Page 1 of 1

Silver lining

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2018 10:43 pm
by lukeyrid13
Herbert really should come back at this point. He has a ton of talent but isn’t ready. If Arizona scheme overwhelms him he’s not ready

We have no seniors on offense. It can only get better.... right!?

Re: Silver lining

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2018 10:45 pm
by OregonFan4Life
He’s also taking organic chemistry, toughest class out there maybe! Hopefully if he returns his school load will be lighter.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Re: Silver lining

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2018 10:46 pm
by lukeyrid13
And we’re a basketball school anyway ;)

Re: Silver lining

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2018 10:54 pm
by Jesseisabeast
Hard to not be overwhelmed when we suck at OL, have 3 running backs that switch without any purpose, one WR and the worst TE group at Oregon in 30 years....and we have a playbook that goes about 3 plays deep. My real question with Herbert is even if we all agree he needs to learn a lot more....how much can he learn from Arroyo and Cristobal about NFL offenses and the quarterback position?

Re: Silver lining

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2018 10:58 pm
by OregonFan4Life
Jesseisabeast wrote:Hard to not be overwhelmed when we suck at OL, have 3 running backs that switch without any purpose, one WR and the worst TE group at Oregon in 30 years....and we have a playbook that goes about 3 plays deep. My real question with Herbert is even if we all agree he needs to learn a lot more....how much can he learn from Arroyo and Cristobal about NFL offenses and the quarterback position?
If Chip had the success he did with the roster he had in 09, then Arroyo and Cristobal should be more successful than this.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Re: Silver lining

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2018 11:11 pm
by Jesseisabeast
Well you can’t win many PAC 12 games when you tack on garbage stats and still don’t sniff 300 yards offense after spotting the other team 20 point leads in the first half sooooooooo......we might need to figure how to translate steroids into yards and points

Re: Silver lining

Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2018 11:50 pm
by UOducksTK1
Jesseisabeast wrote:Hard to not be overwhelmed when we suck at OL, have 3 running backs that switch without any purpose, one WR and the worst TE group at Oregon in 30 years....and we have a playbook that goes about 3 plays deep. My real question with Herbert is even if we all agree he needs to learn a lot more....how much can he learn from Arroyo and Cristobal about NFL offenses and the quarterback position?
Our OL sucks? I love our OL.

Re: Silver lining

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 9:35 am
by GoDucksIn09
I don't know if the OL is bad per se. They need to create holes for the RBs to run through. That is hard when they are putting 8 in the box daring you to run it up the middle which is exactly what Oregon does. They do not run outside or give any reason for teams to think the RBs will run outside. With the salary the coaches are being paid would think they can see what defenses are doing and attack them on outside. Part of what Chip Kelly did was to see what a team would do and then attack their weakness. Oregon simply is not doing that. They are way to predictable. First down run up the middle for 1 yard then throw deep to Mitchell on 2nd and 3rd down. I never played football competitively but if my untrained eye knows what they going to do then you know these DCs who get paid 6 figures can figure it out as well.

Re: Silver lining

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 10:28 am
by Duck07
GoDucksIn09 wrote:I don't know if the OL is bad per se. They need to create holes for the RBs to run through. That is hard when they are putting 8 in the box daring you to run it up the middle which is exactly what Oregon does. They do not run outside or give any reason for teams to think the RBs will run outside. With the salary the coaches are being paid would think they can see what defenses are doing and attack them on outside. Part of what Chip Kelly did was to see what a team would do and then attack their weakness. Oregon simply is not doing that. They are way to predictable. First down run up the middle for 1 yard then throw deep to Mitchell on 2nd and 3rd down. I never played football competitively but if my untrained eye knows what they going to do then you know these DCs who get paid 6 figures can figure it out as well.
So last year I became interested in the idea of the Observer Effect and the Collective Unconsciousness on sports; ie that because we are watching it happen and believe certain things will happen, that it has an effect on the outcome. This year I've really started to think more about how we teach people football (or sports in general) and how their knowledge of the game plays into their play-calling. There is the simple stuff like go with Power Right and then using a Counter Trap Left off the same look to the more nuanced things like setting up route concepts to attack coverages.

My coach in HS was a 3 year starter at Mizzou at LB and I learned so much in my first year from watching and breaking down film with him. To this day my eyes still constantly search out the Guards at the snap because they almost never lie when it comes to telling you if its run or pass. How a Defense is taught to attack and learn about an Offense is just as different but similar in as many ways as the Offense doing that to the Defense. I've always enjoyed this article about Jim Johnson; it's mostly about the origins of the Double A gap blitz but to me its more about the philosophy of why you're doing it that stands out.
On Nov. 16, 1997, the 0--10 Colts knocked off the defending Super Bowl champion Packers 41--38 at the RCA Dome. Johnson's Colts blitzed all day and gave up 441 yards of offense, but they sacked Brett Favre three times, intercepted two passes and left a lasting impression on Green Bay assistant coach Andy Reid. "We scored a lot of points that day, but Jim destroyed our protections with his blitzes," says Reid. "I told myself if I'm ever lucky enough to get a head coaching job in this league, that guy is going to be my defensive coordinator."

Two years later Reid was named coach of the Eagles, and sure enough he hired Johnson, then 57, to run his defense. Johnson immediately installed multiple blitzes to exploit the weaknesses of pass-blocking schemes. "Jim wasn't worried about what teams did in the running game or how they ran pass routes," says Spagnuolo. "He studied protections and attacked them."
https://www.si.com/vault/2009/12/28/105 ... ing-impact

These same things were true about the 46 Defense when it was destroying offenses - it ruined their ability to block up front. If you can't block them up front or they can't block you, you have just gone a long ways towards deciding the outcome of the game. The problem at least with our offense in many ways is that we don't look like we know how to attack what the defense wants to do against us.

I'd like to give Arroyo time because the Verdell play-call against bumass was a great example of scheming a play for your team. Everyone knows we love Mitchell and by motioning him across the backfield we not only cleared out the short-side of the field of defenders but then made the play look like we're trying to discover if Mitchell has Man or Zone coverage so that we can isolate him on a pass. They cleared the box as they guessed pass and we had an easy play to win it. There's also the fact that on just about any pass that falls incomplete you can usually find a guy who was open but the bigger deal is if you're able to make those open WRs the first or second read.