Page 1 of 3

How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 1:41 pm
by UOducksTK1
Something to be worried about? Just first game jitters?

We were among the top in the nation last year with WR drops. Just curious if our lack of WR depth and reliable talent could end up costing us.

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 1:55 pm
by StevensTechU
Concerning. Based on last year, offseason practice reports, and game 1, it looks like it's an ongoing issue. Best fix I can think of is if Bryan Addison winds up getting first team reps.

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 2:08 pm
by FlDuckFan
Very concerning, it would be one thing if they just happened on the first game but, they're happening in practice too. The wr's already have a problem separating from the db's so now the hope is they get open somehow and then actually catching the ball. Herbert's completion is going to suffer this year possibly dropping his draft evaluation.

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 2:17 pm
by UOducksTK1
StevensTechU wrote:Concerning. Based on last year, offseason practice reports, and game 1, it looks like it's an ongoing issue. Best fix I can think of is if Bryan Addison winds up getting first team reps.
That's how I feel. Also getting Hines in the thick of things should help too.

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 2:23 pm
by GrantDuck
Concerned but not panicked.

Reasons for concern are that it's an ongoing trend. Also, Redd is the only WR I saw get much separation. If you're a JJ type guy, not particularly big or fast, you need to have great precision and hands(see Keenan Howry). Some of this has to be on the WR coach as well. It's not just one guy.

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 2:30 pm
by Merganzer
Drops are a large part a lack of attention, not only keeping your eye on the ball, but understanding hand placement varies depending on the location, trajectory of the pass. So, yeah, coaching is important.

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 3:39 pm
by Ducks Decoy
Merganzer wrote:Drops are a large part a lack of attention, not only keeping your eye on the ball, but understanding hand placement varies depending on the location, trajectory of the pass. So, yeah, coaching is important.
Yep, to paraphrase a coach who shant be named "we can't trade our players or cut them so I guess we just got to coach them up."

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 4:04 pm
by GrandpaDuck
I used to think coaching made little difference in drops as all WR coaches at the college level know the basics and teaching technics of catching the ball and the players catch thousands of balls in workouts and with the jugs machines year around, besides formal practices and games. Seemed to me you either had that talent or not by the time you got to college. Then Lubick came and the drops went way down, he leaves and they go way up. Huff who was a notorious dropper was vastly improved under Lubick.

I'm now in the camp that coaching can make a difference. Willie did himself no favor not talking to Matt.

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2018 4:07 pm
by karlhungis
GrandpaDuck wrote:I used to think coaching made little difference in drops as all WR coaches at the college level know the basics and teaching technics of catching the ball and the players catch thousands of balls in workouts and with the jugs machines year around, besides formal practices and games. Seemed to me you either had that talent or not by the time you got to college. Then Lubick came and the drops went way down, he leaves and they go way up. Huff who was a notorious dropper was vastly improved under Lubick.

I'm now in the camp that coaching can make a difference. Willie did himself no favor not talking to Matt.
I feel the same way. And with that, it seems like our coach isn't going to just figure out a way to improve things. His coaching style yields these results. Things may improve as the talent increases but I don't expect to see much in season improvements.

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Wed Sep 05, 2018 10:33 am
by Juice
GrandpaDuck wrote:I used to think coaching made little difference in drops as all WR coaches at the college level know the basics and teaching technics of catching the ball and the players catch thousands of balls in workouts and with the jugs machines year around, besides formal practices and games. Seemed to me you either had that talent or not by the time you got to college. Then Lubick came and the drops went way down, he leaves and they go way up. Huff who was a notorious dropper was vastly improved under Lubick.

I'm now in the camp that coaching can make a difference. Willie did himself no favor not talking to Matt.
Can't put Lubick leaving on ol' Slick. If you were the offensive coordinator (and playcaller) and a new head coach comes in who calls the plays himself, are you going to take a demotion or go elsewhere?

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Wed Sep 05, 2018 10:43 am
by Duckenstein
It's coaching, Imo

Most people can catch a ball. It's focus, technique and reps.

Makes me wonder if Michael Johnson has the chops.

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Wed Sep 05, 2018 10:52 am
by StevensTechU
Juice wrote:
GrandpaDuck wrote:I used to think coaching made little difference in drops as all WR coaches at the college level know the basics and teaching technics of catching the ball and the players catch thousands of balls in workouts and with the jugs machines year around, besides formal practices and games. Seemed to me you either had that talent or not by the time you got to college. Then Lubick came and the drops went way down, he leaves and they go way up. Huff who was a notorious dropper was vastly improved under Lubick.

I'm now in the camp that coaching can make a difference. Willie did himself no favor not talking to Matt.
Can't put Lubick leaving on ol' Slick. If you were the offensive coordinator (and playcaller) and a new head coach comes in who calls the plays himself, are you going to take a demotion or go elsewhere?
He took a demotion... elsewhere.

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Wed Sep 05, 2018 11:48 am
by Juice
StevensTechU wrote:
Juice wrote:
GrandpaDuck wrote:I used to think coaching made little difference in drops as all WR coaches at the college level know the basics and teaching technics of catching the ball and the players catch thousands of balls in workouts and with the jugs machines year around, besides formal practices and games. Seemed to me you either had that talent or not by the time you got to college. Then Lubick came and the drops went way down, he leaves and they go way up. Huff who was a notorious dropper was vastly improved under Lubick.

I'm now in the camp that coaching can make a difference. Willie did himself no favor not talking to Matt.
Can't put Lubick leaving on ol' Slick. If you were the offensive coordinator (and playcaller) and a new head coach comes in who calls the plays himself, are you going to take a demotion or go elsewhere?
He took a demotion... elsewhere.
Unless he had strong ties to the university and/or state, which he didn't, his ego wasn't going to let him take a demotion for a new incoming HC, regardless of where he ended up.

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Wed Sep 05, 2018 1:28 pm
by UOducksTK1
GrandpaDuck wrote:I used to think coaching made little difference in drops as all WR coaches at the college level know the basics and teaching technics of catching the ball and the players catch thousands of balls in workouts and with the jugs machines year around, besides formal practices and games. Seemed to me you either had that talent or not by the time you got to college. Then Lubick came and the drops went way down, he leaves and they go way up. Huff who was a notorious dropper was vastly improved under Lubick.

I'm now in the camp that coaching can make a difference. Willie did himself no favor not talking to Matt.
I do miss Lubick.

Re: How concerning are the drops?

Posted: Wed Sep 05, 2018 8:48 pm
by ducks5ever
Where is Mitchell? Taj Griffen might have nice hands and speed?