Page 1 of 1
Little Margin For Error Now (Why We Need An 8 Team Playoff)
Posted: Sun Sep 01, 2019 3:18 pm
by SuperDuck
Last night's loss hurt, in more ways than one.
Personally, I think that by games 3-4 this is going to be a very good team, and even better afterward. The problem isn't the one loss. A one loss team from a TD in the final seconds "shouldn't" keep a team from playoff consideration. However, one more loss would not only virtually eliminate the Ducks from playoff contention, but even running the table and finishing 12-1 might not be enough.
An unbeaten or one loss Alabama, Clemson, Ohio State and probably Oklahoma/Texas would get the nod over Oregon, simply because of the perception of the strength of the Pac-12.
Another concerning possibility is even if we do lose one conference game, and that one loss is to a Pac-12 North team like UW, WSU or Stanford, they'd automatically hold the tie-breaker for the conference championship. That team would have to lose twice because of their head-to-head win against us.
Would a New Year's Day Bowl still be a possibility? Yes, but some have conference tie in's in those games would be a consideration, as well. Example, if OU or Texas made it to the playoff, the loser would likely go to the Fiesta Bowl, assuming that they had no more than 2 losses. But what if Notre Dame also goes 10-2 or 11-1?
As much as I DO prefer the current system vs the old BCS, I still don't think it's fair. Every Power-5 conference champion should be included, no exceptions. I think it sucks that losing ONE close game could define your entire season.
My two cents.
Re: Little Margin For Error Now (Why We Need An 8 Team Playo
Posted: Sun Sep 01, 2019 3:31 pm
by GoDucksIn09
There is no room for error when we have an offensive coordinator who thinks the players have to perform perfectly to cover up his inability to adjust to what the other teams defense is doing. He does not get it and considering he is making 6 figures I doubt he really cares what the outcome is. There is enough blame to go around. Herbert and Addison need to take their share of the blame. I do not get a sr quarterback throwing the ball out of the end zone where nobody can catch it with no time on the clock.
Re: Little Margin For Error Now (Why We Need An 8 Team Playo
Posted: Sun Sep 01, 2019 3:37 pm
by OregonFan4Life
Whatever, Oregon lost, if they don’t make the playoffs it’s their own fault, not the playoff committee’s fault. Same in 2001 and 2012, Oregon lost at home to stanford both seasons when they were the much better team, nobody but Oregon to blame. If you wanna make the playoffs, don’t lose to inferior opponents.
Re: Little Margin For Error Now (Why We Need An 8 Team Playo
Posted: Sun Sep 01, 2019 8:52 pm
by GoDucksTroll
OregonFan4Life wrote:Whatever, Oregon lost, if they don’t make the playoffs it’s their own fault, not the playoff committee’s fault. Same in 2001 and 2012, Oregon lost at home to stanford both seasons when they were the much better team, nobody but Oregon to blame. If you wanna make the playoffs, don’t lose to inferior opponents.
100% this. The playoff is reserved for elite teams, and unless we’re 12-1 at the end the year we have no business discussing it.
Re: Little Margin For Error Now (Why We Need An 8 Team Playo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 6:22 am
by GoDucksIn09
We have road games against Washington, USC and Stanford, and ASU I think. Who in their right mind given what we have seen from Oregon the last 2 years plus on the road thinks Oregon wins all of those. I certainly don't. I said before game one we go 9-3 and all three of the losses were on the road. I still say we lose to Washington and USC. Nothing on Saturday makes me feel any different. This team can not perform perfectly and we have Arroyo who can not adjust to teams making adjustments in the second half. Until he is gone, we will continue to lose close games on the road. I hope Cristobal realizes it soon.
Re: Little Margin For Error Now (Why We Need An 8 Team Playo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 7:34 am
by droop10
GoDucksIn09 wrote:There is no room for error when we have an offensive coordinator who thinks the players have to perform perfectly to cover up his inability to adjust to what the other teams defense is doing. He does not get it and considering he is making 6 figures I doubt he really cares what the outcome is. There is enough blame to go around. Herbert and Addison need to take their share of the blame. I do not get a sr quarterback throwing the ball out of the end zone where nobody can catch it with no time on the clock.
Awful take all around. Why would Arroyo not care about the outcome? Because he makes 6 figures, he doesn’t have the drive to do well, so he can continue to grow in his field? That’s just like the annoying take I always see about the basketball team not caring every time they don’t perform well. It’s entirely possible for someone to care about what they do and have an off day. That being said, Arroyo came in with a good game plan and some wrinkles. Eventually Auburn figured out that they could just play man coverage on the receivers that were left, and they could create zero separation. What’s this magical play call you expect from Arroyo that would suddenly make create all this separation? They tried to go deep multiple times, but there was absolutely nobody open.
How often do you think Herbert practices the 30 yard Hail Mary pass? I had a bad feeling the second I saw the returner get tackled that close, as I thought a Hail Mary would have had a better chance from 10-15 yards further back. That senior quarterback should be more well equipped to throw a pass he’s never had to make though! He tried to throw a jump ball from close, and overshot it a bit. Ridiculous to blame him. He played a hell of a game. You should be thrilled the game was that close. You predicted Auburn would blow the Ducks out! If anything, they greatly exceeded your expectations.
Re: Little Margin For Error Now (Why We Need An 8 Team Playo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 7:51 am
by Duck07
Not once did that make me think we need to force a bunch of amateur athletes to play another game to fatten the pockets of amateur athletics administrators.
What it did make me think is why do we do these (non-)neutral site road games where we let our opponents fan base have the easy trip (or where we know we're going to be vastly outnumbered)? I say we should be playing a game in Hawaii to start the season off every other year and make them travel out West.