surprise this afternoon.
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 5:52 pm
by pezsez1
I felt like Mike Bellotti was calling the second-half plays!
I have no clue why he went so conservative, especially with an offense as good as ours. Just get first downs and score more points. The only time I advocate conservative playcalling is when there is mathematically not enough time for the other team to come back and win.
Teachable moments all around. Thank goodness our defense is vastly improved.
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 5:57 pm
by greenyellow
I hope that we never see that kind of conservative playcalling again unless it's some cupcake they're blowing out.
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 5:59 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
One thing to take solace in is the fact that it wasn't that we couldn't score. We simply chose not to try to score ha. I would be a lot more worried if we kept running all the same stuff as we did in the 1st half and were still shutout.
Like Pez said, this should be a teachable moment for WT and the staff, not a sign of something wrong with the offense.
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 6:01 pm
by weezle
After lurking here for a while, the second half of this game is what finally convinced me to register.
I'm not a big x's and o's guy, but this second half was obviously not well managed. I understand that when you have a large lead your goal is to run down the clock as much as you can to walk away with the win. Obviously running the ball consumes more clock than incomplete passes that stop the clock. But I'm pretty certain that getting 1st downs uses more clock than does going 3 and out over and over. I can't figure out why the coaching staff took the ball out of Herbert's hot hand? He must have had a >80% completion rate in the first half. Even if he hits an incompletion here and there, the 1st downs will continue to roll in and maybe some points along with them. And if you absolutely insist on running the ball, why continue to run the same play up the gut over and over that the defense clearly has an answer for? We saw on the last drive that once we started running it to the outside we were much more successful. And why not go for the bubble screens that we had prior success with? I'm also annoyed at the conservative punt call on 4th and 1. Then the play calls on the 3rd and short and 4th and short were low percentage plays with the deep passes.
Sure we came out with the W, but if we were playing against a better team that likely would not have been the case. It's really frustrating to watch a team that has obvious talent be confined by the coaching decisions. I don't expect to have a perfect season, but we shouldn't be seeing what happened during that second half.
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 6:03 pm
by OregonFan4Life
Yeah I feel the exact same way. If Oregon lost, Willie would've been embarrassed. I'm curious to see the press conference and the questions he's asked. We had an opportunity to thrash this team and show the nation we're back. Instead we squeaked out a win thanks to the defense making bad plays and Lee not being a very good QB. Between the penalties, turnovers, and extremely conservative playcalling, that was a very ugly second half. Again, it worked out against Nebraska, would that work against USC or Washington? Heck no! I'm glad we're 2-0, but I'm certainly concerned after this win and not sure what to expect from Willie. I'll say this again, if he coaches every game like he did in the second half, he won't have a long career here. I hope Willie learns just as much as the players do from this game.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 6:04 pm
by chapelhillduck
Any one of the following happens and the game is easily won:
1) Royce doesn't fumble
2) Breeland makes an easy catch
3) we recover Nebraska fumble
4) Springs makes a tackle on 4th and 10
5) Schneider hits FG
All that said, we still won
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 6:05 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
chapelhillduck wrote:Any one of the following happens and the game is easily won:
1) Royce doesn't fumble
2) Breeland makes an easy catch
3) we recover Nebraska fumble
4) Springs makes a tackle on 4th and 10
5) Schneider his FG
All that said, we still won
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I would add the stupid penalties that killed our drives and extended theirs.
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 6:06 pm
by OregonFan4Life
chapelhillduck wrote:Any one of the following happens and the game is easily won:
1) Royce doesn't fumble
2) Breeland makes an easy catch
3) we recover Nebraska fumble
4) Springs makes a tackle on 4th and 10
5) Schneider hits FG
All that said, we still won
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
There were absolutely moments the players could've won, but regardless, the conservative coaching was not a good move.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 6:12 pm
by GrandpaDuck
Repeatedly running straight up the middle when it hasn't worked all game and they know you're going to do it is stupid. Is doing something stupid being conservative?
I think we saw a combination of fear induced stupidity.
"Wee Balls Willy"
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 6:15 pm
by duckduckgoose
chapelhillduck wrote:Any one of the following happens and the game is easily won:
1) Royce doesn't fumble
2) Breeland makes an easy catch
3) we recover Nebraska fumble
4) Springs makes a tackle on 4th and 10
5) Schneider hits FG
All that said, we still won
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
We would have lost if this thing happened:
1) Nebraska’s running back had stayed healthy and in the game.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 6:16 pm
by GrantDuck
Agree that it reminded me of Bellotti and what frustrated me with him late in game sometimes.
The one that irks me the most was actually punting on 4th and 3 at midfield up 14-0 and with Nebraska on their heels. Nebraska went 95 yards for a score.
Statistically in that situation, you go for it. Urban Meyer goes for that, Dabo Swinney goes for that, etc.
Saban may punt, but he has one of the best defenses in history...
Then the play calling got super stale after Herbert's INT. Was either go deep on a one-on-one or run up the gut.
So, the first 2 "worries" I have are halftime adjustments, which are a big deal in coaching and getting too conservative. We'll see if it's a pattern.
Re: Coaching Conservatively
Posted: Sat Sep 09, 2017 7:30 pm
by buckmarkduck
I've seen rumors that Herbert had his hand wrapped in ice during the 4th qrt. Not excusing the 2 runs up the middle and a run around the side over and over, but that might be why they only threw 1 time in the 4 qrt and what 7 times in the half?