Position Grades Week 8 (Wazzu Rewatch)
Posted: Mon Oct 22, 2018 9:37 am
Well, usually when I chart these I sort of chart negative and positive plays...I ran out of space for the negative things in the first half! That said, it appears we got some good news with Herbert likely coming back(if CBS is to be believed to have good sources) and also it was good to see the team fight back in the 2nd half. There's zero doubt the combination of us coming off the big win and heading into that hornet's nest had a fair bit to do with what happened in the 1st half.
Quarterback-B+. Missed a couple deep balls early. 2nd half was an A. Not much else to say. Valiant in the 2nd half taking shots in there all game.
Running Back- C. Well, there weren't any fumbles and the YPC for CJ was alright. I thought it was a mediocre day for the running breaks. O-Line had an awful game(detailed later), but it's just that young running backs without as much physical development(and not being freaks like Royce/Tyner were) just don't break as many tackles. Dye picked the wrong gap on one of his runs when we had the 3 straight running plays. Multiple times we had a nice hole on the left side and CJ got about 9 yards, but with one more good cut, they could have been 35. Good running backs break off safeties and corners at the 2nd level and we just haven't seen that this year. As with many, not sure why TJB isn't getting more touches, especially on stretch/outside type plays where he's proven to be effective over the years.
I get that Verdell fits the scheme better, but you also have to mold player usage to the guys you have.
Wide Receiver/Tight End B-. Hard to grade separation as WSU's strategy was literally to hold/PI every play and hope the Pac-12 refs didn't call it(which they didn't nearly as often as it happened). Mitchell would have likely had multiple scores if not for the grabass and as a result drew multiple penalties. Unfortunately, he also had a key drop on the Hail Mary and JJIII had another key drop during our last failed drive of the game. Schooler and Breeland had some tough catches in traffic.
Offensive Line- D- Barely a passing grade(Shane played well, but F for the other 4 guys). Herbert was running for his life. Bad snaps. Multiple missed blitz pick ups. Jake Hanson continues to struggle against quicker defensive tackles. People want to blame the play calling, but when your center gets beat across his face(and the play would have gone for a touchdown) if he doesn't, multiple times in a game. Particularly,Travis Dye's 3rd down run in the 3rd quarter was actually a perfect play call, only Hanson just completely whiffed his block. He leaned over and reached like a freshman the first day of fall camp. Didn't handle the noise or atmosphere. Aiello had multiple penalties and was getting beat like a drum in pass pro. This is an experienced, veteran group. No excuse for that performance from them. This was the thing that stood out most on the re-watch. I was ready to jump all over Arroyo(and I'm still going to a little), but when your O-line plays like that crap show we saw from them, it really limits the play caller.
Offensive Coaching: D+. I wanted to grade this lower and I'm very concerned about this going forward, but when I saw how poorly the O-line played I bumped the grade slightly. You have to also consider that in the first half we ran so few plays and then in the 2nd half we were just trying to come back efficiently. I've been saying for weeks now that our offense lacks variety and it was never more evident than in the 1st half of this game. WSU was all over our power run to the left side on 1st down and was slanting that way or to the middle nearly every 1st down in the first half. You know, using TBJ or even Dye on a screen pass would have been VERY EFFECTIVE on multiple plays here Arroyo, or simply some simple WR screen passes to the edges to counter what WSU was doing with those slants. It's like Taj Griffin left and we just decided to scrap those plays entirely from the playbook?!
You can't be waiting until drive 5-6 to make that adjustment and I thought that, as much as anything, cost us the game. Next time we play Wazzu we MUST come up with a better gameplan offensively. That was really bad 2 years in a row on that side of the ball.
Defensive Line: D. Not only did they generate no pass rush(I know the air raid gets the ball out quick, but you've got to disrupt it more) but WSU also RAN the ball effectively. A complete non-factor in this one.
Linebackers: B-. Apelu and Dye were absolute studs. They each missed a key tackle on TD plays for Wazzu, however. LaMar Winston missed 4 tackles in the game, but also had the 2 nice batted balls. Hollins had his worst game of the season. Non-factor. A couple of Dye's sticks were absolute monsters.
Secondary: B. Some might think this grade is a little high, but in the 2nd half, save for #4's usual get beat deep for a big play over the middle(which has now happened literally every single game this season). We didn't have any blown coverages. Lenoir had an awesome game. 2 picks, lots of smothering coverage. He got beat for 1 TD, but he had very good coverage on the play. Most of what WSU did in the 1st half actually came on dump downs to running backs against our linebackers and mixing in their effective running game.
Defensive Coaching: C. That's about as bad of a gameplan as I've seen from Leavitt in the 1st half since he's been here. No freakin' clue what we were doing running completely telegraphed heavy blitzes and off man coverage. That's literally what Air Raid is built to beat. 2nd half looked like the Leavitt I know and love.
We need to work on our blitz schemes to that we aren't giving it away so much. When WSU runs a dummy count and like 3 guys come suddenly running up to the line, like every freaking time we're going to blitz, it makes it really easy on the QB.
Recap:
-Offensive line was atrocious. Hanson needs major work on his technique against quick dudes. I suppose San Jose giving him a tough time was probably an indicator he was going to struggle this year against those types.
-Herbert was good and is coming back!
-Offensive coaching is my biggest concern with this team going forward
-Defense was bad in the 1st half, but I thought the secondary played much better in that 2nd half outside of a couple of plays and better than I thought after initially watching overall.
All of that said, I do think if we can stay healthy, we have a fair shot at winning out or only losing 1. ASU/OSU/UA are teams we should handle. UCLA is playing scary...Chip is getting them going man. Utah on the road will always be tough and is the hardest game left.
Quarterback-B+. Missed a couple deep balls early. 2nd half was an A. Not much else to say. Valiant in the 2nd half taking shots in there all game.
Running Back- C. Well, there weren't any fumbles and the YPC for CJ was alright. I thought it was a mediocre day for the running breaks. O-Line had an awful game(detailed later), but it's just that young running backs without as much physical development(and not being freaks like Royce/Tyner were) just don't break as many tackles. Dye picked the wrong gap on one of his runs when we had the 3 straight running plays. Multiple times we had a nice hole on the left side and CJ got about 9 yards, but with one more good cut, they could have been 35. Good running backs break off safeties and corners at the 2nd level and we just haven't seen that this year. As with many, not sure why TJB isn't getting more touches, especially on stretch/outside type plays where he's proven to be effective over the years.
I get that Verdell fits the scheme better, but you also have to mold player usage to the guys you have.
Wide Receiver/Tight End B-. Hard to grade separation as WSU's strategy was literally to hold/PI every play and hope the Pac-12 refs didn't call it(which they didn't nearly as often as it happened). Mitchell would have likely had multiple scores if not for the grabass and as a result drew multiple penalties. Unfortunately, he also had a key drop on the Hail Mary and JJIII had another key drop during our last failed drive of the game. Schooler and Breeland had some tough catches in traffic.
Offensive Line- D- Barely a passing grade(Shane played well, but F for the other 4 guys). Herbert was running for his life. Bad snaps. Multiple missed blitz pick ups. Jake Hanson continues to struggle against quicker defensive tackles. People want to blame the play calling, but when your center gets beat across his face(and the play would have gone for a touchdown) if he doesn't, multiple times in a game. Particularly,Travis Dye's 3rd down run in the 3rd quarter was actually a perfect play call, only Hanson just completely whiffed his block. He leaned over and reached like a freshman the first day of fall camp. Didn't handle the noise or atmosphere. Aiello had multiple penalties and was getting beat like a drum in pass pro. This is an experienced, veteran group. No excuse for that performance from them. This was the thing that stood out most on the re-watch. I was ready to jump all over Arroyo(and I'm still going to a little), but when your O-line plays like that crap show we saw from them, it really limits the play caller.
Offensive Coaching: D+. I wanted to grade this lower and I'm very concerned about this going forward, but when I saw how poorly the O-line played I bumped the grade slightly. You have to also consider that in the first half we ran so few plays and then in the 2nd half we were just trying to come back efficiently. I've been saying for weeks now that our offense lacks variety and it was never more evident than in the 1st half of this game. WSU was all over our power run to the left side on 1st down and was slanting that way or to the middle nearly every 1st down in the first half. You know, using TBJ or even Dye on a screen pass would have been VERY EFFECTIVE on multiple plays here Arroyo, or simply some simple WR screen passes to the edges to counter what WSU was doing with those slants. It's like Taj Griffin left and we just decided to scrap those plays entirely from the playbook?!
You can't be waiting until drive 5-6 to make that adjustment and I thought that, as much as anything, cost us the game. Next time we play Wazzu we MUST come up with a better gameplan offensively. That was really bad 2 years in a row on that side of the ball.
Defensive Line: D. Not only did they generate no pass rush(I know the air raid gets the ball out quick, but you've got to disrupt it more) but WSU also RAN the ball effectively. A complete non-factor in this one.
Linebackers: B-. Apelu and Dye were absolute studs. They each missed a key tackle on TD plays for Wazzu, however. LaMar Winston missed 4 tackles in the game, but also had the 2 nice batted balls. Hollins had his worst game of the season. Non-factor. A couple of Dye's sticks were absolute monsters.
Secondary: B. Some might think this grade is a little high, but in the 2nd half, save for #4's usual get beat deep for a big play over the middle(which has now happened literally every single game this season). We didn't have any blown coverages. Lenoir had an awesome game. 2 picks, lots of smothering coverage. He got beat for 1 TD, but he had very good coverage on the play. Most of what WSU did in the 1st half actually came on dump downs to running backs against our linebackers and mixing in their effective running game.
Defensive Coaching: C. That's about as bad of a gameplan as I've seen from Leavitt in the 1st half since he's been here. No freakin' clue what we were doing running completely telegraphed heavy blitzes and off man coverage. That's literally what Air Raid is built to beat. 2nd half looked like the Leavitt I know and love.
We need to work on our blitz schemes to that we aren't giving it away so much. When WSU runs a dummy count and like 3 guys come suddenly running up to the line, like every freaking time we're going to blitz, it makes it really easy on the QB.
Recap:
-Offensive line was atrocious. Hanson needs major work on his technique against quick dudes. I suppose San Jose giving him a tough time was probably an indicator he was going to struggle this year against those types.
-Herbert was good and is coming back!
-Offensive coaching is my biggest concern with this team going forward
-Defense was bad in the 1st half, but I thought the secondary played much better in that 2nd half outside of a couple of plays and better than I thought after initially watching overall.
All of that said, I do think if we can stay healthy, we have a fair shot at winning out or only losing 1. ASU/OSU/UA are teams we should handle. UCLA is playing scary...Chip is getting them going man. Utah on the road will always be tough and is the hardest game left.