Page 1 of 4
Arroyo: Should he stay or go?
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 4:49 pm
by GrantDuck
Since Arroyo has to be as good as gone who are some of the people we might look at as replacements?
Some lower tier teams that put up big points:
Ohio
Memphis
La Laff
App State
U Mass
Any other guys, NFL or otherwise that we might have take over for Arroyo?
Re: New Offensive coordinator for 2019 (possibilities)
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:05 pm
by Duck07
What makes you think that Mario is going to move on from his OC or that the move wouldn't cause Herbert to leave?
Re: New Offensive coordinator for 2019 (possibilities)
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:10 pm
by Phenom
lmao
Re: New Offensive coordinator for 2019 (possibilities)
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:11 pm
by TualatinDuck
GrantDuck wrote:Since Arroyo has to be as good as gone who are some of the people we might look at as replacements?
Some lower tier teams that put up big points:
Ohio
Memphis
La Laff
App State
U Mass
Any other guys, NFL or otherwise that we might have take over for Arroyo?
Put the bong down my friend.
Re: New Offensive coordinator for 2019 (possibilities)
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:18 pm
by Everythingsducky
Agreed. MSU is a top Flight D. This game was all about receivers that can’t catch. Maybe get a better receivers coach.
Re: New Offensive coordinator for 2019 (possibilities)
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:22 pm
by Phenom
Everythingsducky wrote:Agreed. MSU is a top Flight D. This game was all about receivers that can’t catch. Maybe get a better receivers coach.
Are receivers are definitely subpar but our RBs aren't much better. At least they're young...
Re: New Offensive coordinator for 2019 (possibilities)
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:25 pm
by Everythingsducky
Phenom wrote:Everythingsducky wrote:Agreed. MSU is a top Flight D. This game was all about receivers that can’t catch. Maybe get a better receivers coach.
Are receivers are definitely subpar but our RBs aren't much better. At least they're young...
I like them both, but would like to see CHL get more run. If not, they have to get a bruiser in there.
I'm glad we won but . .. .
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:26 pm
by picksix
Run it up the middle Arroyo has got to go!! I understand our receivers had stone hands today, but play calling was so predictable with not no imagination. There's way too much talent on this team. We are lucky Michigan State was abysmal on offense. Huge props to our defense, but we have to score points.
Re: I'm glad we won but . .. .
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:32 pm
by Everythingsducky
If the intended targets actually catch the passes, it wouldn’t be so predictable. Arroyo gets heat, but his players actually have to perform the plays he draws up. If not, it gets ugly.
Help me understand why Arroyo shouldn't be fired
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:41 pm
by pezsez1
Thread title says it all. This isn't a thread to talk about hypothetical replacements -- or to even lobby for Arroyo to be fired -- but as a Duck fan who has been dissatisfied by the predictability of our offense all season long, I honestly need help to understand the benefits of keeping Arroyo vs. letting him go.
Full disclaimer: I'm not nearly as well-versed on football Xs and Os as others on this board. That's why I'm making this thread, though -- I WANT to be talked off my ledge. I've been slow to condemn subpar coaching in the past, but in this case, I'm legit wondering whether I need to slow my roll.
Anyway, here's how I see it:
Our offense is smashmouth, but predictable. We seem easily defended by decent teams. Arroyo's offensive tendencies don't seem to flow with the personnel this team actually has. I see lots of throws to covered, stationary receivers. I see lots of runs up the middle. I see lots of reverting to low-percentage carries/dives even when the passing game is firing on all cylinders. I see conservative playcalling at the ends of halves/games... like today, at the end of the game, we basically chose to NOT try for a first down and instead give the ball back to MSU for another chance to win.
The thing that concerns me most about this style of offense is, so far, it seems easily stopped by mediocre Pac-12 teams. Yes, I know our receivers struggle at times with drops -- but it's not the drops that worry me most. We've struggled offensively even when drops aren't a problem. Usually what really seems to kill us is reverting to predictable running plays, or running into a crowd on first and second down, then going for long bombs (lower-percentage conversions) on third down. It's as if this scheme doesn't really do anything to help the players actually make plays.
Like today, I wasn't pulling my hair out because Mitchell dropped that first-half bomb in the endzone. I was more agonized by the fact we couldn't string together any kind of drive to actually move the ball down the field. We lost the field position battle for pretty much the entire second half. It's hard to worry about scoring when we struggle so mightily to even MOVE the ball -- and this isn't a new problem.
Now, this is just what I see. Here's what I ask myself when trying to rationalize it:
- Would having another stellar receiver or two on the field cause Arroyo to not lean so heavily on predictable running plays?
- Are our runningbacks simply not that good? (Kind of like how Schooler led the team in tackles a couple years ago, but was easily beaten on the depth chart by new recruits the next season?) Would those run plays be better with different RBs?
- Is our offensive line, mostly recruited under previous coaches, simply not gifted in the types of techniques/styles that Aroyyo needs?
- Is the entire offense hamstrung by our lack of a dependable backup QB?
A friend of mine today made a funny (but sad) comment -- he said watching this offense is like watching Mariota vs. Stanford when he was playing on one leg. Like, someone saw that game tape and was like, "OMG, there's the blueprint!" It's just so hard to watch.
So... what am I missing? Why might Arroyo deserve the benefit of the doubt despite his offense clearly underperforming for most of the season?
And also, why should I be hopeful that Aroyyo's offense would be better next season?
EDIT: This was meant to be a new thread, because I have no interest in discussing hypothetical replacements, but oh well.
Re: New Offensive coordinator for 2019 (possibilities)
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 7:38 pm
by OregonFan4Life
I’ll just say this:
Expectations are getting high quick, when you’re getting a top 5 recruiting class you’re expected to be towards the top. In this day in age of football in both the NCAA and NFL, you need a good high power offense to compete for a championship. Sure Bama used to win natties with 9-6 scores, but even Saban had to adjust and get a new offense. With the offensive schemes we’ve had this year, I personally don’t see that helping Oregon compete for a national championship. Sure Arroyo didn’t hurt the team like the players did today, but I don’t see how he helped the team much with this gameplan and playcalling.
With that said, I’m indifferent regarding who is OC for next year. I’m OK with Arroyo coming back but I also wouldn’t be heartbroken if we had someone else who is a “nerd” as Duck07 puts it. I do think next year he needs to be under a microscope, and if he continues to produce gameplans that opposing defenses stop easily, then it’ll be clear he isn’t the man for the job as Oregon’s Offensive Coordinator. He has way more reasons to have a successful offense than he did this year, so we better see a much improved offense.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Help me understand why Arroyo shouldn't be fired
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 8:01 pm
by Tray Dub
EDIT: This was meant to be a new thread, because I have no interest in discussing hypothetical replacements, but oh well.
Same, whether to replace him is what we really ought to be talking about.
pezsez1 wrote:Thread title says it all. This isn't a thread to talk about hypothetical replacements -- or to even lobby for Arroyo to be fired -- but as a Duck fan who has been dissatisfied by the predictability of our offense all season long, I honestly need help to understand the benefits of keeping Arroyo vs. letting him go.
Full disclaimer: I'm not nearly as well-versed on football Xs and Os as others on this board. That's why I'm making this thread, though -- I WANT to be talked off my ledge. I've been slow to condemn subpar coaching in the past, but in this case, I'm legit wondering whether I need to slow my roll.
Anyway, here's how I see it:
Our offense is smashmouth, but predictable. We seem easily defended by decent teams. Arroyo's offensive tendencies don't seem to flow with the personnel this team actually has. I see lots of throws to covered, stationary receivers. I see lots of runs up the middle. I see lots of reverting to low-percentage carries/dives even when the passing game is firing on all cylinders. I see conservative playcalling at the ends of halves/games... like today, at the end of the game, we basically chose to NOT try for a first down and instead give the ball back to MSU for another chance to win.
The thing that concerns me most about this style of offense is, so far, it seems easily stopped by mediocre Pac-12 teams. Yes, I know our receivers struggle at times with drops -- but it's not the drops that worry me most. We've struggled offensively even when drops aren't a problem. Usually what really seems to kill us is reverting to predictable running plays, or running into a crowd on first and second down, then going for long bombs (lower-percentage conversions) on third down. It's as if this scheme doesn't really do anything to help the players actually make plays.
Like today, I wasn't pulling my hair out because Mitchell dropped that first-half bomb in the endzone. I was more agonized by the fact we couldn't string together any kind of drive to actually move the ball down the field. We lost the field position battle for pretty much the entire second half. It's hard to worry about scoring when we struggle so mightily to even MOVE the ball -- and this isn't a new problem.
Now, this is just what I see. Here's what I ask myself when trying to rationalize it:
- Would having another stellar receiver or two on the field cause Arroyo to not lean so heavily on predictable running plays?
- Are our runningbacks simply not that good? (Kind of like how Schooler led the team in tackles a couple years ago, but was easily beaten on the depth chart by new recruits the next season?) Would those run plays be better with different RBs?
- Is our offensive line, mostly recruited under previous coaches, simply not gifted in the types of techniques/styles that Aroyyo needs?
- Is the entire offense hamstrung by our lack of a dependable backup QB?
A friend of mine today made a funny (but sad) comment -- he said watching this offense is like watching Mariota vs. Stanford when he was playing on one leg. Like, someone saw that game tape and was like, "OMG, there's the blueprint!" It's just so hard to watch.
So... what am I missing? Why might Arroyo deserve the benefit of the doubt despite his offense clearly underperforming for most of the season?
And also, why should I be hopeful that Aroyyo's offense would be better next season?
I agree with your approach here. It's hard to say exactly what you can attribute to a coordinator and what you can't, so it's worth thinking about. My sense is that the play-calling certainly hasn't been doing us any favors, so at best it's been in the neighborhood of average. Is it worse than average? Hard to say — how much of the blame lies on extraneous factors, like the talent of the skill position players? Mitchell was definitely good, I like Redd, but I'm not sure how many bona fide playmakers we really had out there. So might that be part of it? Yeah, it might. It might even be that our team would look downright impressive, and Arroyo look smart, if we had better players. On the other hand, maybe our guys are more talented than I realize and Arroyo is just misusing them. All I'm confident saying at this point is that while it's hard to know exactly what didn't work in a single year, if there's a pattern it'll be time to move on. That's why I think he will, and probably should, get another chance next year. It will need to be a better year for me to want to see him keep his job beyond that.
Fortunately, we do have some highly-touted guys from last year's recruiting class and this year's. Plus another year of stability under Cristobal. Those are the facts I'm gonna base my offseason hopes on.
Re: Arroyo: Should he stay or go?
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 8:37 pm
by GoDucksIn09
In 4 road games Oregon has scored 15 points in the first half. WSU we scored 0. Arizona we scored 8. Utah we scored 7 and then in our bowl game we scored 0. Today it was receivers not catching the ball. The bottom line is in those 4 games we have scored not even an average of 4 points in the first half. I don't care who you play in Division 1 college ball you are not going to win very many games with that average. Can point the fingers at the drops this game but in the other 3 road games Oregon did not even show up for in the first half. That is on the coaches. Arroyo need to go.
Re: New Offensive coordinator for 2019 (possibilities)
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 8:49 pm
by buckmarkduck
Phenom wrote:Everythingsducky wrote:Agreed. MSU is a top Flight D. This game was all about receivers that can’t catch. Maybe get a better receivers coach.
Are receivers are definitely subpar but our RBs aren't much better. At least they're young...
To bad we didn't RS Benoit, he would have been a much better option this year. CJ just lacks vision and Dye is to small. Dye might get bigger, but I'm not sure CJ can fix his vision issues.
Re: New Offensive coordinator for 2019 (possibilities)
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 9:05 pm
by greenyellow
buckmarkduck wrote:Phenom wrote:Everythingsducky wrote:Agreed. MSU is a top Flight D. This game was all about receivers that can’t catch. Maybe get a better receivers coach.
Are receivers are definitely subpar but our RBs aren't much better. At least they're young...
To bad we didn't RS Benoit, he would have been a much better option this year. CJ just lacks vision and Dye is to small. Dye might get bigger, but I'm not sure CJ can fix his vision issues.
Benoit did RS, back in 2013.