Page 1 of 1

Ducks Defense now 39th this year

Posted: Wed Nov 29, 2017 1:53 pm
by soduck
http://www.ncaa.com/stats/football/fbs/current/team/22, What an amazing job by Leavitt and staff. Next year will be even better.

Re: Ducks Defense now 39th this year

Posted: Wed Nov 29, 2017 2:35 pm
by duckduckgoose
soduck wrote:http://www.ncaa.com/stats/football/fbs/current/team/22, What an amazing job by Leavitt and staff. Next year will be even better.
Wyoming was 22nd on that list for what it’s worth.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Re: Ducks Defense now 39th this year

Posted: Wed Nov 29, 2017 2:44 pm
by UOducksTK1
duckduckgoose wrote:
soduck wrote:http://www.ncaa.com/stats/football/fbs/current/team/22, What an amazing job by Leavitt and staff. Next year will be even better.
Wyoming was 22nd on that list for what it’s worth.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Yeah, but who do they play?

Pretty incredible given our talent level at D to finish 39th.

Re: Ducks Defense now 39th this year

Posted: Wed Nov 29, 2017 2:59 pm
by GrandpaDuck
77th in scoring defense. As in "Scoreboard". Slightly below average but not horrid, 7th in the conference. Marked improvement, but they break too much. The great defenses have some bend in them.

Re: Ducks Defense now 39th this year

Posted: Wed Nov 29, 2017 3:30 pm
by dphi
GrandpaDuck wrote:77th in scoring defense. As in "Scoreboard". Slightly below average but not horrid, 7th in the conference. Marked improvement, but they break too much. The great defenses have some bend in them.
Tough to hold up when your offense is constantly going three and out or giving up turnovers as happened during the BB games.

Re: Ducks Defense now 39th this year

Posted: Wed Nov 29, 2017 3:58 pm
by pudgejeff
dphi wrote:
GrandpaDuck wrote:77th in scoring defense. As in "Scoreboard". Slightly below average but not horrid, 7th in the conference. Marked improvement, but they break too much. The great defenses have some bend in them.
Tough to hold up when your offense is constantly going three and out or giving up turnovers as happened during the BB games.
This. I care about the ranking during games Herbert played and while it was still a game during them.

Re: Ducks Defense now 39th this year

Posted: Wed Nov 29, 2017 4:35 pm
by GrandpaDuck
pudgejeff wrote:
dphi wrote:
GrandpaDuck wrote:77th in scoring defense. As in "Scoreboard". Slightly below average but not horrid, 7th in the conference. Marked improvement, but they break too much. The great defenses have some bend in them.
Tough to hold up when your offense is constantly going three and out or giving up turnovers as happened during the BB games.
This. I care about the ranking during games Herbert played and while it was still a game during them.

Well the problem with that is the games Herbert played were against the composite 70th ranked offenses, whereas BB played against teams whose average rank was 36th. It is true that there were almost a turnover a game more with BB, but those games were also against vastly superior offenses and defenses .

Anyway yes, against the poor offenses where JH played the defense gave up 24.6 points per game which would rank 49th nationally. Unless every team were allowed to throw out the results against the 4 toughest games on their schedule in which case it would probably rank in the 80s or below.

Re: Ducks Defense now 39th this year

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2017 10:22 am
by Greenblood
And the Ducks are #31 in ypp given up (112th last year), with only UW and WSU among Pac-12 schools finishing higher on that stat. And the site (http://www.footballoutsiders.com/stats/feidef) that goes deeper into overall defensive effectiveness has the Ducks at 45th and 58th, respectively, in their two sets of measures. Putting it all together, I'm comfortable saying the Ducks are a little above-average defensively this year, i.e., a HUGE improvement over last year.

I'm not so sure I agree with the suggestion, however, that the Ducks don't have much talent defensively. I think much of the great improvement we saw may have been because they were severely under-coached last year, along with some great coaching this year.

Re: Ducks Defense now 39th this year

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2017 10:37 am
by Phalanx
Greenblood wrote:And the Ducks are #31 in ypp given up (112th last year), with only UW and WSU among Pac-12 schools finishing higher on that stat. And the site (http://www.footballoutsiders.com/stats/feidef) that goes deeper into overall defensive effectiveness has the Ducks at 45th and 58th, respectively, in their two sets of measures. Putting it all together, I'm comfortable saying the Ducks are a little above-average defensively this year, i.e., a HUGE improvement over last year.

I'm not so sure I agree with the suggestion, however, that the Ducks don't have much talent defensively. I think much of the great improvement we saw may have been because they were severely under-coached last year, along with some great coaching this year.
Exactly. The idea that the defense was so awful because of bad recruiting is a myth. As soon as the A.D. paid the money to get a real defensive coordinator, the defense improved, which will likely also help get better recruits.

Re: Ducks Defense now 39th this year

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2017 11:18 am
by Duck07
Phalanx wrote:
Greenblood wrote:And the Ducks are #31 in ypp given up (112th last year), with only UW and WSU among Pac-12 schools finishing higher on that stat. And the site (http://www.footballoutsiders.com/stats/feidef) that goes deeper into overall defensive effectiveness has the Ducks at 45th and 58th, respectively, in their two sets of measures. Putting it all together, I'm comfortable saying the Ducks are a little above-average defensively this year, i.e., a HUGE improvement over last year.

I'm not so sure I agree with the suggestion, however, that the Ducks don't have much talent defensively. I think much of the great improvement we saw may have been because they were severely under-coached last year, along with some great coaching this year.
Exactly. The idea that the defense was so awful because of bad recruiting is a myth. As soon as the A.D. paid the money to get a real defensive coordinator, the defense improved, which will likely also help get better recruits.
But it's also not wrong to say that the defense still lacks talent. We've got a few guys who could play next level, but we don't have the depth right now and that was the biggest thing that was taken away during "that" period was the depth behind the starters. I view this season defensively as an example of being able to outsmart your opponent with the "X's and O's." In another year or two with this group we could talking about how we're blowing up offenses because of the "Jimmie's and Joe's."

Re: Ducks Defense now 39th this year

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2017 12:44 pm
by Phalanx
Duck07 wrote:
Phalanx wrote:
Exactly. The idea that the defense was so awful because of bad recruiting is a myth. As soon as the A.D. paid the money to get a real defensive coordinator, the defense improved, which will likely also help get better recruits.
But it's also not wrong to say that the defense still lacks talent. We've got a few guys who could play next level, but we don't have the depth right now and that was the biggest thing that was taken away during "that" period was the depth behind the starters. I view this season defensively as an example of being able to outsmart your opponent with the "X's and O's." In another year or two with this group we could talking about how we're blowing up offenses because of the "Jimmie's and Joe's."
While I agree there is room for improvement and depth (as is perpetually the case with Oregon defenses), the main point I was trying to make is that poor coaching on the defensive side was the cause of "that period" more than poor recruiting. The defense that performed fairly well this year was mostly recruited by 'those coaches', and yet somehow, they figured out how to tackle this year and didn't look like a Pop Warner team. I think Pellum and Hoke were poison for the ducks, and as soon as they opened the wallet and got a real DC, they showed marked improvement. It stands to reason that recruiting also improves once kids figure out that a real coach is at the helm on defense.

Someday, I would like to hear the inside story on why they made the awful decision to promote Pellum. Was that actually Helfrich's call, or the A.D.'s? Was Helfrich limited also by the amount of funds he could spend to candidates like Pellum and Hoke rather than being able to go after the Leavitt's of the world? People hate Helfrich now and blame him for everything under the sun, but I still mourn the fact that we lost a guy from Oregon who ran a great offense for years and who we would never have had to deal with the swirl of rumors and insecurity we have with Taggart. We may never know the truth for sure, but I suspect it could have worked out.

Re: Ducks Defense now 39th this year

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2017 2:36 pm
by lawduck
Phalanx wrote:
Duck07 wrote:
Phalanx wrote:
Exactly. The idea that the defense was so awful because of bad recruiting is a myth. As soon as the A.D. paid the money to get a real defensive coordinator, the defense improved, which will likely also help get better recruits.
But it's also not wrong to say that the defense still lacks talent. We've got a few guys who could play next level, but we don't have the depth right now and that was the biggest thing that was taken away during "that" period was the depth behind the starters. I view this season defensively as an example of being able to outsmart your opponent with the "X's and O's." In another year or two with this group we could talking about how we're blowing up offenses because of the "Jimmie's and Joe's."
While I agree there is room for improvement and depth (as is perpetually the case with Oregon defenses), the main point I was trying to make is that poor coaching on the defensive side was the cause of "that period" more than poor recruiting. The defense that performed fairly well this year was mostly recruited by 'those coaches', and yet somehow, they figured out how to tackle this year and didn't look like a Pop Warner team. I think Pellum and Hoke were poison for the ducks, and as soon as they opened the wallet and got a real DC, they showed marked improvement. It stands to reason that recruiting also improves once kids figure out that a real coach is at the helm on defense.

Someday, I would like to hear the inside story on why they made the awful decision to promote Pellum. Was that actually Helfrich's call, or the A.D.'s? Was Helfrich limited also by the amount of funds he could spend to candidates like Pellum and Hoke rather than being able to go after the Leavitt's of the world? People hate Helfrich now and blame him for everything under the sun, but I still mourn the fact that we lost a guy from Oregon who ran a great offense for years and who we would never have had to deal with the swirl of rumors and insecurity we have with Taggart. We may never know the truth for sure, but I suspect it could have worked out.
I agree. It wasn't even scheme as much as technique. So many of our defensive problems last year were directly related to poor tackling technique and, more importantly, poor alignment/gap responsibility. It is amazing how often the kids were filling the wrong gaps (or allowing themselves to be blocked into the wrong gaps). That is on the coaches.