Page 1 of 1
Early draft entries
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 2:56 pm
by TualatinDuck
How can an OL that was so highly rated by PFF and an All-American selection be told by the NFL advisory committee, return to school.
Makes me think the NFL doesnt think hes as good as we do.
Re: Throck
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 3:16 pm
by TualatinDuck
NM, found the answer. If your not a projected first or second round pick, your told to go back to school.
Re: Throck
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 3:19 pm
by Tray Dub
Not sure about Throckmorton in particular, but lots of guys are great on the field in college but can't translate it into the NFL game. Most often it's size or athleticism concerns. Throck is pretty big so not sure what the issue might be there, but in general I'm rarely too surprised when star college guys aren't impressive to NFL scouts.
Re: Throck
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 3:26 pm
by maxduck
What position is he projected to play? I saw this interesting tidbit in the article about Lemieux
The College Advisory Committee tells players if they’re projected as a first or second-round pick or recommend staying in school and offensive guards typically are not drafted in the first two rounds. Last year was an anomaly, with four guards being selected in the first 50 picks.
Re: Throck
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 3:30 pm
by Phenom
Boom!
Re: Early draft entries
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 3:32 pm
by greenyellow
Herbert is likely the only one who'll for sure get a first or second round grade. Mitchell likely is a 3rd or 4th rounder at best due to his size and lack of top-end speed when compared to other WRs. Dye is the true wildcard since he's got the speed NFL teams covet for LBs in covering all the spread passing formations showing up in the league but may not have the ideal size for run defense.
Re: Early draft entries
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 4:28 pm
by karlhungis
I'll be shocked if Dye is drafted on the first day.
Re: Early draft entries
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 4:45 pm
by FlDuckFan
karlhungis wrote:I'll be shocked if Dye is drafted on the first day.
I'll be shocked if he's picked on the second day. ( so long as it's three days still.)
Re: Early draft entries
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 5:09 pm
by StevensTechU
I don't see Mitchell getting picked at all, and think Dye's ceiling is 5th round.
Edit*- Just saw that WalterFootball.com has Troy Dye as a 4th-6th rounder ... in 2020.
Re: Early draft entries
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 6:20 pm
by UofDuck
I’ve said this a few times and I’ll say it again. Dye is too slight to be in inside backer. His best work shown when he was as a freshman on the outside. He has incredible instincts that serve him better in space.
Re: Early draft entries
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 6:32 pm
by FlDuckFan
UofDuck wrote:I’ve said this a few times and I’ll say it again. Dye is too slight to be in inside backer. His best work shown when he was as a freshman on the outside. He has incredible instincts that serve him better in space.
100% Guy has been playing out of position. He tends to get lost in the wash when playing in the middle.
Re: Early draft entries
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 7:02 pm
by StevensTechU
I wonder if even the coaches know that Dye is best outside, but they play him there because there’s no one else.
Re: Early draft entries
Posted: Fri Dec 21, 2018 10:34 am
by Duck07
Honestly our best defensive prospect after this season to date is probably Justin Hollins. Jelks didn't have the kind of year we would have hoped and in a loaded DL class he's going to fall unless he's got a great workout and a team falls in love with him. Ugo will get a free trip to Nashville as a local prospect workout and could end up like Troy Hill in that he never had a great career but still finds the field next level.
An overwhelming number of College Tackles all get moved inside to Guard next level because they lack foot speed to play outside. Jonah Williams has a LOT of people all saying he's going to kick inside to Guard. I also don't think there is as much a of need to have a Premier LT anymore either. Some teams go in on the T-C-T combo and others are more focused on G-C-G and protecting up front vs on the edge. Having quality guards against pass-rushing DT's an systems that move defenders across the formation mean you just need good OL period, regardless of position. Rob Staton and his TEF (Trench Explosion Formula) has been interesting in gauging the explosive strength of OL vs DL. For example with the Titans, Lewan has a 3.55 coming out and Conklin was like 2.82. Anything above 3 is considered great as the formula finds that more DL having that high metric than OL. It's also interesting that a lot of people also think that Conklin needs to move inside to G, too.(Man I wish they had just drafted Buckner #1 in hindsight)
Its also important to NEVER use PFF as anything more than a fun tool, especially with their college grades. They literally are just guessing what they think the right grade should be for a given play regardless of what was actually called for in that specific system and they lack All-22 coverage.
Re: Early draft entries
Posted: Fri Dec 21, 2018 11:09 am
by GrandpaDuck
Duck07 wrote: ....
Its also important to NEVER use PFF as anything more than a fun tool, especially with their college grades. They literally are just guessing what they think the right grade should be for a given play regardless of what was actually called for in that specific system and they lack All-22 coverage.
PFF grades are complete crap. The grading system is bunk and the scorers are amateur, under resourced and can be extremely biased. Some of their collected stats though can be fun to look at.
I love how they use decimal points in their grades to give an impression of precision. I am looking out my window and see the tip of a rock half buried in my garden. I estimate it weighs 143.263 pounds.