Page 1 of 1
All Coaches Team
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2019 1:26 pm
by StevensTechU
Interesting thought exercise occurred to me. If you could start Oregon football over, and pick head coach, coordinators, and position coaches from the last 20 years, who do you take? Some are obvious to me, while others are not. Thinking about who can make up for others shortcomings (playcalling vs. recruiting, recruiting vs. development) adds a layer of complexity and interest.
Here's my take:
Head Coach: Chip Kelly
Offensive Coordinator/QB Coach: Mark Helfrich
WR Coach: Matt Lubick
RB Coach: Gary Campbell.
OL Coach: Mario Cristobal
TE/ST Coach: Tom Osborne
DC/Linebackers: Jim Leavitt
DL Coach: Joe Salave'a -- This was actually really tough between Big Joe and
CB: Charles Clark
Safeties: Keith Hayward
Strength: Aaron Feld
Can I just say, head coach was really hard? Who would win-- A Mario Cristobal team with Chip Kelly as OC/QB coach, or a Chip team with Helf as OC? One has more talent and an A+ OC, while the second produced spectacular consistency. For a moment I had Cristobal (HC), Chip (OC), and Greatwood (OL) on the basis of attracting talent while still having A+ offense, but it's just so hard to overlook what Chip did and what MC hasn't yet done.
RB and DC were the easiest for me to pick.
DL was tough, but I'm not impressed with what Jerry Azzinaro is doing at UCLA right now.
There are probably guys I didn't consider and should have. Seemed weird not having Neal or Greatwood. I also think David Yost is a hell of a QB coach. I laughed at how non-deserving Scott Frost was.
Re: All Coaches Team
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2019 1:49 pm
by OregonFan4Life
I would argue Scott Frost as WR coach, our WR's were blocking and catching great under him. He wasn't as good as OC but I certainly liked him as the WR coach.
Also before he became DC Pellum was a very good LB coach, I might argue it'd be best to have him as LB coach and Leavitt as solely DC.
Re: All Coaches Team
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2019 1:55 pm
by Merganzer
StevensTechU wrote:Interesting thought exercise occurred to me. If you could start Oregon football over, and pick head coach, coordinators, and position coaches from the last 20 years, who do you take? Some are obvious to me, while others are not. Thinking about who can make up for others shortcomings (playcalling vs. recruiting, recruiting vs. development) adds a layer of complexity and interest.
Here's my take:
Head Coach: Chip Kelly
Offensive Coordinator/QB Coach: Mark Helfrich
WR Coach: Matt Lubick
RB Coach: Gary Campbell.
OL Coach: Mario Cristobal
TE/ST Coach: Tom Osborne
DC/Linebackers: Jim Leavitt
DL Coach: Joe Salave'a -- This was actually really tough between Big Joe and
CB: Charles Clark
Safeties: Keith Hayward
Strength: Aaron Feld
Can I just say, head coach was really hard? Who would win-- A Mario Cristobal team with Chip Kelly as OC/QB coach, or a Chip team with Helf as OC? One has more talent and an A+ OC, while the second produced spectacular consistency. For a moment I had Cristobal (HC), Chip (OC), and Greatwood (OL) on the basis of attracting talent while still having A+ offense, but it's just so hard to overlook what Chip did and what MC hasn't yet done.
RB and DC were the easiest for me to pick.
DL was tough, but I'm not impressed with what Jerry Azzinaro is doing at UCLA right now.
There are probably guys I didn't consider and should have. Seemed weird not having Neal or Greatwood. I also think David Yost is a hell of a QB coach. I laughed at how non-deserving Scott Frost was.
Those are some tough calls, mine has Neal at CB.
Re: All Coaches Team
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2019 2:00 pm
by maxduck
I would have to go Mario in charge with Chip as OC. Willie Lyles and lots of off the field problems tarnish Kelly's time as head coach but as OC what he did with Dennis Dixon was amazing. Braxton Burmeister would easily be a P5 quality QB with Chip as his primary coach and offensive coordinator.
Chris Petersen slips inside the 20 year window, was he a better receiver coach than Matt Lubick?
Re: All Coaches Team
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2019 2:22 pm
by FlDuckFan
Head Coach/OL Coach: Mario Cristobal
Offensive Coordinator: Chip Kelly
QB Coach: Mark Helfrich
WR Coach: Matt Lubick
RB Coach: Gary Campbell.
TE/ST Coach: Tom Osborne
DC: Jim Leavitt
DL Coach: Coach Joe ( Initially I thought Jerry Azzinaro but the team need a recruiter aside from Cristobal)
CB: Neal ( Secondary hasn't been the same since )
LB: Peter Sirmon ( He was a GA and to me that counts )
Safeties: Keith M. Heyward Jr. ( Need another recruiter, his on field results are TBD )
Strength: Aaron Feld
Thought really hard about going OC : Helfrich and QB : Yost. Cristobal with a guy like Helfrich at OC would be an amazing combo. Helfrich was a great OC and excels in that role so long as he isn't in charge of the whole rodeo I trust him.
Re: All Coaches Team
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2019 2:26 pm
by DCfeatherbutt
DC - Charlie Waters.
I know it was 22 years ago, but I’m sticking to it.
Re: All Coaches Team
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2019 3:33 pm
by GoDucksTroll
Will due respect to the people listing Charles Clark, I don't see it. He was here for one year, and a short stay at Colorado where he benefited from some upperclassmen.
HC: Mike Bellotti. Not a popular choice considering Chip is an option, but I'm going to cheat a bit. Also, Bellotti is a guy like Cristobal who would adapt to whatever the landscape is. Never afraid to change his offense, would hire recruiters.
OC: Chip Kelly. There's the cheating, but if not Chip then...
QB: Jeff Tedford. QB whisperer.
RB: Gary Campbell, in the biggest no brainer.
WR: Scott Frost. Our WRs were solid with him, obviously motivates his guys.
DL: Big Joe? Anyone that's not Ron Aiken will suffice.
DC: Either Leavitt or Aliotti. I didn't realize how much I loved Allowalotti until I had to see Don Pellum and Brady Hoke try to call plays.
LB: Don Pellum.
DB: John Neal. Fantastic talent developer, until he became older, bitter, and stopped bothering to recruit or coach.
I'd fill out the staff with excellent recruiters. Find a job for Heyward/Arroyo/Williams, some young guys that can recruit.
Re: All Coaches Team
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2019 4:35 pm
by woundedknees
Small sample size, but early in Bellotti's tenure as HC, Charley Waters flashed the potential to make this list.
Sadly, the passing of his oldest son shortened his time at Oregon, and lead him to resign, and move back to Texas.
(Cody Waters was a first team all state kicker in football, concurrent with the same level in soccer... Incredibly talented, and would likely have become a Duck)