Page 1 of 2
Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 7:42 am
by nogerO
His play calling in the first half was a big improvement over last year. In the second half it disappeared. You have to ask why? I believe he was told to go conservative. You can't change my mind on that and I wish someone from the green and gold Kool-aid fish rag know as the Red Guard needs to ask the head coach who called the plays in the second half. I think
Arroyo will be fine if he is allowed to do his job. JMTC
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 7:54 am
by FlDuckFan
I wasn't happy with the play calling either but on second watch, The lack of quality WR's cut's your plays down a lot. In the second half Auburn made an adjustment and loaded the box and played man across the board. Aside from the few quick passes and dump offs there was no body to throw to and running the ball against a loaded box when you only have 5 lineman and a pair of TE's who aren't known for blocking is very difficult. You have to think, there were guys who practiced with the 3rd team all summer getting significant minutes. As for blaming Mario for getting in Arroyo's ear , unless you have evidence it happened I doubt it's the case.
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 8:05 am
by nogerO
FlDuckFan wrote:I wasn't happy with the play calling either but on second watch, The lack of quality WR's cut's your plays down a lot. In the second half Auburn made an adjustment and loaded the box and played man across the board. Aside from the few quick passes and dump offs there was no body to throw to and running the ball against a loaded box when you only have 5 lineman and a pair of TE's who aren't known for blocking is very difficult. You have to think, there were guys who practiced with the 3rd team all summer getting significant minutes. As for blaming Mario for getting in Arroyo's ear , unless you have evidence it happened I doubt it's the case.
Agree about being hamstrung re: wr's. However we actually ran a screen for good yardage once. Why once when they had their ears pinned back and were coming after JH? Respectfully disagree about whether our head coach isn't influencing the play calling. Just trying to figure out why our play calling in the second half ALWAYS seems to be ultra conservative. You think Arroyo does that all by his lonesome? Just sayin...
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 8:23 am
by Phenom
His play calling was good throughout the entire game considering the personnel he has at this disposal. The issue is the mentality. We went conservative way too early. I don’t know how much influence Mario has over that.
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 8:27 am
by FlDuckFan
nogerO wrote:FlDuckFan wrote:I wasn't happy with the play calling either but on second watch, The lack of quality WR's cut's your plays down a lot. In the second half Auburn made an adjustment and loaded the box and played man across the board. Aside from the few quick passes and dump offs there was no body to throw to and running the ball against a loaded box when you only have 5 lineman and a pair of TE's who aren't known for blocking is very difficult. You have to think, there were guys who practiced with the 3rd team all summer getting significant minutes. As for blaming Mario for getting in Arroyo's ear , unless you have evidence it happened I doubt it's the case.
Agree about being hamstrung re: wr's. However we actually ran a screen for good yardage once. Why once when they had their ears pinned back and were coming after JH? Respectfully disagree about whether our head coach isn't influencing the play calling. Just trying to figure out why our play calling in the second half ALWAYS seems to be ultra conservative.
You think Arroyo does that all by his lonesome? Just sayin...
Yes. I do. The 4th and Inches is 100% Mario but the rest is Arroyo. The gameplan the whole game was conservative. Taking shots down the field only works if a guy can get open enough to warrant the ball. Go rewatch it the calls were there the execution by the players was not. Could they have used more HB screens? maybe Auburn was sending 5-6 at a time giving Herbs and the offense little to no time to set the screen up. When they're bringing pressure like that a stupid play call would be for something similar to a reverse it would more than likely result in a loss of 10+ yards.
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 9:40 am
by Duck07
Blame whoever is adamant we should be running the pistol ffs. Still such a stupid offense that's only worked at one place, in the WAC.
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 9:43 am
by buckmarkduck
Duck07 wrote:Blame whoever is adamant we should be running the pistol ffs. Still such a stupid offense that's only worked at one place, in the WAC.
Agree the pistol sucks. Go back to the shot gun, and if Mastro can't get more than 3.8 yes a carry from his group, he may be the problem. His Pistol, his RBs.
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 9:45 am
by FlDuckFan
Duck07 wrote:Blame whoever is adamant we should be running the pistol ffs. Still such a stupid offense that's only worked at one place, in the WAC.
Not a fan of the mesh with the RB when running a give/pull but other than that it's not much different than shotgun. Most of the time Oregon has the rb move to the side of the QB and into a more traditional shotgun set anyway.
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 2:24 pm
by vegasdom
Don't call out Arroyo? That's a joke right? Get rid of him and his stupid offense. We should poach the rest of Boise's coaches.
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 2:49 pm
by droop10
vegasdom wrote:Don't call out Arroyo? That's a joke right? Get rid of him and his stupid offense. We should poach the rest of Boise's coaches.
You realize the pistol isn’t Arroyo’s offense right? If anything, they brought in Mastro to help implement the offense as he helped pioneer it. I’m not a huge fan of the pistol, but they don’t run a ton out of it.
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 5:03 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
In all the Arroyo criticism I have yet to see a legitimate breakdown of what he does so wrong. Of course there are poor play calls here and there but that usually isn’t the insinuation; it’s that his offensively philosophy and play calling are fundamentally flawed. I have yet to see any real evidence of that. Any in-depth breakdown of our offensive flaws typically reveals mostly poor execution by players, and general lack of ability. Our WRs inabilities to create separation, for example.
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 5:19 pm
by buckmarkduck
dthomas=ddixon wrote:In all the Arroyo criticism I have yet to see a legitimate breakdown of what he does so wrong. Of course there are poor play calls here and there but that usually isn’t the insinuation; it’s that his offensively philosophy and play calling are fundamentally flawed. I have yet to see any real evidence of that. Any in-depth breakdown of our offensive flaws typically reveals mostly poor execution by players, and general lack of ability. Our WRs inabilities to create separation, for example.
I can only judge him based on the numbers as a OC. And at every job, the offence never improves. Hope that changes.
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Mon Sep 02, 2019 11:14 pm
by vegasdom
dthomas=ddixon wrote:In all the Arroyo criticism I have yet to see a legitimate breakdown of what he does so wrong. Of course there are poor play calls here and there but that usually isn’t the insinuation; it’s that his offensively philosophy and play calling are fundamentally flawed. I have yet to see any real evidence of that. Any in-depth breakdown of our offensive flaws typically reveals mostly poor execution by players, and general lack of ability. Our WRs inabilities to create separation, for example.
What a load of BS. Stop the WR blame game. How much separation are you going to get in 5 yards? 3rd and 7, lets throw a 4 yard pass and blame the WRs for not breaking 3 tackles. They rose to the occasion(excluding Addison). The play calling is terribly predictable. Has he ever heard of play action pass? How about going deep a few times to give the defensive backfield something to think about. Did you know Auburn was susceptible to deep pass plays last year and they returned a weaker secondary. Its not all his fault but it would be nice to start the next game with 3 timeouts.
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 12:29 am
by Everythingsducky
vegasdom wrote:dthomas=ddixon wrote:In all the Arroyo criticism I have yet to see a legitimate breakdown of what he does so wrong. Of course there are poor play calls here and there but that usually isn’t the insinuation; it’s that his offensively philosophy and play calling are fundamentally flawed. I have yet to see any real evidence of that. Any in-depth breakdown of our offensive flaws typically reveals mostly poor execution by players, and general lack of ability. Our WRs inabilities to create separation, for example.
What a load of BS. Stop the WR blame game. How much separation are you going to get in 5 yards? 3rd and 7, lets throw a 4 yard pass and blame the WRs for not breaking 3 tackles. They rose to the occasion(excluding Addison). The play calling is terribly predictable. Has he ever heard of play action pass? How about going deep a few times to give the defensive backfield something to think about. Did you know Auburn was susceptible to deep pass plays last year and they returned a weaker secondary. Its not all his fault but it would be nice to start the next game with 3 timeouts.
Agreed. It’s not like this is some local media shenanigans. National media barked about the conservatism in this game, that has long been a gripe of this offense. Any semblance of a trick play now and then to keep the defense guessing? Fake anything? Couldn’t help but think of the 4th and short attempt, and in my mind I was thinking ‘wish this was an option/pitch’ as the D was sucked in, something that the defense probably wouldn’t suspect. No freaking imagination, just regurgitated boredom.
Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo
Posted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 5:17 am
by GoDucksIn09
How many halves of football over the last 2 seasons has our offense scored 8 points or less. How many of those games where we had a non existent offense have we won. I can think of only one that we won. That is beyond pathetic. Why is this even remotely acceptable.