Page 1 of 2
How talented are we?
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2018 7:02 pm
by lukeyrid13
Let me preface by saying we shouldn’t lose by 30 to Arizona no matter what.
But, before the year I think most here said 8-4 or 9-3 would make this a successful season. Did we show enough in the Stanford and uw games to create lofty expectations or is 5-3 more in line with the talent that we have? If you look at this years roster compared to years past, I would say it’s better than 2016 but mainly because of QB play. Besides that year, How far back would we need to go to see an equal team talent wise? Probably 2006, where we went 7-6.
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2018 8:01 pm
by GrandpaDuck
Offensively we are more talented the 2017 and 2016. Defensively better than 2016 even with the Hoke factor making the 2016 defense much worse than its talent.
Offensively 2009 is interesting. Dickson edge at TE, Masoli vs Herbert @ QB, Mitchell versus Maehl at WR with no supporting cast for either of them, James and Barner Freshman but an edge there, Huge taland edge for the 2018 OL line versus a 2009 O-Line that came in with a combined 1 career start.
Now off on a slight tangent in regards to whether it is talent or coaching:
In 2016 with 4 skinny freshman starters Tony Brooks James averaged 7.5 yards per carry and Royce and Benoit 6. A team average of 5.5. This year running behind the same 4 linemen bulked up over 20 pounds each with now over 100 career starts he averages 4.7 and the team averages 4.3. It is massive under-achievement that is all scheme and coaching. (By the way the 2016 QB's averaged under 3 yards per carry so its not like say 2009 where QB running drove the running game. Herbert could run 2 read options a game like Thomas in 2011 and make the threat viable.)
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2018 8:53 pm
by lukeyrid13
We lost: Crosby, freeman, Benoit and Nelson from last year. I think we had more talent last year personally.
I was re watching a game from 2013 and our skill position talent was worlds apart.
Addison, huff, Marshall, DAT, mundt, tyner, lyerla, Baylis, pharaoh brown, Dwayne Stanford etc.
Mariotas weapons were so much better than what we have now.
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2018 9:08 pm
by GrandpaDuck
lukeyrid13 wrote:We lost: Crosby, freeman, Benoit and Nelson from last year. I think we had more talent last year personally.
I was re watching a game from 2013 and our skill position talent was worlds apart.
Addison, huff, Marshall, DAT, mundt, tyner, lyerla, Baylis, pharaoh brown, Dwayne Stanford etc.
Mariotas weapons were so much better than what we have now.
Yes, much more talent in 2013.
Verses 2017 I give weight to the line being more experienced across the board and a third year QB being better than one who had 4? starts going into 2017. QB and O-line for me. I consider the loss of Nelson offset by the 3 wideouts having a year of experience instead of the zero experience they had going into 2017, though only Mitchell has capitalized on it.
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2018 9:33 pm
by chapelhillduck
We finished last night's game with Brady Breeze and a walk on (sorry blanking on hyphenated name) at OUTSIDE LINEBACKER
Our first team is talented, but injuries and scholarship limits take their toll
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 12:27 am
by jimmy12
chapelhillduck wrote:We finished last night's game with Brady Breeze and a walk on (sorry blanking on hyphenated name) at OUTSIDE LINEBACKER
Our first team is talented, but injuries and scholarship limits take their toll
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Scholarship limits?
How talented are we?
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 7:31 am
by chapelhillduck
jimmy12 wrote:chapelhillduck wrote:We finished last night's game with Brady Breeze and a walk on (sorry blanking on hyphenated name) at OUTSIDE LINEBACKER
Our first team is talented, but injuries and scholarship limits take their toll
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Scholarship limits?
From Chip, through 2016. Lost a bunch of visits and a couple of scholarship slots for three classes through 2016.
Plus the transfers that happened since coaching changes. AFAIK I don't think we have 85 on scholarship right now, and if we do it's because they were given to more than normal number of walk ons
They weren't crushing penalties, but taken with everything else it means we don't have a lot of depth that's near the level it could be.
We're not a different team than Stanford or UW games, just a bunch more people banged up.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 8:42 am
by Duck07
From what I can remember about a lot of our preseason prognostications, staying Healthy was the #1 key for us to have a season where we likely finish above what our record should be. It wasn't just Herbert staying healthy either, but all of those key players we've seen us have to rely on so far.
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 8:53 am
by StevensTechU
Defensively, our talent is paper thin. Offensively, we have few standouts; our talent is Stanford-esque in that it's at QB and OL.
Overall, ex-QB, this is one of the least talented teams we've had in the 2-deep since I became a fan in 2007.
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 10:03 am
by Duckenstein
This team has less than ideal numbers and quite a bit of dead wood
There is also lak of experience at many positions
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 10:25 am
by StevensTechU
I couldn't easily find the number of scholarship athletes on the roster, but if memory serves, it's in the mid-to-high 70s right now despite an allowance of 85. We're experiencing a "USC Problem." When they were dealing with the Reggie Bush penalties, they had no margin for error or injury, which is where we're at.
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 10:43 am
by Duck07
StevensTechU wrote:I couldn't easily find the number of scholarship athletes on the roster, but if memory serves, it's in the mid-to-high 70s right now despite an allowance of 85. We're experiencing a "USC Problem." When they were dealing with the Reggie Bush penalties, they had no margin for error or injury, which is where we're at.
https://web.nmsu.edu/~ogden/oregon/depthchart.html
ChileDuck says 74 scholarship, 45 walk-on. We have 28 JR and SR on scholarship. If you take transfers Tabari Hines and Kano Dillon out, we have 7 SRs on scholarship.
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 11:09 am
by greenyellow
Duck07 wrote:StevensTechU wrote:I couldn't easily find the number of scholarship athletes on the roster, but if memory serves, it's in the mid-to-high 70s right now despite an allowance of 85. We're experiencing a "USC Problem." When they were dealing with the Reggie Bush penalties, they had no margin for error or injury, which is where we're at.
https://web.nmsu.edu/~ogden/oregon/depthchart.html
ChileDuck says 74 scholarship, 45 walk-on. We have 28 JR and SR on scholarship. If you take transfers Tabari Hines and Kano Dillon out, we have 7 SRs on scholarship.
And that's an increase over last year's 68-70 scholarship players. Next year will likely be the first year in about 5 years that they'll have close to a full team.
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 2:02 pm
by bdkipe
I tend to give weight to the trained eye, which I am not, I am just a football fan. I know some of you guys coach and have played at high levels so I respect your opinions.
Our new Oregonian beat writer (Crepea) covered the SEC for a long time and he thinks there is definitely quite a bit of talent on this team that should be winning more of their basic match-ups. Same with analysts/writers like George Wrightster, Ken Woody, Austin Meek & Tyson Alger. It's not like we are rolling out undersized, non-athletic guys that should be playing at George Fox or Linfield.
At the end of the day though, this happens all the time in college football. tOSU lost a head-scratcher to Purdue and USC under performs seemingly damn near every year and we all know the talent they recruit year after year.
Maybe it's a case of Cristobal and Arroyo learning how to coach in the P12? I mean you can't just line up, go basic and impose your will on every team you feel is undersized, even if you do it to Stanford and Washington (and you still lost the Stanford game and almost lost the UW game). Maybe they underestimated the level of fight & coaching creativity in this conference?
Re: How talented are we?
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2018 2:08 pm
by Duck07
It doesn't help either that apparently every team is playing us again like we've been undefeated in conference play for years. We've been getting everyone's best shot seemingly.