Page 1 of 1

Game 2 (Portland State) grades after re-watch

Posted: Mon Sep 10, 2018 12:49 am
by GrantDuck
Overall, execution was much better on offense in this game. Less thing like footwork mistakes and dropped snaps. A few mistakes on defense from guys that haven't played much, which is fully correctable.

Quarterback: A. Really nice day from Justin Herbert. Missed a couple of protection calls, but that was about it.

Running back: B-. Still not many broken tackles, but I thought Verdell was better than in game 1 and Dye showed some speed.

Wide Receivers/TEs: C+. Also better than game 1, but the drops and off the hands stuff has to stop. In the regular season those will be turnovers. Did think there were some great blocks. I noted Dillon Mitchell and Schooler making multiple big blocks. Mitchell sprung Hines' TD with one where he completely spun his man the wrong direction. Was great to see Addison get into the game and snag one. The TE's had really strong games..bumps the overall grade. Breeland and Dillon have some work to do on their blocking, but that was a big time catch and run from Kano.

OL: B. The running game was better, Sewell is a monster. Pass pro had some minor mistakes. Good news again is it was mental mistakes and not a physical thing. Our OL could be very very good by midseason if they keep improving.


DL: A. Fat Mac is a terror. Most important player on our defense. Jelks was unreal too. Even the 2nd unit played better(but we still don't have quite the depth we need here, but they played great for today).

LB: B+ A couple mistakes from the young guys in the running game, but otherwise good. Jackson and Slade have NFL potential, when they "fire" wow!!, but have to play with a little more discipline before they get more PT.

DB: C+. Starters looked pretty good, but youngsters gave up a few big plays. Holland had a rough game 2. Won't really be tested until Stanford(fade routes), but I think Lenoir does look pretty good so far.

Special Teams: B. No mistakes, no great plays. Wondering if Stack will ever get healthy.

Coaching/ Game Plan : A. No complaints. Throw early, run late. Worked. Got a lot of players into the game.

Re: Game 2 (Portland State) grades after re-watch

Posted: Mon Sep 10, 2018 6:07 am
by gogreen55
Pretty much how I viewed it also. I was definitely more encouraged by this game than I was by the first game. I don't know if it will translate against better opponents or not, but I am a little more optimistic after Week 2.

Re: Game 2 (Portland State) grades after re-watch

Posted: Mon Sep 10, 2018 7:25 am
by woundedknees
Honestly hate the fair catch on the kick-off, mainly because it automatically places the ball on the 25.

I know it protects players from potential injuries. It's just a "meh" way to start a series.

Re: Game 2 (Portland State) grades after re-watch

Posted: Mon Sep 10, 2018 8:48 am
by AshlandDuck
I hate the rule too. It severely handicaps the coverage aspect of the game. I can remember many plays that helped the defense by pinning an opponent deep with great coverage - and now that's only really possible on a muff or an ill-advised attempt to run it back.

Re: Game 2 (Portland State) grades after re-watch

Posted: Mon Sep 10, 2018 9:30 am
by lukeyrid13
I re-watched all of Herbert's throws and he actually did a really good job of spreading the ball around to all areas of the field. Last game, he was a bit too reliant on the deep bomb, but in this game he threw a good number of intermediate passes as well. I will post a link to a youtube video of all of his attempts.

Re: Game 2 (Portland State) grades after re-watch

Posted: Mon Sep 10, 2018 9:30 am
by lukeyrid13

Re: Game 2 (Portland State) grades after re-watch

Posted: Mon Sep 10, 2018 10:17 am
by karlhungis
lukeyrid13 wrote:I re-watched all of Herbert's throws and he actually did a really good job of spreading the ball around to all areas of the field. Last game, he was a bit too reliant on the deep bomb, but in this game he threw a good number of intermediate passes as well. I will post a link to a youtube video of all of his attempts.
He really did look sharp.

Re: Game 2 (Portland State) grades after re-watch

Posted: Mon Sep 10, 2018 12:19 pm
by Duckenstein
Herbert is amazing

The power run game is good too, but the RBs aren't quite as seasoned as we're used to seeing

Re: Game 2 (Portland State) grades after re-watch

Posted: Mon Sep 10, 2018 2:07 pm
by duckduckgoose
woundedknees wrote:Honestly hate the fair catch on the kick-off, mainly because it automatically places the ball on the 25.

I know it protects players from potential injuries. It's just a "meh" way to start a series.
Why not get rid of kickoffs and start all drives from the 25? Makes more sense, except for onside kicks.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Re: Game 2 (Portland State) grades after re-watch

Posted: Tue Sep 11, 2018 8:51 am
by GoDucksTroll
I'll agree with everyone about the kick-off fair catch rule being stupid. It's part of the game. I'm all for player safety, but the dangerous part of it isn't really for the returner - it's the coverage team and blockers colliding.

Guys that impressed me:

Tabari Hines: He knows how to run a route.

Kano Dillon: That TD was fun to see, a physical freak that we need with McCormick gone.

Dillon Mitchell: Had a great block and showed off his athleticism on those sideline tightrope plays. He's going to explode eventually.

Adrian Jackson: He blew up a few plays.

DL: The usual suspects, Jelks, Scott, Faoliu, Hollins all played great. Gus Cumberlander had a great play in the second half, he's been forgotten, but if he can add depth that would be great.

CJ Verdell: He didn't impress me all that much in week 1 considering the expectations we all have for him, but he did this week. I know he's going to break a few big plays this season with that bowling ball style and getting past the secondary.

That play on the punt to keep it out of the end zone by Ugo Amadi was such a smart play. He's become a fantastic football player.

The one thing I didn't like was Brady Breeze getting beat on that long TD pass. It was a funky scramble drill type of play, but Breeze is usually the one who never makes a mistake. Early WR miscues for the second week in a row. Shane Lemiuex got beat on a pass rush, continuing his struggles against speed rushers that come inside. Missed PAT on a combination of a not great snap and a line drive kick. Emerson is okay, hopefully Stack is better.