Page 1 of 2

Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Sun Sep 23, 2018 11:22 pm
by GrantDuck
I'll admit I fast forwarded through.."plays" in the 2nd half, but I made myself re-watch most of it. I have most of the same sentiments as right after the game, but I am a little more worried about our defense going forward in the Pac-12 after re-watching the 2nd half. We also got a ridiculous amount of bad bounces in that 2nd half.

Quarterback- A. What a game from Justin. He brought it. The one thing he needs to work on(and part of this is WR play), is when the other team blitzes, finding his hot route faster. He takes some sacks he doesn't need to. Outside of that..running/passing/deep/short, he was great. Elite game from an elite QB, from Eugene!

Running Backs- B-. Obviously a breakout from Verdell we were waiting for. Got into a nice rhythm. The fumble takes away from it, but gosh, did it HAVE to bounce right to a Stanford player!? Did he have to be laying on another Oregon player instead of the ground?! Travis Dye is great when he gets a hole, great burst, but he's still an 18 year old when he runs into contact. Would like to give a higher grade, but can't with 2 fumbles. Would like to see them use TBJ and Verdell together at times.

Wide Receivers/TE's- B; A+ for Mitchell. B- for the rest. Mitchell got a raw deal on at LEAST 1 call in OT.(pac-12 refs, especially with PI calls never go our way). Breeland had a REALLY improved game blocking. Even got a 2fer on our first TD. That's the best I've ever seen him block(was a weak point in the past). A couple drops, but ones we can live with. In OT they didn't get any separation and the drops mixed in, so that's why B is the overall grade.

Offensive Line: A-. Basically A for everyone except Hanson's snaps. Had 5-6 bad snaps, and 3 egregious ones.(one which Herbert saved). Pass pro was AMAZING outside of a couple times Travis Dye missing his blitz pick ups. Ran the ball on Stanford consistently and I think they will prove to be a real salty run defense this season. The Warmack/Shane L combo blocks on that Verdell big run in the 2nd quarter was an OL coach's dream. (and Mario was PUMPED after that run, lol). Hopefully doesn't become a mental thing for Jake, because he's always been a consistent snapper.

Defensive Line: A-. Really great first half. The pass rush in obvious passing situations late left some to be desired. Fat Mac was a monster. carlberg showed UP!

Linebackers: A-. Ditto on the great first half. Dye, Apelu, brought the wood. Slade over ran a couple plays but was otherwise solid. Need Winston to show up a little more. Troy was superb in pass coverage in the game. Really look away the underneath stuff and had a sweet breakup on Stanford's first drive to end the possession. Then had PERFEct coverage against Love on the wheel route later. What a stud. Hollins had another all-around game.

Secondary(this is long, so bear with me): D. More than anything, I wanted to watch how often we put 8 in the box(outside of when Stanford had like 5 Guards in). It was less than I thought. This is a major worry. Dropping 7, if we can't defend the pass against Stanford, we are going to have a major problem against passing teams in the Pac-12.

Ugo was pretty good, everyone else was not too good, sadly. Lenoir had a nice play on the opening drive, forcing a guy out of bounds on a back shoulder throw. Those are the positives. The negatives here...

We still have to go against N'keal Harry, UW's tall WR, WSU's collection, and so forth. I'm not going to bag on #4 anymore than I already have, but he got beat on the skinny post again in this one, against Stanford's #3 WR. If our "#1" corner can't defend SJSU's WR's and Stanford's #3 WR on the same route...it's going to be a loooong season back there.

It's not JUST the corners:
Pickett is pretty solid, but he needs to have more of an impact back there in the passing game. For example, on Stanford's last TD, we were in cover 1 and he has center field duty. The corner(Lenoir) played correct technique inside of the Stanford player(although he mistimed his jump). The ball was "tipped" and caught on the left hash. A FS needs to be able to get to that spot after the tip if he's reading the QB properly in cover 1 and either blast the guy or make a play on the ball. You have to be able to cover at LEAST hash to hash in cover 1 in that spot. (Guys like Earl Thomas can cover damn near sideline to sideline it seems sometimes).

I think we had a lot of "worries" coming into this season..and most of them have proven to be OK...but as we know from past years(2004, 2015), if you have young corners that aren't very good, it's going to be a long season on defense. As I said in the secondary thread, part of this is past staff's whiffing on guys in recruiting...but that said we need to figure something out in the back end in the next few games, or it's going to be hard to stop teams that have good WRs.


coaching: B. Some may disagree, but I thought the coaching was good. Great offensive gameplan. Great gap discipline on defense in the run game. I don't know a single coach that punts in that situation and doesn't try to at least get the 1st down running(unless the clock is going to be under 5 seconds, which it wasn't). Two glaring things to me was the play calling on offense where we ran that goofy fat mac package instead of just lining up and punching it in. That hurt us. Secondly, I thought the overtime play calling was poor. Just taking 4 shots at the end zone.... I like mixing in a shovel pass/screen, draw in there on 2nd down, especially with Stanford blitzing on 3 out of the 4 plays.

I love how much we've cut down on penalties(although Johnny Johnson III had a REALLY stupid one late). It's great when we see a coach have a clear cut goal for the program and that program is achieved. Another one is being more "physical" as a program, and there's no doubt that's starting to happen(jury still out if we can sustain this on the road, etc.)..but again, it means what the coach is saying is not just words, and that means players are buying in and it's being taught correctly. Easily the biggest silver lining for me after this one.

TL;DR: A lot to be encouraged about for a loss. Penalties were still low and physicality was better(cristobal establishing his identity with the team).
Question for now is if we can sustain this level of play all season and not just for big games. Main negative is we have to figure something out in the secondary, it's worse than I thought because we didn't stack the line that much (whether it's moving someone to corner or playing backups or the DB's just improving over the season. Go Ducks!

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 8:35 am
by Merganzer
GrantDuck wrote: Defensive Line: A-. Really great first half. The pass rush in obvious passing situations late left some to be desired. Fat Mac was a monster. carlberg showed UP!
Clearly no disagreement on the secondary, gotta get better play there, the biggest step in improvement is supposed to be from 1st year to 2nd, so #4 is definitely troublesome. What may become more effective sooner is the pass rush, as you noted above, there also weren't many, if any blitz's called. The risk is leaving the secondary vulnerable, but since that is its normal condition, why not?

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 8:37 am
by OregonFan4Life
You are very brave to rewatch the game, but great analysis like always. It’s hard to see such highly deserves grades yet know that they somehow managed to lose, even with the poor play of the secondary.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 8:55 am
by GoDucksIn09
Stanford uses multiple guys who are over 6'4 going up against guys quite a bit smaller. This I the challenge that Stanford has over just about anyone in the league. I do not know how to defend them. If you rush the qb then leave them in man coverage and that is perilous. There has to be a way to cover them and still get pressure on the qb and not allow Love to gash you I don't know what it is though. Oregon did a good job.

The mistakes hiking the ball and the fumble are two things that resulted in costing us the game. You take away either one of those and we win the game. Verdell will be tested for next several weeks to see if his ball security improves. You can bet the other defensive coordinators will be telling them to try to strip the ball from him.

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 9:02 am
by Merganzer
GoDucksIn09 wrote: You can bet the other defensive coordinators will be telling them to try to strip the ball from him.
That can work out well for the Ducks & Verdell. If it was a one time thing, not a real ball security issue, then concentrating on stripping, rather than tackling, plus Oregon.

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 9:26 am
by StevensTechU
Most of the catches made by Stanford receivers weren't because of how tall they are, it was because the DB was out of position. That happened in the preseason, and it's going to continue to happen in other conference games. It's by far the weakest point of our defense, and I'm concerned because neither Heyward or Donte have ever had a shutdown secondary.

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 10:08 am
by dphi
StevensTechU wrote:Most of the catches made by Stanford receivers weren't because of how tall they are, it was because the DB was out of position. That happened in the preseason, and it's going to continue to happen in other conference games. It's by far the weakest point of our defense, and I'm concerned because neither Heyward or Donte have ever had a shutdown secondary.
Exactly, people keep bringing up the height difference but it wouldn't have mattered even if those guys were 5'8"

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 10:12 am
by Alan
dphi wrote:
StevensTechU wrote:Most of the catches made by Stanford receivers weren't because of how tall they are, it was because the DB was out of position. That happened in the preseason, and it's going to continue to happen in other conference games. It's by far the weakest point of our defense, and I'm concerned because neither Heyward or Donte have ever had a shutdown secondary.
Exactly, people keep bringing up the height difference but it wouldn't have mattered even if those guys were 5'8"
6'7" against 5'8", 6'7" wins 95% of the time in a jump ball situation.

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 10:17 am
by StevensTechU
But Alan, of Stanford's 19 completions, how many were jump balls?

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 10:41 am
by GrantDuck
I think maybe 4-5 completions were jump balls, tops. A skinny post where our DB is 5-10 yards behind their WR that he is faster than...I can't even explain that.

As far as how to defend those plays as a shorter player, basically what Troy Dye did the first series of the game. Get your body in front of theirs, get your arm between their arms, and either rip the ball out or rip their arms apart.

I'm not saying this is always easy and yes, you're going to lose some of them, but there's much better technique than what we saw Saturday.

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 10:45 am
by Juice
StevensTechU wrote:Most of the catches made by Stanford receivers weren't because of how tall they are, it was because the DB was out of position. That happened in the preseason, and it's going to continue to happen in other conference games. It's by far the weakest point of our defense, and I'm concerned because neither Heyward or Donte have ever had a shutdown secondary.
To be fair when was the last time we had a shutdown secondary?

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 10:51 am
by OregonFan4Life
StevensTechU wrote:But Alan, of Stanford's 19 completions, how many were jump balls?
Good point, I can for sure remember 2 touchdowns from jump balls, and in both of them the CB’s were in terrible position. As another poster just pointed out, Troy Dye was far better at coverage than our DB’s, that’s definitely a concerning sign that a LB was better than our CB’s at covering opposing WR’s.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 10:52 am
by Duckenstein
Kudos for rewatching

I think..

We played a nearly perfect first half. A lot to be encouraged by

You can't stop 6'6' receivers with 5'10' dbs

But those terrible mistakes cost us. The bad snaps, that fumble at the end. The scoop and score.

Those mistakes were magnified x10 because of the inconsistent officiating and some unbelievable lucky bounces for Stanford

Normally, mistakes like that will cost you something, but in this case standard truly lucked out in a way I have never seen in college football

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 11:04 am
by Penky26
Tough to watch that game once let alone twice.

Part of me simply wonders how the game would have finished out if they recovered the first fumble from 1st and goal at the 1. Would have turned the ball over to Stanford but it would have been 1st and 10 from their own 10 and the score still 24-7.

Lot of "if's." Too many for me to be brave enough to watch this game again

Re: Week 4 (Stanford) Grades on Re-Watch

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2018 11:04 am
by Duckenstein
More I think a about it, the more bizarre the 4th qtr and other were

The other td was a tipped ball. Stanford just had everything handed to them.

So bizarre