Page 1 of 2
Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Mon Sep 03, 2018 9:08 pm
by GrantDuck
Took some notes on the re-watch.
QB; A-/B+; Maybe an unfair grade, the WR's dropped a lot of balls, but I'm almost grading Herbert on his own curve. Missed a couple throws and had 2 misreads in the option game. Burmeister didn't do much(1 good throw).
RB; c+; Have to do better than 5.0 ypc against that caliber of school. Very few broken tackles. Liked Habibi-Likio's TD run, but didn't see anything else fantastic other than Taj's speed. Think we'll have to wait until Sean Dollars is on campus again to have a top tier all around running back like we're used to.
WR; D; Rough day for the wideouts. Drops, bad routes leading to INT's, lack of separation....not good. Redd has a lot of potential, clearly. Hopefully we can get Addison up to speed with the playbook and Tabari Hines more involved.
OL; A-. Overall, pretty good game 1. Need more consistent push in the running game, but pass pro was good and Shane L. was absolutely mauling people. Thought they did a real nice job in the screen game.
DL: B+. Fat Mac was just a force in there WITH one hand btw!! 7 tackles from the DT spot is awesome. Thought Faoliu and Jelks also played well. carlberg looked good actually. The one drive where FatMac was getting his hand re-taped wasn't good. Gary Baker was the one bad spot. Got knocked off the ball a few times. Really need to stay healthy here and continue to develop the depth.
LB: B+ Troy Dye was a little hyper and out of position to start, then played awesome. Hollins was unblockable, he'll play on Sundays next year. Going to say this now SLADE NEEDS to be starting at MLB. Apelu gets mauled in the middle repeatedly and got beat on their first TD. Love our talent overall here. Exciting position group.
DB: A-. Solid game outside of #10 getting torched on a deep route. The minus is for the tackling on the first couple drives. Outside of that, they stayed away from Graham, and Lenoir before his concussion looked pretty good too. The freshman corners got some run and didn't look completely lost and tackled well.
Overall coaching: A-; Honestly liked the gameplan. Pretty vanilla, but good. Truly hope the screen game is a major part of the offense going forward. It's a great play in cfb if executed properly. Loved going for it on 4th down. Loved the penalty reduction. Damn, only 3 penalties! Only minus is for the flat start and stepping on each other a few times to start.
Overall, as most of us know, we won't know much until those Stanford/UW games, but there were some positive signs out there for the program as a whole. Would give the game a B overall.
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Mon Sep 03, 2018 9:14 pm
by Merganzer
GrantDuck wrote:Took some notes on the re-watch.
WR; D; Rough day for the wideouts. Drops, bad routes leading to INT's, lack of separation....not good. Redd has a lot of potential, clearly. Hopefully we can get Addison up to speed with the playbook and Tabari Hines more involved.
I think Schooler should help, hopefully next week.
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Mon Sep 03, 2018 9:18 pm
by lukeyrid13
I agree, we should be letting ISM get a ton of reps at MLB over the next few games to get his feet wet. He has much better size and potential than Apelu. I love Apelu's effort, but he just gets eaten up by blocks.
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Mon Sep 03, 2018 11:02 pm
by buckmarkduck
Merganzer wrote:GrantDuck wrote:Took some notes on the re-watch.
WR; D; Rough day for the wideouts. Drops, bad routes leading to INT's, lack of separation....not good. Redd has a lot of potential, clearly. Hopefully we can get Addison up to speed with the playbook and Tabari Hines more involved.
I think Schooler should help, hopefully next week.
Is Schooler the most overrated duck player of all time?
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 2:22 am
by Alan
buckmarkduck wrote:Merganzer wrote:GrantDuck wrote:Took some notes on the re-watch.
WR; D; Rough day for the wideouts. Drops, bad routes leading to INT's, lack of separation....not good. Redd has a lot of potential, clearly. Hopefully we can get Addison up to speed with the playbook and Tabari Hines more involved.
I think Schooler should help, hopefully next week.
Is Schooler the most overrated duck player of all time?
No! The kid balls out every play, I would think he is close to breaking the starting line up, sure couldn't have played any worse than any other WR last week.
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 2:32 am
by Alan
GrantDuck wrote:Took some notes on the re-watch.
QB; A-/B+; Maybe an unfair grade, the WR's dropped a lot of balls, but I'm almost grading Herbert on his own curve. Missed a couple throws and had 2 misreads in the option game. Burmeister didn't do much(1 good throw).
RB; c+; Have to do better than 5.0 ypc against that caliber of school. Very few broken tackles. Liked Habibi-Likio's TD run, but didn't see anything else fantastic other than Taj's speed. Think we'll have to wait until Sean Dollars is on campus again to have a top tier all around running back like we're used to.
WR; D; Rough day for the wideouts. Drops, bad routes leading to INT's, lack of separation....not good. Redd has a lot of potential, clearly. Hopefully we can get Addison up to speed with the playbook and Tabari Hines more involved.
OL; A-. Overall, pretty good game 1. Need more consistent push in the running game, but pass pro was good and Shane L. was absolutely mauling people. Thought they did a real nice job in the screen game.
DL: B+. Fat Mac was just a force in there WITH one hand btw!! 7 tackles from the DT spot is awesome. Thought Faoliu and Jelks also played well. carlberg looked good actually. The one drive where FatMac was getting his hand re-taped wasn't good. Gary Baker was the one bad spot. Got knocked off the ball a few times. Really need to stay healthy here and continue to develop the depth.
LB: B+ Troy Dye was a little hyper and out of position to start, then played awesome. Hollins was unblockable, he'll play on Sundays next year. Going to say this now SLADE NEEDS to be starting at MLB. Apelu gets mauled in the middle repeatedly and got beat on their first TD. Love our talent overall here. Exciting position group.
DB: A-. Solid game outside of #10 getting torched on a deep route. The minus is for the tackling on the first couple drives. Outside of that, they stayed away from Graham, and Lenoir before his concussion looked pretty good too. The freshman corners got some run and didn't look completely lost and tackled well.
Overall coaching: A-; Honestly liked the gameplan. Pretty vanilla, but good. Truly hope the screen game is a major part of the offense going forward. It's a great play in cfb if executed properly. Loved going for it on 4th down. Loved the penalty reduction. Damn, only 3 penalties! Only minus is for the flat start and stepping on each other a few times to start.
Overall, as most of us know, we won't know much until those Stanford/UW games, but there were some positive signs out there for the program as a whole. Would give the game a B overall.
Very good analysis, I think I would have graded them just the same. I pretty down on Redd because of the drops and he just flat out took too many plays off which caused some problems. Herbert was 10 for 21 with 5 TD's. Half the time the receivers could catch the ball it was a TD. I can recall they had at least 4 through the hands drops, didn't help Herbert or the team.
I'm very high on the coaching staff, good play calling , good coaching, those guys are engaged.
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 6:31 am
by justducky0
buckmarkduck wrote:Merganzer wrote:GrantDuck wrote:Took some notes on the re-watch.
WR; D; Rough day for the wideouts. Drops, bad routes leading to INT's, lack of separation....not good. Redd has a lot of potential, clearly. Hopefully we can get Addison up to speed with the playbook and Tabari Hines more involved.
I think Schooler should help, hopefully next week.
Is Schooler the most overrated duck player of all time?
It blows my mind that a kid like Schooler gets hate from Duck fans. He balls out as hard as he can every game and actually produces.
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 6:31 am
by Duckenstein
Lenoir got a concussion?
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 7:21 am
by buckmarkduck
justducky0 wrote:buckmarkduck wrote:Merganzer wrote:GrantDuck wrote:Took some notes on the re-watch.
WR; D; Rough day for the wideouts. Drops, bad routes leading to INT's, lack of separation....not good. Redd has a lot of potential, clearly. Hopefully we can get Addison up to speed with the playbook and Tabari Hines more involved.
I think Schooler should help, hopefully next week.
Is Schooler the most overrated duck player of all time?
It blows my mind that a kid like Schooler gets hate from Duck fans. He balls out as hard as he can every game and actually produces.
It's not hate. But it blows my mind that people think hes going to be a great WR all the suddenly. He what he is, UO version of Steve Tasker. He plays hard, but he's not a guy that is going to blow up and be 1000 yard receiver like the small contingent of fans who want to constantly say how awesome he is.
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 7:23 am
by Alan
buckmarkduck wrote:justducky0 wrote:buckmarkduck wrote:Merganzer wrote:GrantDuck wrote:Took some notes on the re-watch.
WR; D; Rough day for the wideouts. Drops, bad routes leading to INT's, lack of separation....not good. Redd has a lot of potential, clearly. Hopefully we can get Addison up to speed with the playbook and Tabari Hines more involved.
I think Schooler should help, hopefully next week.
Is Schooler the most overrated duck player of all time?
It blows my mind that a kid like Schooler gets hate from Duck fans. He balls out as hard as he can every game and actually produces.
It's not hate. But it blows my mind that people think hes going to be a great WR all the suddenly. He what he is, UO version of Steve Tasker. He plays hard, but he's not a guy that is going to blow up and be 1000 yard receiver like the small contingent of fans who want to constantly say how awesome he is.
No he I said not a super star, he's just a kid many fans like because goes 100% every play and does produce..... he is not over rated.
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 8:38 am
by buckmarkduck
Then I apologize Alan. I've seen a contingent of fans on other sites saying he will be our best WR this year, and I've yet to see that from him. He does play hard and I appreciate that, but Redd and Johnson also play hard. For my not being happy with the drops, Johnson blocked like a mad man all game.
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 8:44 am
by Juice
Duckenstein wrote:Lenoir got a concussion?
He and La'Mar Winston I believe.
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 9:02 am
by StevensTechU
Without going team-by-team, we might have the worst WR corps in the conference. Truly on par with Oregon State.
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 9:16 am
by smithall
I think Troy Dye had a bad game. Being out of position at linebacker kills. He is always aggressive, but he got a TD scored on him when he didn't take the RB on a wheel route out of the backfield and the guy was wide open in the end zone. Dropped an easy interception as well. In a big game he can't have those mistakes. C-
Re: Game 1 (Bowling Green) Grades After Re-Watch
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 10:44 am
by GoDucksTroll
buckmarkduck wrote:Merganzer wrote:GrantDuck wrote:Took some notes on the re-watch.
WR; D; Rough day for the wideouts. Drops, bad routes leading to INT's, lack of separation....not good. Redd has a lot of potential, clearly. Hopefully we can get Addison up to speed with the playbook and Tabari Hines more involved.
I think Schooler should help, hopefully next week.
Is Schooler the most overrated duck player of all time?
You can't be overrated when for some reason 75% of Duck fans inexplicably hate you. I don't understand the Schooler hate. He got ran over as a safety because he was made out of matchsticks as a true freshman, but he still made plenty of plays. There was a reason he was starting: he's better than the other guys we had. 74 tackles and led the team in picks. You would take that from a true freshman any year, even if he's still got Ryan Nall's knee imprinted in his chest.
As a WR he is one of Herbz' favorite targets. He had a few drops last season, but overall he had a good year. I personally thought he was better than Johnny Johnson III last year, JJIII got bullied at times like when that Wazzu DB took his lunch money.
On special teams Schooler has been one of our best players. He has the speed to get down in coverage and make plays.